Sign in

Joshua Cherniss

@jcherniss.bsky.social
864 followers 378 following 373 posts

Political theorist. Worker in the "Realm of Concepts." Book accumulator. Ethical worrier. Teaching at Georgetown University since 2014.

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Kevin M. Kruse @kevinmkruse.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
I'm serious when I say I've lost track of all the recent revelations of literal Nazis working in high-level positions in Republican congressional campaigns and I would very much appreciate a journalist who took the time to detail as many of them as can fit into an article.
9768101615
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Hassinator @hassinator.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
a great letter in the times today. perhaps worth sharing in these troubled times. #RNLI #heroes
4059872392
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 31/08/2026
Why "Cold War liberalism" (or, some of the thinkers associated with that label) is worth revisiting today. With many thanks to @jkuznicki.bsky.social and his colleagues at liberalism.org. www.liberalism.org/p/the-hard-w...
liberalism.org
The Hard-Won Lessons of Cold War Liberalism
Twentieth-century liberal intellectuals stood firm against the totalizing ideologies of left and right. Their insights remain valuable today.
033
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 31/07/2026
I think this is clearly correct, and important; naturally, I also like to see it as vindicating *my* analysis. www.illiberalism.org/the-ruthless...
illiberalism.org
The Ruthlessness is the Point: Trumpism and the Ethical Allure of Ruthlessness illiberalism.org |
Joshua Cherniss on the ethos and ethics of ruthlessness, and how they've come to be embodied in Trumpism.
010
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Nicholas Grossman @nicholasgrossman.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
The Trump admin had a real theory of war: Put on a show of toughness, tell people how manly you are, disdain law, do war crimes, and you win. Earlier losses came from leaders too "weak" to do that. It was a very stupid theory. But they espoused it a lot, really seem to believe it, and acted on it.
1092566664
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
American Political Science Review @apsrjournal.bsky.social · 16/07/2026
From our FirstView: The Politics of Privilege: Discrimination, Monopolized Social Rights, and Reform by @andysabl.bsky.social. doi.org/10.1017/S000...
045
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 24/06/2026
So much winning!
000
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
I support Somali-Americans @adamrothman.bsky.social · 24/06/2026
Greenwatergate
2025032
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Zach D Roberts @zdroberts.bsky.social · 24/06/2026
Urgent policing at the reflecting pool in DC. A tourist touched the water.
1952024445
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 16/06/2026
Many of us fall into the fallacy of assuming that, if grotesquely venal, selfish and cruel figures achieve success (political or financial), they must also be very clever. Trump and Netanyahu are salutary reminders that quite often the opposite is true.
042
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Aaron Ross Powell @aaronrosspowell.com · 14/06/2026
A multicultural city of millions experiencing and sharing joy together is the quintessential symbol of why the far right's worldview is such a sad failure, one that can occasionally gain temporary power, but will always be a historical failure clung to only by failed people. Diversity is strength.
15011
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Sarah Kay @k-interarma.bsky.social · 13/06/2026
Aerial PARTIAL view of the anti racist, anti fascist crowd in Belfast right now. City Hall to the left for scale. This - this is the real Belfast. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.
8488582240
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Schooley @schooley.bsky.social · 13/06/2026
It's not often that a living man gets such a vivid preview of how he will be mourned.
8357861009
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Stef "inclusion is a human right" Christensen @wikisteff.bsky.social · 13/06/2026
America waits for its 250th Anniversary to begin with a symbolic end to the Imperial Presidency and a restoration of both the rule of law and democracy.
Construction workers building more scaffolding above the 6th level to stabilize the structure so that when they remove Donald Trump's name from the Kennedy Center, the torques don't make the structure unstable.
10573104
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Scott Smith @canaansdad1987.bsky.social · 12/06/2026
4.3 million people have already been dropped from Snap benefits and with 14 million children already living in food insecure households they have made food pantries working past capacity. This can't continue. Vote blue everyone. #USDemocracy www.pbs.org/newshour/sho...
pbs.org
Millions lose SNAP benefits as One Big Beautiful Bill’s stricter requirements kick in
SNAP enrollment has fallen sharply nationwide since the passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act last summer. More than 3.5 million people have lost access to the food assistance, as states implement...
621305762
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Gayton Gomez @gpgomez.bsky.social · 13/06/2026
It took them less time to take down the East Wing
504975678
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
ellie lockhart (she/they) @eleanor.lockhart.contact · 04/06/2026
Who could possibly have anticipated the shocking revelation that Graham Platner may have harmed women? Who among us might possibly have predicted this? Surely no one. Surely this is utterly unforeseeable, with zero warning signs
513320
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 02/06/2026
Indeed -- but there is a way to stop him. It's impeachment; and the fact that it is out of the question -- and that even with a flipped House, the Senate is unlikely to convict -- suggests something has gone deeply wrong with our system.
000
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Well, I'd say there are several really big questions that need answering, which is one reason why making distinctions is helpful! (And I'm glad that among other things, you bring out some of those distinctions ...)
010
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
(or for that matter Weber's idea of modernity-as-rationalization), which seem like a kind of historicism (though not one in which any human agent, individual or collective, exercises -- to borrow a phrase from Mansfield -- rational control.)
