Sign in

Phillip H. Roth

@preprintculture.bsky.social
722 followers 1.4K following 53 posts

Postdoc @core-rwth.bsky.social / media sociology / science studies / interested in the socio-cultural history of communication infrastructures / currently writing a history of preprints in physics: preprint-culture.net / also: modular synthesis

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Juan Pablo Alperin @juancommander.scholcommlab.ca · 05/10/2026
Conversations of #openscience are waning, and I feel we missed boat of making OS about changing culture to one that truly opens science to society. Real shame OS has remained just about opening research outputs. I've argued against this framing for years now, but wish I'd articulated it better.
252
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Lisa Messeri @lmesseri.bsky.social · 27/09/2026
has anyone written about pre-print culture in the snail mail era? What were the norms? At what point was a pre-print considered 'good enough' to send to colleagues? maybe @mbarany.com might have a lead here?
572
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Julian Hamann @julianhamann.bsky.social · 01/10/2026
Zwei neuere Befunde aus der Hochschulforschung stützen die Kritik des @nnwiss.bsky.social: 1) Heinze et al. zeigen in der neuen Forschung & Lehre, dass die ExStra hinsichtlich der Vergabe von Geldern eher eine zusätzliche Grundfinanzierung darstellt, die sich vor allem nach Größeneffekten richtet.
1185
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Bart Penders @penders.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
Back of the envelope calculations: 3600 years of research time went into the collective application process. The research will fund 3200 years of research. We are 400 research years poorer as a result of this. 1/2
316486
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
SocArXiv @socarxiv.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
At SocArXiv, our intrepid volunteers screen a few dozen papers per day, using this moderation policy: socopen.org/moderation-p..., supplemented by this AI policy: socopen.org/ai-policy/. If that sounds fun or interesting or important to you, join us! Contact: socarxiv at gmail.
socopen.org
Moderation Policy
This moderation policy is now supplemented by our AI Policy, here. If your paper has been rejected and you would like to appeal the decision, use this form. Policy revision date October 2025, by th…
097
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Steve Jankowski @textaural.bsky.social · 08/09/2026
The best place to download my glossary entries on the nature of Internet "projects" and "hype histories" with the Institute of Network Cultures is here matterofimagination.neocities.org/glossary
matterofimagination.neocities.org
matterofimagination
012
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
GWTF e.V. @gwtf-sts.bsky.social · 30/06/2026
‪The Call for Papers for the annual meeting of the Society for Science and Technology Studies (GWTF) is now open. Varieties of science and technology in Europe: Shifting fortunes of STS in turbulent times Featuring a Winter School (09.-13. Nov.) and a Conference (12. & 13. Nov.). www.gwtf.de #sts
gwtf.de
GWTF e.V.
Annual Meeting of the Society for Science and Technology Studies (GWTF e.V.) 2026 Conference (12.&13. Nov. 2026) and Winter School (09.-13. Nov. 2026), RWTH Aachen
174
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Martin Paul Eve @eve.gd · 23/06/2026
I agree with this - amid all the creative ideas people have had for new assessments, we also need an explicit, robust defence of the essay. Writing essays does something to your thinking and improves your neural wiring. You can produce essays (as objects) with AI, but you don't get this benefit.
48118
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Research on Research Institute (RoRI) @rorinstitute.bsky.social · 22/06/2026
📢 New RoRI Report: The Future of Peer Review Peer review is at a breaking point. Strained by hyper-competition & AI, we need system-wide reform. Read here: rori.figshare.com/articles/report/The_Future_of_Peer_Review_A_system-wide_perspective/32685351?file=65684898
0810
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Bart Penders @penders.bsky.social · 12/06/2026
Join us as a postdoctoral researcher! "Invisible Knowledge Work in Open Science Practices", funded by OSNL #STS #metascience Come help us map and understand the invisible labour that enables, allows, supports and shapes #openscience, and lets it grow. Mostly #qual work, with small #quant pockets.
academictransfer.com
Postdoctoral Researcher Invisible knowledge work in open science practices
Welcome to Maastricht University! Are you an ambitious post-doctoral researcher with an Open Science mindset who seeks to unravel the threads of visibility and invisibility of staff across research pr...
