Sign in

Defiantly Alice

@mechanival.bsky.social
252 followers 168 following 295 posts

Glasgow based lover of worldbuilding, and anything that tells a story. Can often be found several wiki pages deep in lore creation. 🏳️‍⚧️ 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 (she/her)

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
transmetalmum.bsky.social @transmetalmum.bsky.social · 20/09/2026
Sandy Peggie's daughter is crying about her hateful mother having an awful time. Living it up on holiday, hosted by JKR, adored by the press. Not a hard life at all. Dr Beth Upton is the one who had an awful time. Leaving the country, hiding away and being vilified and attacked wherever she goes.
09720
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Sarah Clarke - Not your doll @damselindystopia.northsky.social · 20/09/2026
It frustrates me so deeply that cis people simply cannot concieve of transphobia as something serious.
141271210
Defiantly Alice @mechanival.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
Naomi Cunningham has become so unhinged about trans people that she's making Sarah Phillimore look reasonable. Taking pictures of - or filming - people in a public toilet with the explicit purpose of posting online to shame them is almost certainly illegal Naomi.
0285
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Philippa East (Author) @philippaeast.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
The NHS Wales JCC subcommittee on Quality, Safety and Outcomes have now released their “Incidents and Concerns” report that was considered at the August 26 meeting, following which all Wales gender reforming surgeries were immediately halted. jcc.nhs.wales/committees/q... 1/
jcc.nhs.wales
715565
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Elizabeth Taylor @elizabethtaylor47.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
I realise this is a clear troll but this is just incorrect. Caroline cossey ans April Ashley used women’s spaces in the 70s. When the UK government defended itself (and lost) at ECtHR they defended themselves by saying that trans women were accommodated in female hospital wards and prisons
27210
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Elizabeth Taylor @elizabethtaylor47.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
I realise I repeat this on like a daily basis, but please me restate it again - the ‘status quo’ in the UK for decades was trans inclusion. What we have now is not really precedented for a 21st century democracy.
222053
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Mags Campbell @magscampbell.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
Folk criticising trans people in the US for being pissed off at Democrats for shoving them under the bus while chasing more right-wing votes, maybe take a look at the UK. Brits were convinced to get rid of the Tories at any cost & we've had 2 years of the nastiest anti-trans Labour government.
45715
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
theotheories.bsky.social @theotheories.bsky.social · 04/09/2026
Looks like there is genuinely nothing more than in the nick Wallis article. They've cancelled everyone's surgery indefinitely because one transphobe complained. the Welsh service sees and refers more patients than English clinics. So all those surgeries are cancelled. No patient safety concerns.
1226
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Jacey is a suitable combo of my actual name for privacy reasons @spacegrace.bsky.social · 04/09/2026
Welcome to the UK, where using the magic word ‘trans’, allows you to skip standard process with no evidence of harm or wrongdoing. Just send a complaint! We all know they wouldn’t take the same action for any other form of healthcare. @plaidcymru.bsky.social cavuhb.nhs.wales/our-services...
What evidence is there that patients were referred inappropriately?
At this stage, it is not known if patients have been referred inappropriately. The purpose of the Independent Clinical Review is to assess this.Have any patients undergone surgery inappropriately?
At this stage, the NWJCC has not identified any patients who have undergone surgery inappropriately.
However, there are cases where patients have been referred into the surgical pathway but have not gone on to have surgery, including where NHS England providers have identified that referral criteria had not been met. It is also recognised that concerns have been raised by some patients about the referral
process.
The purpose of the current review is to better understand these concerns and provide assurance that patients are being appropriately supported, assessed and referred, and that the necessary clinical governance arrangements are in place.Does this mean patients may have come to harm?
No immediate patient safety concerns have been identified by the NWJCC, and therefore they are not concluding that patients have come to harm.
However, concerns have been raised through complaints to the NWJCC, correspondence, and other information received about the gender affirming surgery pathway. As a precautionary measure, referrals, surgical assessments, and surgery are paused while further review work is undertaken.