010
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
(Eric in conclusion raises the question of the relationship between value pluralism and historicism. I wonder if he has thoughts on the proximity of some sort of pluralism nascent in Smith, and stadial theories of history ...
120
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
it seems like the value-pluralist objection isn’t incidental or eccentric, but rather central after all.
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
But if the worry/objection concerning history and meaning has to do not w/collective agency but with the idea of rendering human experience coherent/comprehensible in terms of some single universal meaning (that is, not just freedom but "reason" in history) ...
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
So, “humanity” may not be brought into being by Geist's coming-to-consciousness-of-self; but by being threatened by, and the only agent that can address, the climate crisis. But that may still smack too much of the sort of “survivalism” that I take it we’re supposed to overcome!)
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
(One option: the view that suprapersonal historical agents are not “given” prior to collective action, but called into being in response to shared threats that create a historical agent – a people, or humanity itself – by threatening it.
110
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
with less plausible claims that see suprapersonal entities as unified agents into which individuals are subsumed so that the realization of a “will” identified with the whole is identical w/the realization of the wills of each individual member (one of the things I take Berlin to have targeted)
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
(namely, that individuals don’t spring like mushrooms from the ground but are formed by social environment, and even have identities as members of large wholes)
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Intellectually, if we *are* going to reject this part of the CWL legacy, I think we need more of a justification for an ontology of suprapersonal agents that avoids the fallacy of conflating plausible claims associated with social ontological holism
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Ethically, given our continued propensity for slaughtering individuals because we identify them with one, bad, collective agent, on behalf of some other, good, collective agent, I’m sympathetic to their views.
110
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Psychologically, this is understandable enough, as so many of them had been victims – or knew and loved people who had been victims – of actions undertaken in the name of (though seldom actually by) such supra-personal agents.
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
... via the convergence of their ideas with separate currents in the social sciences which pushed methodological individualism – to the eclipse of the sort of holism involved in seeing “the people” or “humanity” as historical agents.
110
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
I don’t think it’s right to see the CWLs as doctrinaire sociological or ontological (as opposed to ethical) individualists. But I think they certainly contributed ...
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
(This may be connected to the rejection of autonomy which, like Eric, I find bewilderingly summary)
100
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
One thing that occurs to me – and I’m raising this publicly so that @samuelmoyn.bsky.social can respond if he wishes – is that an important issue here, running alongside the ethical issues that matter particularly to me (and I’d argue many CWLs), is the question of social ontology.
110
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Related to this, if the complaint is about rejection of capacity for world-making, it seems odd that Arendt is lumped in – and also subject to critique. And as Eric notes, CWLs like Popper did NOT reject efforts at collective action.
120
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
I do think Moyn blurs important differences between rejecting long-range historical determinism & teleology (“providentialism”); an ethical critique of the sacrifice of individuals to long-term, over-abstract/vague, and implausible goals; and denial of capacity for collective historical agency.
220
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Thanks to @nescio13.bsky.social for the shoutout in this very interesting post. A thread in response: Thinking of the critique of Cold War liberalism in terms of meaning in history & collective worldmaking is illuminating.
141
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
I'm not sure what's funnier/more tellingly apt: that Vanilla Ice is the only artist who is actually willing to embrace the Trump music festival, or that the festival has booked a fake version of famous fakers Milli Vanilli.
000
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Digressionsimpressions @nescio13.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
On Popper as the Useful Idiot of Anti-History. Responding to @samuelmoyn.bsky.social open.substack.com/pub/digressi... Shout out to @jcherniss.bsky.social
open.substack.com
On Popper as the Useful Idiot of Anti-History.
Yesterday, Samuel Moyn (Yale) gave our public, annual Jos de Beus lecture in Amsterdam.
264
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Alan Elrod @aselrod.bsky.social · 15/05/2026
This is outrageous. It’s just pure largesse for the president’s family, cronies, and street thugs. The corruption is mind-blowing.
According to ABC, the settlement would create a
"commission" with "total authority" to settle
"claims" brought by those who allege such weaponization. Per ABC, this not only includes the insurrectionists; it could even settle purported claims by "entities associated with President Trump himself." By all indications it would operate with little-to-no congressional oversight.In our interview, Raskin pointed out other glaringly corrupt aspects to this. He noted that Treasury's Judgment Fund is supposed to dole out its settlements and lawsuit judgments in accordance with actually existing court or administrative proceedings involving genuine victims of the government. As Raskin's staff notes, depending on the details, the relevant agencies and government officials must sign off on these payments, and they're disclosed to Congress and the public.But with the new fund, it's not clear the payments will look anything like this. It appears to transfer control over its payments to Trump alone, Raskin's staff says, and decouples them entirely from all those agency processes.