13840
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Mar Hicks @histoftech.bsky.social · 06/06/2026
Grad students, early career folks, non-historians, and practitioners in the field are very much encouraged to be a part of this issue! (As well as folks at any stage of their careers—we just want to especially encourage newer folks!)
Call for Abstracts:
Special Issue: New Perspectives on Computing History (50th Anniversary Issue)
Editor: Mar Hicks, University of Virginia, mhicks@virginia.edu

"New Perspectives on Computing History" is the second of two anniversary issues to celebrate the upcoming 50th anniversary of the IEEE Annals. This special issue will focus on where our field is, and where it is heading-materially, methodologically, intellectually, and ideally. To do this, the issue is designed to encourage and platform the voices of newer and upcoming scholars in the field of the history of computing, and aligned disciplines, and ask them to reflect on where the field has been, and where it is going. This issue invites a broad variety of scholars and practitioners to reflect on the past and present of computing's history, through research-informed short articles (or practice-informed, in the case of practitioners). The envisioned length is roughly 2000-4000 words.

This issue seeks to expand the network of writers beyond just those who have frequently written for the IEEE Annals in the past, to ensure that this issue represents our changing field and welcomes in more voices as we embark on our next 50 years. For example, scholars in media studies, information studies, and a range of allied fields (see, for instance, Melissa Villa-Nicholas and Tonia Sutherland) have produced critical scholarship related to the history of computing, while practitioners in other fields (for example, Clarissa Redwine and Meredith Broussard) have written about the computing's historical and present enmeshment with social, political, and economic change. Essays that touch on issues like these—and beyond —would be welcome in this issue. While historical in nature, in alignment with our journals' mission, this call for papers also welcomes topics, methods, and fields related to the history of computing, and its likely future.
Some of the topics and methods welcomed for this issue include, but are not limited to:
- Discussions of computing history's trajectory as viewed through the lens of an individual scholar's specific research
- Histories of computing that discuss the role of workers, consumers, or activists
- Historical essays that focus on insights we can collectively gain from the changing topics and methods that have been commonly published in the Annals
- Historically-minded interventions and reflections from aligned fields like media studies, information studies, and STS
- Historically relevant practitioner contributions related to research or experiential insights from tech fields (e.g. tech worker labor organizers or tech workers participating

in movements to restrain "Big Tech" from enacting specific harms with the software they help write.)
- Histories of hardware and software that are attentive to global, national, and local political and cultural contexts
The goals of this special issue are to platform newer voices in the history of computing (both the up-and-coming authors on whom our future relies, as well as established voices from allied fields who have not published in Annals before), and to reflect the changing methodological and topical concerns reflected in the pages of the lEEE Annals at 50. This anniversary issue aims to ensure that the celebration of our past is also a springboard into our future, welcoming new voices, ideas, and topics into our pages.

Please send 200-500 word abstracts to the issue editor (mhicks@virginia.edu) for consideration for this issue by August 1, 2027. You are also welcome to write with questions at any time before submitting an abstract. Graduate students and recent PhDs are especially encouraged to submit. If your abstract is accepted, full submissions will then be requested (made through Author Portal by November 1, 2027).
13513
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Mar Hicks @histoftech.bsky.social · 06/06/2026
Oh shit that’s me
419828
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Senthorun S. Raj @senthorun.bsky.social · 15/03/2026
“Data labelers train, refine, and moderate the outputs of AI tools made by the largest companies in the world, yet they are wildly underpaid and haven’t benefitted from the runaway valuations of AI companies.” Good to see folk who build what we call “AI” are creating unions to defend their rights.
404media.co
'AI Is African Intelligence': The Workers Who Train AI Are Fighting Back
Kenyan workers are still the underpaid labor behind AI training, moderation, and sex chatbots. The Data Labelers Association is fighting back.