These prompt actions have been taken to ensure any potential risks
are identified and addressed as quickly as possible, and that patients continue to receive safe and high-quality care.
730385
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
sasha @2damntrans.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
A reminder that this all started circa 2015/16 with “legitimate concerns” over some small and trivial reforms to the Gender Recognition Act. That evolved into transgendercide. We were told by many at the time that we were too ferocious in our response, but evidently we did not go hard enough.
29229
Defiantly Alice @mechanival.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
Every time I see an American claim that trans people kill their own support, I think about how in the UK, self ID polled majority support until the media attacked it. When Labour accepted self ID should die, we were told to let them win, it would get better. Now we have a bathroom ban. Fuck you.
141676301
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Standplaats Kraków could really use some cash! @standplaatskrk.pl · 10/09/2026
askinnyblackman:  "republicans will be like "good news, everyone! we have passed legislation that will make it legal for us to shoot you in the chest" and dems will respond with "we have listened to the SCIENTISTS and the SCIENCE says that being shot in the chest is bad! and that is why we are proposing a BOLD counter-legislation that would provide FREE bulletproof vests to individuals making less than $30,000 per year!" and leftists are like "um yeah I guess if those are our only options I'll pick the dems but why is it legal for you to shoot us in the chest? maybe they shouldn't be able to do that in the first place? where's that option?" and dems will be like "shut up and vote blue no matter who you stupid fucking hippie" and then you find out that the private company that makes the bullets and the vests funds both parties"
31040419
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
ICE must be destroyed 🏳️‍⚧️🏴 @miawong.bsky.social · 12/09/2026
This is the goal of bathroom bills: to drive trans people from public life so we can be exploited and exterminated in the shadows Moreover, ICE must be destroyed
4602155
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Tristan Grayford @tristangrayford.scot · 12/09/2026
Scottish Greens - "Why can't you just be normal?"
GPEW Internal Politics - *Screams*
Meme format
0306
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Alistair Davidson @moh-kohn.eurosky.social · 08/09/2026
Me when racist protests started in Possil: "I lived in Possil, this will be loyalists and gangsters" 1 million Facebook accounts I've never seen before: "There's a Celtic fan there! You never lived in Possil!" Daily Record today: "Here's a list of the loyalists and gangsters" Vindicated! 💀
0298
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
George Monbiot @georgemonbiot.bsky.social · 28/08/2026
I know this isn't terrorism. You know this isn't terrorism. The authorities know this isn't terrorism. But, once again, they have labelled protesters "terrorists", as part of the long-running programme to ensure that no one dares protest about anything any more. www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026...
theguardian.com
Seven charged with damaging Trump’s Scottish golf course accused of ‘terrorist connection’
Course at Donald Trump’s Turnberry resort was painted with words ‘Gaza is not 4 sale’ and clubhouse was sprayed with graffiti
13534501492
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Cathal Malone @cathalmalone.bsky.social · 27/08/2026
The excuse here seems to be that as a full General, he automatically gets full state honours. Bullshit. This should be the official end of Serbian accession talks; they've been on their last legs for a decade.
23714
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Small Robots @smolrobots.bsky.social · 27/08/2026
Hot Rod, from The Transformers: The Movie, with a speech bubble underneath him so it looks like the quoted post is being said by him.
728975
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
geoffrey @parsnip.bsky.social · 27/08/2026
obviously a massive scandal for the university and for belgium, but equally a scandal that the president of the united states intervened in academic affairs in europe on behalf of a white supremacist race scientist, though it's likely to be treated as a non-story
729477
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
GeekOnALeash 🏳️‍⚧️ @geekonaleash.co.uk · 26/08/2026
Well, this was inevitable. Forstater is now using her own case to argue that racism should/is protected as a philosophical belief 🤮
"Even comments which are “serious, severely hurtful and 
prejudicial”are covered by Article 10 of the European Convention on Human rights (freedom of expression) which doesn't mean absolute freedom of expression in a situations, but employers should treat beliefs equally.