"The Judgment Fund exists to settle valid judgments against the United States government," Raskin told me. Trump and his allies, Raskin said, are "trying to take money from the Judgment Fund while eliminating any controls and oversight" and putting it under Trump's "direct unilateral control."

On top of that, Raskin added, this circumvents Congress in another way, since Congress never voted to create a fund structured this way.
Which potentially renders it unconstitutional, too.Ultimately, this story also helps explain the sordid political economy of MAGA fascism. As writer John Ganz has explained, Trump uses the government in various ways to support his coalition's "material basis." For instance, the massive scaling up of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Ganz notes, functions as "an employment program for the
Trumpenproletarian mob," as a key component of the "class composition of actually existing fascism."

This new MAGA slush fund seems very much in this vein, particularly if it hands out payments to January 6 rioters. As Raskin put it to me, Trump and his lawyers "are figuring out a way to refund the January 6 militia, presumably to get them ready for the next round of battle."
16382154
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Adam Gurri @adamgurri.liberalcurrents.com · 10/05/2026
Despite clear moral justification, the Civil Rights activists did not pick every possible fight on every possible front. This is because choosing your battles isn’t defeatist, it is the opposite. It’s the thing you do when you want to win.
824845
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Doctor Charlton Cussans PhD @charltoncussans.bsky.social · 06/05/2026
When the people's justice includes executing lemonade sellers and nuns, something has gone badly wrong.
14511
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Michael DeMoor @michaeldemoor.bsky.social · 06/05/2026
… what you saw as a student — imposing buildings full of imposing professors and administrators with imposing power and prestige — perhaps you can be forgiven for not knowing that universities are held together with sticks and duct tape and an almost perverse resolution to make it work.
131
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 06/05/2026
010
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 29/04/2026
Shoot, he's gone the full Paul Rahe!
010
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Kevin M. Kruse @kevinmkruse.bsky.social · 27/04/2026
By this same logic, Donald Trump bears direct personal responsibility for the murder of Melissa Hortman, the assault on Paul Pelosi, the guy who showed up armed at the Obamas, the attempted pipe bombing of several prominent Democrats, the January 6th rioters who assaulted cops, and many many more.
21347651457
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Cambridge University Press Political Science & IR @cambup-polsci.cambridge.org · 27/04/2026
#OpenAccess from The Review of Politics - Between Philosophy and Culture, A Symposium on Sungmoon Kim’s Confucian Constitutionalism: Dignity, Rights, and Democracy - cup.org/4t8mZtu - Chungjae Lee #FirstView
The image features a two-toned background, with the top half in dark blue and the bottom half in yellow. The text reads "The Review of Politics" in large letters and "#OpenAccess" below.
002
Reposted by Joshua Cherniss
Katherine Alejandra Cross @quinnae.com · 26/04/2026
Honestly, it's supremely irresponsible to the *staff* to keep this disgusting panto act going for a minute longer. No decent person should blame them if they all walked out on a wildcat strike.
71101145
Joshua Cherniss @jcherniss.bsky.social · 26/04/2026
From the initial vid I had noticed how quickly JD had hightailed it out; I hadn't twigged that POTUS had stumbled and fallen while being evacuated. That, plus the CBS anchor/chair of WHCA crawling on hands and knees after POTUS, is all just too apt. Reality has gotten too symbolically on-the-nose.
040