Sign in

Ed Morland

@edmorland.bsky.social
434 followers 650 following 1.8K posts

Mostly lurking but enjoy the sudden bursts of sport, SFF, board games or far more likely reposted content. (he/him)

PostsRepliesMedia
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 3h
Ultimately I'm not sure I'm looking for a reviewer to diagnose what caused the issue with the book. As you say it's difficult to impossible to work out whether it's on the writer or on the publisher. But if the book that comes out has an issue on a sentence level it has that issue no matter why.
120
Reposted by Ed Morland
Jake Casella Brookins @casella.bsky.social · 10/10/2026
Personal hobbyhorse, but thinking about AI in publishing is really making me want criticism to go harder on discussing the actual style & substance of books. If we just talk about plot & vibes, we're leaving the door totally open, & missing out on the good stuff besides. "It's just words on a page."
416542
Reposted by Ed Morland
Roseanna Pendlebury @chloroformtea.bsky.social · 09/10/2026
Our Tolkien reread arrives at Mount Doom and the destruction of the Ring, about which I have a lot of thoughts, even for me. And The Field of Cormallen, which... not so much.
readerofelse.wordpress.com
A Close Reading of LotR – Episode 22 – The Winds of Change
And so, we come to the destruction of the Ring. Surely, this is the end! Everything solved, happy fun time. Well… not so much1. This time, we’re covering III – Mount Doom and IV &…
062
Reposted by Ed Morland
The Portal Bookshop @portalbookshop.bsky.social · 10/10/2026
Triple Portal Day is a go! 🥳 It's also National Bookshop Day! Glasgow, Fantasycon @britfantasysoc.bsky.social We look cute, come buy books (authors, come sign your books!) Every purchase today gets entered into a a draw to win a £5 National Book Token!
The left side of the Portal stall, with a bookcase full of paperbacks on a table and an array of hardbacks alongsideThe centre of the Portal stall, with the banner showing the logo along the front of the tablecloth, and stacks and stacks of paperbacks for signings and award shortlists piled high (and some bookmarks and stickers to the far left)The right end of the Porral stall, with a bookcase showing off some hardbacks and increasing numbers of signed books
34319
Reposted by Ed Morland
Eddie Clark @dreddieclark.bsky.social · 09/10/2026
I'm on this panel with Joy & 3 other judges from across the world (credit to IAFA for making a real effort not to be solely US & UK) & want to echo the point she makes later in this thread: the standard of submissions has been INCREDIBLY high. & only 5 books can go on the shortlist; it feels unfair!
1168
Reposted by Ed Morland
Lorraine Wilson @rainewilson.bsky.social · 08/10/2026
IT'S ME. Returning to my beloved Luna Press, who first opened the door to publishing for me. This book is one I am so proud of, guys, it's strange & hopeful & sad, and I'm so glad it gets to live 🖤
15221
Reposted by Ed Morland
Molly Templeton @mollytempleton.com · 08/10/2026
It was of those weeks were I was reminded that I have to write to figure out what I think. This started out just annoyed at RTD—god, shut up about surprise, there's so much more to good shows than that!—and then wound up somewhere I didn't see coming. It's a feelings one. Sorry not sorry?
reactormag.com
Do You Need to Be Surprised? - Reactor
What is the value of surprise in a story? Is it necessary?
1142
Reposted by Ed Morland
Vajra Chandrasekera @vajra.me · 08/10/2026
"What’s different: The prose. That’s it." This is a pretty old gimmick—"abridged" and "simplified" versions of famous old books—now made labour-free to produce in the slop era. But it's interesting in the way it so blatantly exposes the much more widely held idea of story/text dualism
3785
Reposted by Ed Morland
Rachel Cordasco @rachelcordasco.bsky.social · 02/10/2026
#SFinTranslation out in April: an Iranian gothic novel from @twolinespress.com ! www.twolinespress.com/shop/books/f...
twolinespress.com
Frozen Sparrows | Two Lines Press
A dark, poetic knot of a novel, Frozen Sparrows, translated lushly from Farsi by AJ Javaheri, is the first novel in English from the great Iranian author
084
Reposted by Ed Morland
Strange Horizons @strangehorizons.bsky.social · 05/10/2026
We are honoured to receive this award for a second time! Thank you everyone who voted for us and everyone who reads and submits to Strange Horizons! Congratulations to all the award recipients!
25412
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
Not really crossing over so I get it doesn't really work as an example, if you debut into both categories then both can claim you as really theirs, but Susanna Clarke has hit both literary and SFF award ecosystems with both her novels.
