Sign in

Doug Thompson

@dithomps.bsky.social
502 followers 379 following 248 posts

Political theorist. Rewriting the global history of political thought from the perspective of bureaucrats, 3000 BCE to the present. Website: sites.google.com/view/douglas-i-tho…

PostsRepliesMedia
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 19/07/2026
The earliest surviving Egyptian papyrus is the daily logbook of a bureaucrat named Merer (ca. 2550 BCE). Merer supervised the production of limestone for the outer shell of the Great Pyramids at Giza. Many of the “great achievements of civilization” have indeed “come from government bureaus.”
2104
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 03/02/2026
Finally, @michaelhobbes.bsky.social is being recognized as part of the “Western canon.” Frankly, it’s his due.
150
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 11/08/2025
So much of the excellent work that people in my field have done in recent years to expand our geographic horizons has been heavily dependent on scholarship in other fields that began this work much earlier. Interdisciplinary research and even simply reading are truly transformative.
120
Reposted by Doug Thompson
David J. DeVore @devoretext.bsky.social · 11/08/2025
Greek & Roman historian here. Fact check: true. Ancient Mediterranean historians worth our salt don’t just read about Greeks and Romans.
131
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 11/08/2025
Until recently, my academic field—political theory/history of ideas—had a ‘canon’ that cut out the *entire* first half of the record of human political thought. This ‘canon’ was arbitrarily drawn from 4 times and places *only*: (1) a single century in the ancient Aegean, almost all from Athens…
192
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 03/07/2025
Democratizing “reconstruction” moments only happen in the US when the anti-democratization party is totally excluded (1865, 1932) or when the parties are *both* internally split on “race.” Neither is true in 2025. So what’s the path forward?
020
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 03/07/2025
Until now, the basic structure of how the US Constitution "works" has been "refounded" 4 times. We are now *very* far into the 5th "refounding." Dr. McMillan Cottom is right. There is no easy path toward quickly & peacefully reversing this. Why? Let's look at the other "refounding" moments. (1/)
17127
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Kevin Elliott @kjephd.bsky.social · 05/11/2024
@jamellebouie.net's recent columns advance the view that the US Constitution extends far beyond the brief formal text & those informal & unwritten pieces are central to the character of the constitutional order. I just published an article detailing a similar view, but develop it a bit differently:
doi.org
Folk Constitutionalism, or Why it Matters How Ordinary People Think about the Constitution
A truly inclusive democratic politics must be understandable, or cognitively tractable, for ordinary people busy with the rest of their lives. This extends not only to everyday politics and policy,...
1527966
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Tom Ashbyトム アシュビー @tomaashby.bsky.social · 22/06/2025
Now is a moment to reshare this video
181695799
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Bryan Boyle @bryanboyle.bsky.social · 21/06/2025
👀 👀 👀
021
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Amy Fried @asfried.bsky.social · 19/06/2025
This is fascinating.
121
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Graham Hubbs @grahamhubbs.bsky.social · 19/06/2025
Looking forward to reading about Mesopotamian bureaucracy here: www.cambridge.org/core/journal...
cambridge.org
Note from the Editors | Perspectives on Politics | Cambridge Core
Note from the Editors - Volume 23 Issue 2
041
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Paul Rosenberg @paulrosenberg.bsky.social · 19/06/2025
🎯🧵"Beginning the history of political thought at the actual beginning (and not half-way through, as we usually do) opens up a whole new vista on the entire 5,000+ record of human political ideas. Crucially, it restores bureaucracy as a central theme of history of human political reflection."
032
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Bonnie Honig @bonniehonig.bsky.social · 19/06/2025
Inaugurating Mesopotamian school of Political theory (obscured til now by philhellenism), calling for a proper focus on bureaucracy (elided til now because… slavery), noting the centrality of writing to labor, and vice versa, this (un)timely, frame-shifting essay is BIG. Bravo @dithomps.bsky.social
183
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 19/06/2025
Delighted to see my article, "The Bureaucratic Origins of Political Theory," in print in @poppublicsphere.bsky.social. It is my favorite thing I've written, and I hope you'll read it. Like most people, I learned in school that political theory began in Athens in the 5th c. BCE. This is wrong. (1/)
The abstract for the article titled "The Bureaucratic Origins of Political
Theory: Administrative Labor in the 'Other Half' of the History of Political