05120
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Wissenschaft im Dialog @w-i-d.de · 28/04/2026
Jetzt online: Kurzbericht zu Wisskomm in Zeiten der Postfaktizität. David Kaldewey @unwrittencross.bsky.social versteht #Wisskomm als mehr als Faktenvermittlung. Er zeigt vier Perspektiven auf, die in einer reflektierten Wisskomm-Praxis berücksichtigt werden sollten. transferunit.de/thema/kurzbe...
1105
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Julia Schubert @juliaschubert.bsky.social · 24/04/2026
noch (knapp) eine Woche bis zur DL. Wir freuen uns weiterhin über Beiträge!
0109
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Alex Hanna @alexhanna.bsky.social · 20/04/2026
As Alfredo Foucault once wrote
0274
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Dagmar Hoffmann @dagmarhoffmann.bsky.social · 19/04/2026
Stellenausschreibung an der Uni Siegen: Universitätsprofessur (W3, unbefristet) für Medientheorie mit Schwerpunkt Künstliche Intelligenz #KI #CriticalDataStudies #joboffer Bewerbungsschluss: 30.5.2026 jobs.uni-siegen.de/job/Universi...
jobs.uni-siegen.de
Universitätsprofessur (W3) für Medientheorie mit Schwerpunkt Künstliche Intelligenz
Universitätsprofessur (W3) für Medientheorie mit Schwerpunkt Künstliche Intelligenz
148
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
David William with a 'This IS my costume' pin @nrvscrcts.bsky.social · 17/04/2026
A new Boards of Canada track was released yesterday. Today is a little bit brighter.
youtu.be
Tape 05
YouTube video by Boards of Canada
053
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Samuel Moore @samuelmoore.org · 16/04/2026
This bumper special issue was an absolute joy to co-edit. Get stuck in!
02713
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Taint @taint9.bsky.social · 14/04/2026
Exactly 💯
139203205428
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Nature Reviews Physics @natrevphys.nature.com · 09/04/2026
In a Comment in our April issue, @preprintculture.bsky.social looks at how the way preprints get handled was invented in a few libraries, and the classification systems helped create the strong boundary that separates insiders from outsiders in the field www.nature.com/articles/s42...
nature.com
How libraries classified physics preprints before arXiv and set the stage for distinguishing insiders from outsiders - Nature Reviews Physics
In a world with ever-growing scientific literature, meaningful classifications are vital to keep on top of the latest results. In this Comment, historian and sociologist Phillip Roth traces the history of preprint classification in physics.
032
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Nature Reviews Physics @natrevphys.nature.com · 09/04/2026
Our April issue is live! 🩺Upconverting nanoparticles for biomedical applications 📊Metrics for spin-based computing 📏Quantum geometry and the hidden scales in materials 🦄Sub-diffraction confinement in dielectrics with narwhal wavefunctions www.nature.com/natrevphys/v...
Nature Reviews Physics April cover, which uses ice skaters as an artistic way to illustrate spin networks
141
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Phillip H. Roth @preprintculture.bsky.social · 27/03/2026
I'm super thrilled that my Comment on the vital role that #libraries have played in the history of #preprint communication in #physics is now out with @natrevphys.nature.com 🥳🥳🥳 www.nature.com/articles/s42... (message me if you can't access the article! It's not a preprint 😉)
nature.com
How libraries classified physics preprints before arXiv and set the stage for distinguishing insiders from outsiders - Nature Reviews Physics
In a world with ever-growing scientific literature, meaningful classifications are vital to keep on top of the latest results. In this Comment, historian and sociologist Phillip Roth traces the histor...
32611
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Phillip H. Roth @preprintculture.bsky.social · 01/04/2026
How did the whole #preprint thing start? 🤔 In my #OA article, I look closely at how the #library at @cern.bsky.social formalized preprint #communication in #physics in the 1960s; while my Comment in @natrevphys.nature.com gives a general overview: doi.org/10.1038/s422... doi.org/10.1007/s110...
doi.org
Formalizing Informal Communication: An Archaeology of the Early Pre-Web Preprint Infrastructure at CERN - Minerva
Minerva - This article deals with the early development of preprint communication in high-energy physics (HEP), specifically with how preprint communication was formalized in the early 1960s at the...