120
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
Oh yes, I would personally rate say Tolkien as a better stylist and concious writer of prose than most of the average modern Hugo shortlist for example which is not the prevailing view of trends. He's certainly though less accessible if you make certain assumptions about what a book should be doing.
120
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
They would somehow have heard if a non mimetic book had won the Booker so there's no need for continued engagement which is of course why I had to sit through someone confidently proclaiming at an SFF con this could never happen not a year after The Seven Moons of Maali Almeida had in fact won.
030
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
I also think some of that is a lot of people feel like they can opine on "literary fiction" because they read The Great Gatsby at school. They've therefore done their time with it and can pass comment and it couldn't possibly have changed or is a better experience when not being set essays to write.
140
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
And because of this you do see people talking in genre spaces about prose or characterisation like they're car engines that just naturally progress with time rather than the on-average improvement from Golden Age books to now being a result of people making specific choices about what they valued.
140
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
Yeah the quotation from Banks on the importance of the M that goes along the lines of My literary readers don't want SF in their litfic and my SF readers don't want litfic in their SF. I've met plenty in fandom who are absolutely building barricades to keep the non-genre out.
020
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 05/10/2026
Is that how all the admin of ARB gets done?
150
Reposted by Ed Morland
Dan Hartland @danhartland.bsky.social · 05/10/2026
📚 NEW PODCAST EP 📚 In the wake of the @thebookerprizes.com shortlisting both M John Harrison and Rebecca Perry, is it time to ask (again) what relationship exists between the literary and the speculative? Yes. Yes, it is time. @chloroformtea.bsky.social and Ryan Elliott join me to do that (again).
strangehorizons.com
Critical Friends Episode 28: On Literary SFF
In this episode of Critical Friends, the Strange Horizons criticism podcast, Dan Hartland is joined by Ryan Elliot and Rosanna Pendlebury, to ask questions about literary SFF. What is it? How do we…
22612
Reposted by Ed Morland
A Meal of Thorns @mealofthorns.bsky.social · 05/10/2026
A little longer episode for a little longer shortlist: @chloroformtea.bsky.social & @casella.bsky.social talk through the 9 books on the @ursulakleguin.com Fiction Prize shortlist!
ancillaryreviewofbooks.org
A Meal of Thorns 60- 2026 UKLG List with Roseanna Pendlebury
Only in its 5th year of operation, the Le Guin Fiction prize has already become something of a critical darling, with very interesting shortlists and winners that rarely overlap with other genre aw…
22514
Reposted by Ed Morland
Solaris Books @solarisbooks.bsky.social · 05/10/2026
🚨ACQUISITION ANNOUNCEMENT!🚨 'Let justice be done, though the world burn.' We've snapped up @gautambhatia88.bsky.social 's @theignyteawards.bsky.social winning SF legal thriller THE FIFTH INFLECTION for the UK! UK/BC rights acquired by @alrutter.bsky.social February 2027. Preorder geni.us/5thinfl
Against an abstract red and blue background, the paperback cover for THE FIFTH INFLECTION by Gautam Bhatia.
0258
Reposted by Ed Morland
@gavreads @gavreads.co.uk · 05/10/2026
‘a novel that sticks your hand in the dirt and forces you to look at nature’ gavreads.co.uk/2026/08/22/r... FYI: Kobo is also price matching.
kobo.com
When There Are Wolves Again ebook by E. J. Swift - Rakuten Kobo
Read "When There Are Wolves Again WINNER of the 2026 Arthur C. Clarke Award" by E. J. Swift available from Rakuten Kobo. * WINNER of the Arthur C. Clarke Award * * WINNER of the Best Novel Award from the British Science Fiction Association *...
0138
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 04/10/2026
And we read two more chapters in which a piece of jewellery is destroyed to some level of impact.
Mount Doom

Tbf elven shit has been doing a good job so far
Sam finally gave the truth of provisions, and a volcano
Practicality in the face of despair time
Interesting to contrast Sam's bleak frame of mind with Sauron's troubled sense, no one's enjoying themselves
I think a lot of the parallel timeline bits have really hit 
Later than I remembered we are fully Sam now, Frodo had passed beyond the narrator's reach
Gollum still haunts the narrative and the journey
Which Station of the Cross is Frodo currently at?
