minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 09/10/2026Oh, 1000% agreed. I would've preferred a more explicit callout along the lines of "during 601.2b-d some spells may require information about objects used to pay costs, in those cases announce in 601.2b which object will be chosen for that cost". But, y'know, cleaned up. ... Or just re-word Cap. 000
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 09/10/2026You were having spicy CR discussions without me?? Woke up to this in a server I'm in and wrote about 1000 words stream-of-conscious, and figured I'd share here too. docs.google.com/document/d/1...docs.google.com601.5 DiscussionI don't disagree with Jess's intent, here. How you intend to pay phyrexian or hybrid mana is relevant info sometimes to 601.2b-d, so it gets lumped into the 601.2b "announcement" step. This seems mean... 120
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 29/09/2026Wow. Shocker. Who could have foreseen that the anti-queer right-wingers who openly bragged about using ""just asking questions about fairness/safety in women's sports"" as a wedge to eliminate trans rights... Are using that same wedge to eliminate women's rights. Truly impossible to see it coming. 050
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 26/09/2026SCG Hartford in October, but no, not Atlanta. Right now I'm sticking to events within driving range, and my range is no longer 12+ hours like it was when I was fresh out of college. 🥲 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 26/09/2026The -moment- I start working big events again, huh. 🫠 100
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialMaladroithe @maladroithe.bsky.social · 16/08/2026Discomfort is an essential part of growth and wouldn’t it be so embarrassing to be the exact same person thirty years from now, in a totally different world, because you were so averse to discomfort? 4447261737
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialJustin Wolfers @justinwolfers.bsky.social · 07/08/2026It's a healthcare economy, and the rest of us are just living in it. 1192223658
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialTrueScorn (comms closed) @truescorn.bsky.social · 02/08/2026Happy PMD day, scrubs. #pmdday #pmd #pokemonmysterydungeon 2868052434
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialJadzia Axelrod 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️ @planetx.bsky.social · 03/07/2026One of my favorite moments. 015736
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialGarrett Gilchrist @garrettgilchrist.bsky.social · 24/06/2025NANCY PELOSI: We must find the next generation of Democratic leadership. Young, charismatic and exciting candidates who can energize the party. People that voters love because they're not 80 years old and sold out to big capital. CHUCK SCHUMER (behind sniper rifle): Found one PELOSI: Take the shot 3155654465
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 25/06/2026(4) The same logic that makes Dress Down "win" versus Impending creatures (614.12 can't predict counters, default to creature) should make Grist "win" against Dress Down (Grist's static doesn't apply on the battlefield; 614.12 ignores it, Grist's default is noncreature). bsky.app/profile/mino... 010
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 25/06/2026(3) 614.12 was never updated for Xu-Ifit. The look-ahead doesn't technically allow predicting that the creature "has no abilities", because that's not an effect "that already exist[s] and would apply to [it]" - the effect starts existing as the permanent enters. bsky.app/profile/mino... 100
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 25/06/2026 (2) The behavior of "total" targeting restrictions uses plain English only, and behavior w/ otherwise-illegal targets is fully undefined. This also affects V.A.T.S., if a target has hexproof when turned face-up, and likely other cases. bsky.app/profile/mino... 100
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 25/06/2026@wotcmatt.bsky.social, @raginglevine.com, @wotcjess.bsky.social, d'you mind if I pester about a few rules Qs that have been lingering? ~ (1) Forecast's intended behavior isn't compatible with cards like Sphinx of the Second Sun, which create noncontiguous upkeeps. bsky.app/profile/mino... 100
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialUnited Wizards of the Coast - CWA @uwotc-official.bsky.social · 27/04/2026Hello World, we’d like to introduce ourselves. We the workers of the Magic: The Gathering Arena team have come together to unionize as United Wizards of the Coast - CWA! 🧵 unitedwizardsofthecoast.com/news/announcing-united-wizards-coast-cwaunitedwizardsofthecoast.comAnnouncing United Wizards of the Coast - CWA!MTG Arena workers announce unionization as United Wizards of the Coast-CWA, calling on WOTC to voluntarily recognize their union and begin collective bargaining. 8454042047
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 23/04/2026And for Prepare, you don't create a new object with those characteristics - you copy the creature "except apply its alt. chars., and ignore previous copy exceptions". Before, w/ two identical sets of copiable chars., the rules didn't know or care which had included a "copy except..." Now they do. 010