32621
Phillip H. Roth @preprintculture.bsky.social · 09/04/2026
Starting next Wednesday, we continue to explore questions of #digitality #complexity and digital complexity at @core-rwth.bsky.social with a cast of brilliant speakers!! #sts #philsci #sociology #theory
150
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Regina Fabry @reginafabry.bsky.social · 08/04/2026
I am delighted to share Markus Pantsar's (@markuspantsar.bsky.social) and my new contribution to the philosophy of AI. Out now in Synthese (Open Access)! #philsky 1/3 doi.org/10.1007/s112...
doi.org
Why mental metaphors do not help us understand chatbot mistakes - Synthese
Synthese - The function of chatbots like OpenAI’s ChatGPT is based on detecting probabilistic patterns in the training data. This makes them vulnerable to generating factual mistakes in their...
3296
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Julia Schubert @juliaschubert.bsky.social · 02/04/2026
"Technologien der Antizipation" Wir organisieren eine Ad-hoc Gruppe in Mainz und freuen uns noch bis zum 30.4. über Beitragsvorschläge! Vollständiger CfP hier: kongress2026.soziologie.de/fileadmin/us...
02015
Phillip H. Roth @preprintculture.bsky.social · 01/04/2026
How did the whole #preprint thing start? 🤔 In my #OA article, I look closely at how the #library at @cern.bsky.social formalized preprint #communication in #physics in the 1960s; while my Comment in @natrevphys.nature.com gives a general overview: doi.org/10.1038/s422... doi.org/10.1007/s110...
doi.org
Formalizing Informal Communication: An Archaeology of the Early Pre-Web Preprint Infrastructure at CERN - Minerva
Minerva - This article deals with the early development of preprint communication in high-energy physics (HEP), specifically with how preprint communication was formalized in the early 1960s at the...
32621
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Nils C. Kumkar @nilskumkar.bsky.social · 28/03/2026
"Sociologists visible in the public sphere during the first two years of the pandemic mostly have not published academically on COVID-19 related issues between 2020 and 2023." www.nature.com/articles/s41...
nature.com
Navigating the two worlds of academic and public communication: the case of sociologists in Germany during the COVID-19 pandemic - Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
Humanities and Social Sciences Communications - Navigating the two worlds of academic and public communication: the case of sociologists in Germany during the COVID-19 pandemic
3218
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
maybe: leif weatherby @leifw.bsky.social · 27/03/2026
Read immediately
1154
Phillip H. Roth @preprintculture.bsky.social · 27/03/2026
I'm super thrilled that my Comment on the vital role that #libraries have played in the history of #preprint communication in #physics is now out with @natrevphys.nature.com 🥳🥳🥳 www.nature.com/articles/s42... (message me if you can't access the article! It's not a preprint 😉)
nature.com
How libraries classified physics preprints before arXiv and set the stage for distinguishing insiders from outsiders - Nature Reviews Physics
In a world with ever-growing scientific literature, meaningful classifications are vital to keep on top of the latest results. In this Comment, historian and sociologist Phillip Roth traces the histor...
32611
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Carlos A. Scolari @cscolari.bsky.social · 10/03/2026
End of an era: #FirstMonday, the first openly accessible peer review journals solely on the Internet,is shutting down after 30 years (1996-2026) firstmonday.org/ojs/index.ph...
062
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
David Kaldewey @unwrittencross.bsky.social · 13/03/2026
Jetzt online: Mein neuer Blogbeitrag zur Evaluation der #Exzellenzuniversitäten – über den 11. März als eine Entscheidung ohne Verlierer und die Reaktionen zwischen demonstrativer #Freude und stillem #Unbehagen rhine-ruhr-research.de/exstra-blatt... @rrcwisskomm.bsky.social
rhine-ruhr-research.de
ExStra-Blatt, Folge 8: Ein Tag ohne Verlierer? – RRC
023
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Seth Abrutyn @sethabrutyn.bsky.social · 20/02/2026
#sociology
021
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Zachary Levenson @grundrza.bsky.social · 19/02/2026
Yesterday, those who teach Intro to Sociology at Florida colleges (as opposed to universities) received a ready-made curriculum from the state and were ordered to teach it. Yes, you read that correctly. The *state* is enforcing a curriculum on college profs, complete w/ the following restrictions:
18028371615
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Baudrillard Warned Us @baudrillardwarned.us · 18/02/2026
"Disneyland is presented as imaginary in order to make us believe that the rest is real, whereas all of Los Angeles and the America that surrounds it are no longer real, but belong to the hyperreal order and to the order of simulation." - Simulacra and Simulation
042
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Käte Hamburger Kolleg: Cultures of Research (c:o/re) @core-rwth.bsky.social · 13/02/2026
💫Meet our fellows! Yi Gu is a scholar of modern and contemporary art and visual culture, with a particular focus on China. Her current work investigates the intersections of aesthetics, technology, and political economy, as well as the possibilities of digital methods for visual culture studies.