"There, I'll be an orc no more,"
Frodo cannot remember the better times and all Sam can do is remember them
Sam talking to himself in a dialogue that is not un-Gollum-like
I don't think these sections would hit as hard without the time spent on traveling earlier in the narrative, the comparison makes it clear how much they struggle
"I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you" is less dramatic here if no less kind
It would be quite weird narrator if the road was for Sam
The odd break, for good or ill, in the darkness/gloom
That even Gollum has been ruined by the road is an affecting image. Doubly so when we get the comparison to Frodo as a figure robed in white. One speaking prophecy
Sam finally shows pity, interesting that it is put to us that his holding the ring for even a brief time gives him that grace
We are at the end of the road, even elvendom is no help
And Frodo fails, as he must but still
The two paragraphs of Sauron realising his misusing and his danger are tremendous
And Gollum does his part, betrayed by the ring and his oaths. This does work as providence not coincidence
Frodo is back, and so the quest resolves not in triumph but tenderness and reliefThe Field of Cormallen

"Gandalf, and he was white and cold and no shadow fell on him." The shift from Frodo and Sam finishing resigned and low-key to this epic mode works.
The Eagles' arrival is more signifying a moment than decisive
Gandalf will announce the news in case you can't guess, also a shadow now "terrible but impotent" blowing away
Again interesting and not great how men and orcs are contrasted, only one is like "beast spell-enslaved".
And the narrative returns to Frodo and Sam jointly, he is back with us as well as Sam
Even in the face of miraculous survival and Gandalf's resurrection Sam can find the prosaic
Welcome to my text that cannot have Christianity in it, anyway the Fellowship set off at Christmas and destroy the ring at Easter
Glad the heralds have had 14 days to practice the song
Sam is having a moment
Look we've won a great victory, now's not the time to renounce violence and perhaps also the world of the flesh
You'd have thought they might have let them catch up with Merry and Pippin before all the song
There's a lot of nonsense gone on but a second growth spurt?
By the way I'm still doomed says Legolas ruining the moment
Oliphaunt count: Alas 0
Necessary work had been done, now for symbolism.
011
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 04/10/2026
Good Morning Womble About to start Exit Party by Emily St John Mandel, been really looking forward to it and I've now got a clear slate to read it.
061
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 03/10/2026
Exit Party by Emily St John Mandel has been long awaited and is the next book I'm picking up.
020
Reposted by Ed Morland
Renay⁷ @renay.bsky.social · 02/10/2026
Intergalactic Mixtape is live!
buttondown.com
Intergalactic Mixtape #73
Hey! This week there are essays and videos on books, reading, and a ton of reviewers that are new to me, and maybe to you! Plus, many great book rec lists....
088
Reposted by Ed Morland
Roseanna Pendlebury @chloroformtea.bsky.social · 01/10/2026
Only a few years late to the party, but I read The Vanished Birds by Simon Jimenez and really got on with it.
readerofelse.wordpress.com
The Vanished Birds – Simon Jimenez
I should have read this back when it came out. I then should have read this when I adored Jimenez’s second book, The Spear Cuts Through Water. But now is at least better than never, so here I…
0111
Reposted by Ed Morland
Ancillary Review of Books @ancillaryreviewofbooks.org · 02/10/2026
Happy October, everyone! Have some links:
ancillaryreviewofbooks.org
Wow! Signal: October 2026
Jake Casella Brookins Hello everyone, happy October! We’ve had a busy month behind the scenes at ARB—as often happens, the vagaries of publishing and reviewing schedules conspired to stack our queu…
01410
Reposted by Ed Morland
Roseanna Pendlebury @chloroformtea.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
New column up, this time of a book I had an unqualified great time with. I sometimes find books that are just enjoyable in this way hard to talk about, so this is a little of an attempt at explaining exactly what it is that felt good to me.
33011
Reposted by Ed Morland
Dan Hartland @danhartland.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
I'm not saying that SH is influential, but of the six books shortlisted for the Goldsmiths Prize today, we've reviewed The Vivisectors already, have Dooneen coming on Monday, and pieces on both The Rouse and Said The Dead are on their way. Specfic is living high on the hog this year and no mistake.
strangehorizons.com
The Vivisectors by Missouri Williams
This novel cues us to distrust metaphor.
1145
Reposted by Ed Morland
Peer Sylvester @peersylvester.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
My designer diary of Upland&Prairie is online and if for nothing else, ppl should read it to learn how lineages of inspiration can flow. boardgamegeek.com/blog/1/blogp...
boardgamegeek.com
From the King of Siam via Afghanistan to Sweden and back to Berlin: Upland & Prairie | BoardGameGeek Blog
12310
Reposted by Ed Morland
Vajra Chandrasekera @vajra.me · 30/09/2026
My third novel, HERO COME HOME, officially has a cover! Preorderable from the usual places us.macmillan.com/books/978125...