Thought," which reads: The earliest works of political theory precede Athenian democracy—the traditional starting point of Anglophone histories of political thought—by over two millennia. More time passed between the first written accounts of government in Mesopotamia and the birth of Plato than has passed between Plato’s life and ours. And yet this “other half” of the history of political thought has barely registered in the academic field of political theory. This article seeks to “reset” the starting point of the field back to its earliest origins in ancient Sumer. In doing so, the article expands political theory’s recent “rediscovery” of bureaucracy by calling for a new research agenda that will recover questions of public administration as a major thematic throughline in the 5,000-year global history of human political ideas. For while the ancient Athenians enslaved their public administrators and wrote almost nothing about them, the analogous actors were free and highly valued in ancient Mesopotamian political culture. It was these scribal administrators who invented the world’s first literature and written political thought. In their writings, they valorized their own administrative labor and the public goods that it alone could produce as objects of enchantment and wonder. Revealing public administration to be an integral part of large-scale human societies from the very beginning may help to counter oligarchic rhetorical claims in contemporary democracies that the “administrative state” is a recent alien imposition.
56025
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 10/06/2025
86 percent of the US population (almost 300 million people) live in metropolitan areas. To dominate them all militarily is impossible. www.census.gov/library/stor....
census.gov
Some Metro Areas’ Population Gains Reversed COVID-19 Era Trends
New Census Bureau population estimates show 88% of U.S. metro areas gained population between 2023 and 2024.
041
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 10/06/2025
The LA metro area population (12.8 million) is larger than 45 US states. The LA metro area GDP ($1.3 trillion) is greater than all but 16 *nation-states*. Mobilizing a single infantry battalion and a loose collection of ARNG companies is a major constitutional escalation AND a sign of weakness.
151
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 06/05/2025
Grading interrupted again by a friendly anole.
A photo of a green anole (colored brown at the moment) on a laptop keyboard.
150
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 05/05/2025
How am I supposed to finish grading with this beautiful visitor on my laptop?
A photo of an unexpected green tree frog sitting comfortably on a laptop computer.
150
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 29/04/2025
A story in three parts about summer 2025, which will live in infamy…
A graph from the Financial Times showing a >40% reduction in container orders between  China and the US in April 2025 A graph from the SF Federal Reserve Bank showing the tendency of inflation to rise and then peak around 8 months after a global supply chain shock A graph of the causal relation between supply chain shocks and inflation from 1998 to 2023
020
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 20/04/2025
He is risen in the polls.
020
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 08/04/2025
The best part is when she gesticulates toward the guy’s head with her muzzle.
000
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Moudhy Al-Rashid (she/her) @moudhy.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
He did not bend his neck
6611154
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Andrew S. Kelly @askellyphd.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
One upside to having 75% of Medicaid beneficiaries (~71 million people) receiving their benefits through a managed care company is that those managed care companies are big, powerful interests with similarly big economic stakes in making sure people understand these proposed cuts.
24917
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Justin Zimmerman @jztidecat.bsky.social · 20/02/2025
This was YEARS in the making but my first solo authored publication is out. I do more than rant on social media. I also study situational trust! www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10....
tandfonline.com
Cooperating through distrust: seeking remedies to state and community violence
This article focuses on a crucial issue in Black politics: the spectrum of trust. Building on Monica Bell’s theory of situational trust, I explain how community members in three South Side Chicago ...
2534873
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Steven Klein @stevenklein.bsky.social · 18/02/2025
What is the philosophical basis of European integration? My former PhD student Alec Dinnin on Ortega y Gasset's support of European unification as a response to World War II and an antidote to democracy, now out in MIH www.cambridge.org/core/journal...
cambridge.org
Democratic Catastrophes and European Unification in Ortega y Gasset’s Postwar Political Thought | Modern Intellectual History | Cambridge Core
Democratic Catastrophes and European Unification in Ortega y Gasset’s Postwar Political Thought
096
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 15/02/2025
one in the storm drain outside my son’s college dorm this week…
010
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Jacob T. Levy @jacobtlevy.bsky.social · 11/02/2025
Occasional re-post. Constraining the executive to comply with the law is *central* to the separation of powers... and far from being self-enforcing, it's been under considerable strain for a long time before the current crisis. www.constitutionalstudies.ca/wp-content/u...
6460124
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 11/02/2025
A libertarian haiku composed on a repurposed page of a Tintin book. Three people are pictured walking in the distance through snow with mountains in the background. One says, "What I like out here ... no administrative state ... just national park."
040
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Blake Emerson @blakeprof.bsky.social · 11/02/2025
🤔
II. THE PRESIDENTIAL STATE, OR WEIMAR-ON-POTOMAC