As the judge said in my case even beliefs that are profoundly distressing and offensive to many others are beliefs that must be tolerated in a pluralist society.""Cofnas's hereditarian belief has already been found to be "worthy of respect in a democratic society" by a court in the UK. 

Though not binding in Belgium, but its anti-discrimination law is based on the same principle.

Still it's better to have a good job than a good legal case. 

Ghent uni could string out the suspension - the process is the punishment.

If there are calls for a staff member to be discriminated against because of their beliefs the answer should be No (unless the belief falls below the v low threshold for belief discrimination), not "oh well if 2000 people object..."
43816253
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Mo Ryan @moryan.bsky.social · 25/08/2026
every billionaire & tech mogul, they all want to be adored & celebrated without doing the things Dolly did with a fraction of the power & money. What she had, she gave away. I'm sure she was comfortable (& that's good!). But she just relentlessly helped. It's not that difficult. Love. Care. Help. 💚🌸
1188862403
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
QueerAF @wearequeeraf.com · 25/08/2026
Human rights experts warn the EHRC code of practice "risks institutionalising discrimination against transgender and gender-diverse persons"  Understand more: www.wearequeeraf.com/understand-the…
The UN has again warned the UK against the implementation of the EHRC code of practice, which recommends the segregation of Trans+ people
Human rights experts appointed by the United Nations Human Rights Council have warned the UK's EHRC code of practice "risks institutionalising discrimination against transgender and gender-diverse persons" - UN OHCHR
0295
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Ashleeee 🌊🪭 @reactiveashley.cat · 23/08/2026
1/🧵 The moment the EHRC begins “enforcement” against trans-inclusive service providers is the moment it gets to Strasbourg. Mary-Ann can say whatever she want; I dare her to actually enforce it. This relates to effective domestic remedy.
418732
Defiantly Alice @mechanival.bsky.social · 22/08/2026
Being charitable and perhaps a little less jaded than some of my peers - this is a post that Stephen needed to elaborate more on before posting. He doesn't say what his position actually is - it's just that right now, assuming the worst implications of this... Usually isn't wrong. 1/2
100
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Dr Eleanor Janega @goingmedieval.bsky.social · 15/08/2026
Universities are riddled with old white guys who have sexually assaulted their students, but still get a paycheck while not teaching. You won't hear about that.
565697
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Dr Eleanor Janega @goingmedieval.bsky.social · 15/08/2026
This entire disgusting situation with Arday has shown the horrible priorities of a society built for the ruling class. Our press isn't free, and it is used solely and exclusively to pursue the interests of the ruling class which owns it.
101423320
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Dmitry Grozoubinski @explaintrade.com · 15/08/2026
It's me, a Telegraph columnist, taking a break screaming bloody murder about fairness in the women's sports I wouldn't be caught dead watching to wax lyrical about academic integrity in sociology, a field I consider to be fake, at institutions I consider to be communist indoctrination centers.
304935935
Defiantly Alice @mechanival.bsky.social · 10/08/2026
The most absurd thing about the legal reasoning behind the UK's descent into transphobia is that it rests on the idea that the Equality Act was always meant to be interpreted this way, and not just activists, but the EHRC, the lower courts, and Parilament itself have always been wrong about it. 1/3
131
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
👻madeline bOoOoOoOodent👻 @oldenoughtosay.com · 10/08/2026
okay, here’s my take on the dobby’s grave thing: this country has a long and established history of memorialising popular fiction in society. Have you been to Whitby or Baker Street station recently? That part is fine. The problem is that the gov’t and media are allowing JKR to push transphobia.
1350852
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
earend | making 🐻🛡️⚠️ @earend.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
The "Jason figured it out meme" from the Goodplace, but the captions are:

LinkedIn figured it out?