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 23/04/2026Copying it back onto the stack and changing the targets would've nonbo'd both Repartee and Opus - that's a dead end. And the typical template - "copy and cast the exiled card" - would fail (and lock you out of that Paradigm) if the first time it resolved was a copy. Best they could do... But messy. 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 23/04/2026It's... The best that could be done, I imagine. And the mechanics WORK, which is the important part. But. Yeah. For Paradigm, the resolving spell on the stack is the source of copiable characteristics each turn thereafter... But it's copied as an object into exile, then cast, NOT copied as a spell. 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 23/04/2026MTG judge posting: I get -why- Paradigm is the way it is in the CR. Design constraints left few other options. And I get -why- Prepare spells rely on "copy THIS, except just the spell, and ignore previous exceptions". But WOW am I a grouchy old grandma who hates the rules philosophy implications. 140
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 22/04/2026... That "technically" raised questions for me, since we ARE copying a spell on the stack... And getting a non-spell object in exile from it is BIZARRE, even if nothing suggests that can't work. But I guess overriding 707.12's "in the same zone" is the normal 'weird' of card text beating CR. (2/2) 010
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 22/04/2026Hey there @wotcmatt.bsky.social, @wotcjess.bsky.social! It looks like Paradigm's CR entry cites the wrong "for more info, see..." rule. It directs to 707.10, which covers copying spells. But this... Isn't technically doing that? 707.12 seems more accurate, since Paradigm copies the /object/. (1/2) 210
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialSuzanne ✨🌑 @tendermiasma.com · 18/04/2026The Free Speech Coalition is serious about starting an adult industry credit union. Part of this is being able to show regulators that enough people would use it, so please fill out this form if you're interested! (Yes, credit unions can issue credit cards!) www.freespeechcoalition.com/surveyfreespeechcoalition.comCredit Union Survey — Free Speech Coalition 5338262890
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.social#DeafLGBTQWeek @deaflgbtqweek.bsky.social · 14/04/2026Happy #DeafLGBTQWeek from the LGBT National Help Center 💜 073
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 31/03/2026I'm... Curious to see what the reason for the "Book" subtype is. Other noncreature subtypes have some kind of mechanical throughline - treasures, clues, and food all make mana, draw cards, or gain life, even if it's a card with other abilities. Are books only "Books" so that other effects can care? 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 06/03/2026I considered it!!! 😂 But at the very least, True Colors HAD to get a spot, and if I'm ruining the joke anyways... But ISAT did at least get the place of honor as #1. 💕 020
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 06/03/20269 games that describe who I am. 💜 My genres are evidently "hurt me emotionally", "therian/therian-but-robot", "flashbacks are a narrative device in which -", and Portal. This list is... Accurate enough, but I can't shake the feeling I'm forgetting something, so definitely an asterisk to it. 150
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 25/02/2026Hi @wotcmatt.bsky.social, can I poke you about this again? Or maybe pitch it to @wotcjess.bsky.social if you might have more bandwidth for rules questions at the moment? Also, welcome to Bluesky! 000
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 12/02/2026Sort of! It only untaps the creature that was targeted, not any other; Legends (this card) are basically emblems, not creatures themselves; and "conquering" a battlefield mostly maps to "surviving a combat phase" (with some caveats). 000
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 02/02/2026It's uncomfortable how much you sound like a conspiracy theorist, keeping up with the news. Like... Turns out there IS a billionaire pedophiliac cult manipulating world governments. Epstein helped kick off and fund the anti-trans movement. It was strategized in a dozen sloppily misspelled emails. 081
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 31/01/2026Side note, while I said these cases are different, technically I'm arguing 614.12 does the same thing in both: it ignores the type-changing effect during lookahead. Just, for different reasons. Results differ because the defaults differ. Blame post limits, I don't have room for nuance in my explan- 010