The cover of my third novel, HERO COME HOME. Four human figures centred, the main image being that of a bearded man looking back over his shoulder (that's Oro, the protagonist), with a circle of symbols behind him. We can see a swan and a key. In the foreground are three people: two women, one with a mysterious marking? scar? who knows!? on her cheek and the other carrying a sword, flanking an older, balding man holding up a pistol. The possibly-scarred woman looks ever so slightly amused, and that is certainly very like her. Everybody else is not happy to be here, or indeed, anywhere
56589199
Reposted by Ed Morland
Rockets on Tyne @rocketsontyne.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
What is Rockets on Tyne, you ask? Why, it's a day of SF events taking place on 26 November as part of this year's Books on Tyne festival! Details and tickets here and in the following thread: booksontyne.co.uk
Flyer for Rockets on Tyne, the SF&Fantasy day at the Books on Tyne festival, 26 November 2026. Featuring Adrian Tchaikovsky, Emma Newman, Francis Hardinge, Grace Curtis, and small presses The Braag and Carnyx Press.
2138
Reposted by Ed Morland
Elle @elleisanisland.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
tracking the Ring
5806197
Reposted by Ed Morland
Ancillary Review of Books @ancillaryreviewofbooks.org · 30/09/2026
In Defence of the Delightful: for the latest Small Press Dispatch, @chloroformtea.bsky.social reads Zen Cho's THE PERILOUS LIFE OF JADE YEO (@homewardbooksco.bsky.social)
ancillaryreviewofbooks.org
Small Press Dispatch: In Defence of the Delightful
Roseanna Pendlebury There are plenty of ways of talking about books that make me especially happy, and they all bear some baggage. I could say “trash”, which comes with a big side order of judgment…
0268
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
Or the "actually I'm 50k but came out in the Tordotcom Novella line so no one thinks to check".
020
Reposted by Ed Morland
☀️ Starshine @starshine.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
read theory
phuulishfellow.wordpress.com
Elendil the Insufferable Lying Bastard: Historical Bias in the Akallabêth (Part One)
For the past thirty years, substantial scholarly work has been done on the role of Historical Bias in Tolkien’s Silmarillion. Essentially, the premise is that Tolkien was deliberately present…
45915
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
"unable to breathe as she held the flute in her trembling hands, and felt in its cracks the decades." It's been half a decade since I first read it but the opening chapter of The Vanished Birds is still a marvelous thing.
041
Reposted by Ed Morland
Anya Johanna DeNiro @adeniro.bsky.social · 25/09/2026
the Internet Science Fiction Database has the listing of ALL my books and stories under my deadname, and my books with my real name 'written as Anya Johanna DeNiro'. Obviously not a legacy system but a choice. It's exhausting to deal with this shit 10 years after I legally changed my name.
4345
Reposted by Ed Morland
Misha Grifka Wander @mishagw.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
Ancillary Review is looking for more editors! Message me if you're interested in copy-editing, dev editing, or graphics creation for a Hugo finalist magazine of spec fic criticism! It's volunteer-based and fits with your schedule <3
86255
Reposted by Ed Morland
Locus Magazine @locusmag.bsky.social · 24/09/2026
Union Square Announces Novella Program locusmag.com/2026/09...
042
Reposted by Ed Morland
lauren @lauren.rotatingsandwiches.com · 24/09/2026
ME: So I can't put anything else on the scale? ANUBIS: No. Just your heart ME: No money, no good deeds? ANUBIS: No ME: What about steam points? I've got a ton of steam points ANUBIS: The point is to be lighter than the feather ME: I was just hoping to finally do something with the steam points
646088989
Reposted by Ed Morland
🐺Cold🪦Sam🪾 @pdfmerchant.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
355731245
Reposted by Ed Morland
Quinns @itsquinns.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
Rounding out my Summer Reading posts on Quinns Quest with an absolutely electric final brace of releases. I've been reading Infinite Revolution, City of Espers, Asher's Ridge and Girlframe. They are all SO GOOD. www.patreon.com/qquest/posts...
1231968
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
I don't think we do, I bounced off the Ed Chianese strand of it hard enough I'm not sure I kept my copy during one of our moves. Was a while ago.