LinkedIn?  This is a real low point.
58158065077
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
lastpositivist.bsky.social @lastpositivist.bsky.social · 31/07/2026
The thing about this is - the fact that this is even a goal for them makes it clear that SM are flat out just in the business of trying to humiliate a social minority. They just hate trans people, there's not more to their campaign than animus.
516333
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Stub Buns @stubbuns.bsky.social · 31/07/2026
Question for Amnesty. Trans rights have regressed in the UK. That’s undeniable. The organisations you are apologising to have celebrated these rights being eroded. Are you really that weak that you can’t in good faith defend calling them anti-rights? Because they very clearly fucking are.
435672
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Elizabeth Taylor @elizabethtaylor47.bsky.social · 31/07/2026
I think we need to actually restate how wild it is how much anti trans activism there is, and the extreme degree. We're getting two high court decisions on trans rights today alone that have huge consequences for trans people's lives (strip searching and puberty blockers). In one DAY
4383116
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Josh Wilcock @justjoshingf1.bsky.social · 19/07/2026
What’s that? Argentinians started a fight and lost?
2394
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Suzanne 🇵🇸 she/her @rummlie.bsky.social · 16/07/2026
Just so I'm clear, if you phone up Rowling's helpline, you are at risk of having your phone call tweeted out to her 14 million odd followers for a ridicule party?
343720889
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Lazzie BOO!! 😱 @lazzieb.bsky.social · 22/06/2026
I think there's a view which circulates in some quarters, perhaps even especially on the socdem left, that mere mention of trans rights is somehow electoral anathema. I don't know. I don't think so, because how else will we marginalise the support of our eradication? It's the moral thing to do.
1376
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
𝔐𝔞𝔤𝔫𝔢𝔱𝔰 🧲 @magnets.eurosky.social · 22/06/2026
we had the financial crash then elected the tories. labour has only changed PM once. it's a Tory problem
2183
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
jamelle @jamellebouie.net · 14/06/2026
genuinely speechless here.
1265090889
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Lee Hurley @hleehurley.com · 11/06/2026
My gf has roped a load of churches into getting their members to collect a load of food that can then be distributed to those who need it across Belfast. Many are afraid to leave their houses, even to get food. People have been delivering food to strangers since this started.
14573981549
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Jordan @jordanpfot.bsky.social · 09/06/2026
This was a particularly revealing moment. Stephenson says that it’s not on service providers to police toilets but Kirkpatrick says that service providers have the obligation to uphold the law - when Sarah Owen presses them on how those things are reconcilable they just flounder.
723081
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
The Newromancer @tehsamantha.bsky.social · 09/06/2026
This is only a problem if you can only conceive of sex as being determined by a single feature or quality There are plenty of different frameworks which define sex in more varied ways which can better provide for the differing needs of everyone
161
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
phragmosis @phragmosisjones.bsky.social · 09/06/2026
context: new head of UK Equality and Human Rights Commission appears to argue in parliament that it's okay to treat trans women abuse survivors like shit, because we already treat cis women abuse survivors like shit, so it's not discrimination 💁‍♀️
02510
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Rose Schmits @roseschmits.bsky.social · 09/06/2026
A major component of the EHRC expecting “trans people to simply follow The Rules” is that it explicitly positions trans people as illegal transgressors by continuing our lives as we were
833067
Defiantly Alice @mechanival.bsky.social · 10/06/2026
Goodwin v UK was *explicitly* about how Goodwin's employer discovering she was trans led to a violation of Article 8. The GRA therefore was created in part to prevent employers outing trans staff. The idea they now *have* to do so for pay gap data, and that isn't a breach despite Goodwin? Nonsense.
150
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
Rose Schmits @roseschmits.bsky.social · 09/06/2026
Absolute scenes as they have to keep saying with a straight face that “trans people thought they had rights” its just so so openly corrupt and bullshit all the way
112020
Reposted by Defiantly Alice
spooky dickgirl @eigenvectrix.northsky.social · 09/06/2026
Ran into this argument in Karleen Gribble’s work last week and it’s very obviously an attempt to both erase trans people’s economic oppression and use foul play to make the gender pay gap appear to close
3275