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 31/01/2026... since they're not characteristics or effects. Impending are creatures by default; changing that requires the ability AND the counter. Grist is noncreature by default. Its static changes that, but 614.12 only includes abilities in predictions if they "would apply on the battlefield". (2/2) 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 31/01/2026Per Arena, Dress Down beats Grist. You said that likely uses the same argument as Impending vs Dress Down, where they enter as creatures w. no counters. I think they're different. The "noncreature" part of Impending fails lookahead because 614.12 can't include counters in predictions ... (1/2) 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 31/01/2026@wotcmatt.bsky.social Sorry to bother, but I wanted to follow up on this point from the Grist question back in November, if you have bandwidth? 110
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 19/01/2026I've been counting the days to this game's release since November, I'm SO excited for it!! 💕 010
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialJohn Abernathy @john-abernathy.bsky.social · 17/01/2026Photo by Pierre Lavie. Yes this is me. And I threw my Leica. It landed on the bass plate with hardly a scratch. Another Photographer grabbed it along with my phone and I was able to track him later. I was held face down tear gas deployed right in front of me and pepper sprayed directly into the eye. 12983968014519
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialNile (like the river) @nilejoan.com · 06/01/2026ah yes, magic's time honored tradition of going "hey we just received one of the best arts we've ever received, do we have any bulk commons that need artwork??" 5366677
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 05/01/2026Going in with no prior knowledge of the story, I enjoyed it a lot! But I WAS pretty surprised at the narrative decision with the flashback near the end. Revealing his justification and the corruption defangs some tension sooner than I expected. It makes more sense that it's a few episodes combined. 010
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 30/12/2025The City of Tears really is a jaw-dropping moment in that game. They do such a good job building atmosphere. 💜 100
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.social🚲5🇵🇸 @anyfishanytime.bsky.social · 28/12/2025Say it with me y'all sex segregation in sports is to protect mens feelings 10599253
Reposted by @minordeviation.bsky.socialAniList @anilist.co · 28/12/2025"Ruri Dragon" anime adaptation announced. Production: Kyoto Animation. Teaser: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fw0g... anilist.co/anime/204738... - #ルリドラゴン 115672
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 17/12/2025Everything's relative - at least this was all regular cards, without any vanguard nonsense! That one took assembling 8 cards to fully test under ""normal"" constraints. Compared to some esoterica still wedged into dark corners of the CR, I feel like Spy Kit questions are practically tame! 000
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 17/12/2025... it asks if "there are eight or more different names among unlocked Rooms you control." That's significantly different! This template seems to be counting unique names, not comparing objects for likeness. So it shouldn't matter if those names all belong to one object, right? (4/4) 120
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 17/12/2025Having the "same name" or a "different name" should be mutually exclusive, then, based on the test in 201.2c. Meaning an object can never "have a different name than itself". But Promising Stairs doesn't ask if "unlocked Rooms you control have eight or more different names among them,"... (3/4) 120
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 17/12/2025Rules for "same/different names" are written to assume two or more objects being compared... But Surgical Extraction demonstrates that objects have the same name as themselves! The targeted card is only exiled if you find it during your search, it's not in the "exile them" group by default. (2/4) 120
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 17/12/2025Hey @wotcmatt.bsky.social! Promise this one's more reasonable than the MoJhoSto "attach" scenario. If I animate Promising Stairs and equip it with Spy Kit, does the upkeep trigger win the game even if it's the only unlocked Room I control? (1/4) 251
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 13/12/2025Arc Raiders and Expedition 33 won best multiplayer and game of the year despite using genAI. Never been happier to not give a shit about The Game Awards. Sucks to see people fold on anti-AI stances if the game is good enough; reminds me of the "trans allies" who justified buying Hogwarts Legacy. 040
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 10/12/2025Appreciate you taking the time for it (and to reply)! 000
minordeviation.bsky.social @minordeviation.bsky.social · 10/12/2025Obviously this won't really happen outside of the MoJhoSto bug that started this. But it hints at some engine issues with "attach": attaching to a noncreature and a card attaching to itself should fail, not attach and immediately detach, and neither should cancel the reconfigure type change. (5/5) 100