041
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Carl T. Bergstrom @carlbergstrom.com · 27/01/2026
Very nice thread about our piece on AI "peer" review.
210619
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Brent Toderian @brenttoderian.bsky.social · 18/01/2026
“The collapse of the AI bubble is going to be ugly…AI is the asbestos in the walls of our technological society, stuffed there with wild abandon by a finance sector & tech monopolists run amok.“ Read this article by @pluralistic.net.web.brid.gy. Whether you agree with it all or not, it’s important.
theguardian.com
AI companies will fail. We can salvage something from the wreckage | Cory Doctorow
AI is asbestos in the walls of our tech society, stuffed there by monopolists run amok. A serious fight against it must strike at its roots
15498220
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Johannes Schmitthenner @richtennach.bsky.social · 19/12/2025
Die PDFs von "Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe", Band 1-7: drive.google.com/drive/folder...
drive.google.com
Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe - Google Drive
711756
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Steffen Hope @hopesteffen.bsky.social · 11/12/2025
One particular important aspect of this phenomenon is how the promotion of generative AI has inculcated into people that such programmes contain knowledge, & has access to or the ability to find knowledge inaccessible to human beings. Trust is being rerouted from human expertise to digital gods.
3236
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
SocArXiv @socarxiv.bsky.social · 27/11/2025
In light of record submission rates and a large volume of AI-generated slop, SocArXiv recently implemented a policy requiring ORCIDs linked in the OSF profile of submitting authors, and narrowing our focus to social science subjects. Today we are taking two more steps: /1
4284143
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Samuel Moore @samuelmoore.org · 08/11/2025
This isn't really a judgment on Openrxiv, which just reflects the reality of sustaining non-profit infrastructure right now, but it probably shows the need for institutions to get involved in funding the preprint landscape before it's all commercialised rather than community governed.
151
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Samuel Moore @samuelmoore.org · 08/11/2025
I wonder if the differing responses to AI are down to arXiv having a sustainability model that's more mature and dependent on institutional funding, while Openrxiv is newer and looking to more to commercial services and partnerships for sustainability.
1114
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Mar Hicks @histoftech.bsky.social · 02/11/2025
This is why we can’t have nice things
8389100
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
daniela russ @ueberdruss.bsky.social · 17/10/2025
new exhibition 'robotron: code and utopia' on the history of gdr computer technology looks great gfzk.de/en/aktivitae...?
077
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Siobhán Dowling @siobhandowling.bsky.social · 19/10/2025
AfD here, but presumably would be same in other countries too: "mainstream parties had increasingly reshaped their communications to respond, boosting the spread of these ideas and signalling to voters that these ideas and stances were legitimate." www.theguardian.com/world/2025/o...
theguardian.com
German far right setting agenda as opponents amplify its ideas, study finds
Normalisation of far-right stances likely to affect success of such parties at ballot boxes across Europe, say researchers
23314
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Steve Jankowski @textaural.bsky.social · 17/10/2025
I just updated my Keywords Index and it now links to over 550 short essays (sometimes articles) on concepts and terms that are necessary for studying media, information, and culture. A great place to start for literature reviews. textaural.com/keywords/
061
Reposted by Phillip H. Roth
Governor Newsom Press Office @govpressoffice.gov.ca.gov · 15/10/2025
Our amazing president and the American farmer he bailed out! 😍
1113150