The structural position of the president and the executive branch as a whole has strengthened exponentially since the Progressive Era. With the growth of theThe situation is in some ways eerily reminiscent of the executive-centered politics of the late Weimar Republic. With the legislative branch paralyzed by ideological conflict, power steadily accrued to the executive branch. Democracy came to be associated with the decisive will of executive leaders rather than with parliamentary debate, legislation, or more participatory forms of public engagement. Politics became a winner-take-all affair—a struggle to the death among fascists, liberals, and communists rather than a matter of deliberating over common purposes.
Carl Schmitt's political thought remains the most vivid expression of that historical moment. Politics for Schmitt was not a matter of public discourse but rather of "the most intense and extreme antagonism" between "friend and enemy.43 He argued that parliamentary debate had become a "facade," as the state became deeply involved in regulating society and thus had to abandon the forms of bourgeois liberal law. The state would instead operate through emergency measures, broad delegations of power to the executive, and backroom deals between the great economic interests. With the collapse of the ideals of the Rechtsstaat, the alternative was to turn to the executive, which enjoyed plebiscitary democratic legitimacy. Here deliberation had no place, for "the perspective of a dialectic-dynamic process of discussion can certainly be applied to the legislative but scarcely to the executive." Schmitt therefore hoped to liberate the Weimar Constitution from its liberal shell and place decisive powerallomal debate.
The threat we confront here is not necessarily a precipitous descent into fascism. More immediately, we face a highly unstable form of politics, where elections take on a zero-sum characteristic and social conflict is heightened rather than worked through. S As voters and political elites think in terms of ei-ther/or, they lose the capacity to engage with one another in rational argument, which might otherwise have led to new commonalities and constellations of interests. Opportunities dwindle for Follett's idea of integrated solution, where conflicts are resolved not by compromise but by identifying new alternatives that satisfy a wide range of interests. 57
Nor can we expect presidential administration to deliver on all of its promises of popular legitimacy and programmatic performance. As I argued in chapter 4, the president is not able to shape all administrative outcomes in the way he or she would like. Though presidents have strong incentives to maximize their
082
Reposted by Doug Thompson
David Noll @david.noll.org · 04/02/2025
look on the bright side, folks. there is no chance one of elon's lackeys can touch a line of mainframe code without blowing up all federal payments.
7483
Reposted by Doug Thompson
MeidasTouch @meidastouch.com · 02/02/2025
RONALD REAGAN (1988): We should be aware of the demagogues who are ready to declare a trade war against our friends, weakening our economy, our national security, and the entire free world—all while cynically waving the American flag.
18795037717612
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 03/02/2025
Wonderful thread on the pronunciation of numbers in Sumerian and Akkadian—and how we know. I can’t wait to read @moudhy.bsky.social’s forthcoming book, Between Two Rivers.
000
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Spencer Mckay @spencermckay.com · 30/01/2025
Great thread, with a bunch of pieces I teach in my 'political theory and public policy' class. Seems particularly relevant right now.
011
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 30/01/2025
1. I agree 100%. And in addition to publicly accessible *descriptive* work on policy, there is also crucial unmet demand for accessible *normative* accounts of why the bureaucratic institutions that deliver the policies we need and like are good and democratically legitimate.
2114
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Author Myron J. Clifton @deardean22.bsky.social · 29/01/2025
Me on January 1st Also me today on the 622nd day of January
5640036
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Deva Woodly @devawo.bsky.social · 28/01/2025
One thing I’ll say as a Poli Sci prof. is that I hope this goes a good ways to resurface the submerged state.
2354
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 27/01/2025
If you’re worried about oligarchic state capture (as well you should be), and you want to know more about countervailing power that can fight it, then read my colleague @samuel-bagg.bsky.social’s excellent recent book about it: The Dispersion of Power. global.oup.com/academic/pro...
The cover of Sam Bagg’s book, The Dispersion of Power, with an image of Gulliver being tied down by the Lilliputians.
0138
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Kevin Elliott @kjephd.bsky.social · 23/01/2025
Ezra Klein's most recent podcast correctly identifies that there's been a regime change in the US government, & he even uses a game metaphor at one point, but because he doesn't know about the multiple games framework, he flounders by falling into his default technocratic mode of analysis. (Thread)
A table with three headings at the top which read: Friend-Enemy Politics, Pluralist Politics, and Technocratic Politics. The first row is titled "social ontology of politics (what is the political world made of?), the second is titled "task of politics (what do we think we're doing in politics?), the third is titled "goal of politics (what does politics generate?):"