120
Reposted by Ed Morland
Dan Hartland @danhartland.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
I’m not saying that SH is influential, but of the three longlisted books we covered last week, two have just made it to the Booker shortlist. M John Harrison and Rebecca Perry both in the running for the gong. Big moment for spec fic, I’d say, perhaps especially that The End of Everything is there.
2328
Reposted by Ed Morland
Abigail Nussbaum @abigailnussbaum.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
The Great Tolkien Reread meets "The Riders of Rohan" today. Specifically, Éomer, the first of several characters who seem to have been designed to echo Boromir, and to reflect on his strengths and weaknesses. wrongquestions.blogspot.com/2026/09/the-...
wrongquestions.blogspot.com
The Great Tolkien Reread: The Riders of Rohan
Illustration by jorahh , 2025 'What do you know of these horsemen, Aragorn?' [Gimli] said. 'Do we sit here waiting for sudden death?' 'I hav...
44710
Reposted by Ed Morland
Meghan Ellis Brown @meghan0n.bsky.social · 16/09/2026
My very first 🧡 book launch 🧡 I'm so delighted to be included alongside many very cool writers from Glasgow! I can't believe it ☺️ I'll be at a book launch where you can buy a book that has MY WORDS in it! 📚
22011
Ed Morland @edmorland.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
Realised I didn't post this on Sunday, we're into Mordor and Mount Doom it's very much in sight. A lot of orc content, both positive and negative.
The Tower of Cirith Ungol

For a moment he wondered where he was - recap time
Who is forgotten, who is swallowed up by the darkness
The timetable remains apparent
Sam puts on the ring for comfort, no temptation yet but the habit is already forming
Evil getting in its own way, shadows hide as well as conceal
A tower built to stop escape not entry, Tolkien gives us small glimpses of what life looks like on the other side
And the temptation of Sam, that he resists is not necessarily surprising but why is both the sublimation of self and an inherent humbleness/small scope of ambitions. As throughout Sauron does not comprehend other than himself
The Two Watchers is a moment of supernatural horror that stuck with me from the first read
Despite his refusal the ring is still working on Sam, he's not immune
Not an unbelievable orc civil war but a convenient one.
Mount Doom overlooks and haunts this section
Please go to Appendix F to find out what the slur means
An orc's two least favourite things, elves and Sauron
And here is (part of) why The One Ring has a sing skill
Even towards the climax Sam is bad at violence
Sam is tempted but does give it up, given that claiming it is different from just carrying it now much does the fact he was holding it for someone else protect him from it
Again we get the dynamic of Sam dehumanising the enemy
One more dramatic scene with the Watchers, enter NazgulThe Land of Shadow

We return to a favourite topic, getting down of mountains/ridges is hard
It's just possible Frodo isn't currently in the best of shape
The wind's changed, happiness, BTW Théoden's dieing
This is a land oppressed, by darkness, by Sauron but not a wasteland. There are roads, there is water
"Mordor was a dying land, but it was not yet dead."
The star, much like the King's crown, the book avoids despair
Sauron, very much a Fisher King to Mordor
And, knowing the last book, we get the reason/impact of the last debate
Neither Sam nor Frodo knew anything of logistics but Tolkien does
Even on home ground we get a militarised Orc culture but a modern one too, chains of command, reporting names and number, censorship. Not the 'savage horde' of later writers
Gollum saving them unwittingly, foreshadowing
Frodo's pacifism, more featured later but coming here
Mordor gets an internal geography, it's not just here be evil
Similarly Sam and Frodo are saved by orcs having a psychology, they understand deserting so they are fitted into that schema
Again, perhaps one too many times, internal orc arguing saves the day
100
Reposted by Ed Morland
Roseanna Pendlebury @chloroformtea.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
We continue our Lord of the Rings reread, now heading into book 6, in which I am a bit of a grump and Ed has a lot of good points.
readerofelse.wordpress.com
A Close Reading of LotR – Episode 21 – Some Things Don’t Change
Here comes book six. Just two chapters this time, but they’re slightly chunky ones (at least by page count): I – The Tower of Cirith Ungol and II – The Land of Shadow. The story i…
074
Reposted by Ed Morland
Eddie Clark @dreddieclark.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
My review of This Is Where The Future Bleeds by Mike Brooks is up on @nerdsofafeather.bsky.social. A hugely fun, funny fantasy romp that also has something reasonably savage to say about extractive capitalism.
nerds-feather.com
Book Review: This Is Where The Future Bleeds by Mike Brooks
Quality fantasy romp with a side of anti-capitalist fury Mike Brooks is a writer that rarely disappoints. He's one of the most consistently...
0199