The social ontology of politics in friend-enemy politics is a "world made up of friends and enemies. No neutrality or fairness. Identity overriding," in pluralist politics it is a "world made up of innumerable groups who must find ways to live together. Identity is central," in technocratic politics, the "world [is] composed of individuals who experience common problems. No groups, no identity." 

The task of politics in the friend-enemy mode is "for the virtuous 'Us' to defeat the evil 'Them,'" in pluralist politics it is "conciliation of different groups and their competing interests," in technocratic politics it is "solving social problems." 

The goal of politics in friend-enemy politics is "public tokens of 'our' domination or of enemy's defeat;" in pluralist politics it is "fair compromise;" in technocratic politics it is "effective policy."
23494129
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 19/01/2025
One last day without the chaos...
020
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Jessica Schoenherr @jessicaann87.bsky.social · 12/01/2024
Honored to join a long list of winners of the 2024 Neal Tate Award along with @kstauffer.bsky.social and Jonathan King! Thank you to the committee and SPSA for this opportunity!
2203
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 12/01/2025
Amen! Here's my proposal... www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1...
173
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 05/01/2025
Melville the highly effective research assistant
130
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 16/12/2024
I forgot to tag @shoufuyin.bsky.social!
061
Doug Thompson @dithomps.bsky.social · 16/12/2024
1. AMAZING new article in APSR by Shoufu Yin. He traces the transmission of a concept of liberty in multiple directions across Afro-Eurasia from 1000-1600 CE. This should change the way political theorists address questions of context when doing historical work. doi.org/10.1017/S000...
A picture of the front page of Shoufu Yin's excellent new APSR article, titled "The Global Network of Liberty: Toward a New Framework for Understanding the History of Political Concepts"
170
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Hakeem Jefferson @hakeemjefferson.bsky.social · 13/12/2024
This is a very good and important paper for scholars of race and identity. Also just one of those papers you read that makes you wonder how this wasn’t done much sooner. Highly recommend it.
39732
Reposted by Doug Thompson
Jeff Lazarus @jlazarus.bsky.social · 10/12/2024
IIRC The American Voter teaches us that partisanship operates at a near-subconscious level. People don't *know* that they decide who to vote for based on party ID, so they make up all sorts of rationalizations to explain what their gut has already decided.
1254