Sign in

Josh

@geekcritique.org
2.6K followers 336 following 8.9K posts

The Geek Critique (TGC) features video gaming nerd analysis, computerized guru reviews, poindexter software entertainment media exposition, and bad jokes. He/Him YOUTUBE: geekcritique.org PATREON: patreon.com/geekcritique

PostsRepliesMedia
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27m
I feel that and I don't entirely disagree, but more than anything I think he's just polarizing. The people who love him REALLY love him, and the people who don't REALLY don't, and how loud each group is inclined to be is largely determined by how much shine he's gotten recently.
391
Josh @geekcritique.org · 59m
Important reminder:
1141
Reposted by Josh
downchasm @downchasm.bsky.social · 7h
everyday on this website I encounter unwell people making dangerous claims like “I’m going to play through the entire 3DO library” and instead of directing these individuals to emergency services or calling local authorities, other users of this site celebrate them, reenforcing unhealthy behaviors
66611
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 22h
Kid me unironically took this lyric as further confirmation that Adventure Sonic was a new canon.
48415
Josh @geekcritique.org · 10h
Considering how many popular games now feature vast open worlds where you walk around pressing the A button over and over again to collect pointless objects, I'd say the only thing Rare was behind on was letting players craft Golden Bananas out of 100 regular bananas and 50 golden flakes.
13811
Reposted by Josh
Sam Logan @samandfuzzy.com · 17h
Big surprise, I know, I know
Old airbrush artwork of Sonic putting on his gloves
3817
Reposted by Josh
John Linneman @dark1x.bsky.social · 13h
I remain pretty bummed out by the state of decompilations, ports, FPGA cores etc these days. The rise of GenAI has really flooded the whole scene with garbage and kinda poisoned the whole concept. Good piece from @pandamonium.bsky.social on it www.segasaturnshiro.com/2026/09/24/c...
segasaturnshiro.com
Column: All A.I. Projects Are Digital Asbestos
The views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of all SHIRO! Media Group contributors. The cost of modern day video game consoles and personal computers have skyrocketed…
27559165
Josh @geekcritique.org · 20h
I poster I had in my room growing up. One time a lady came over and laughed at the "giant pile of naked men" on my wall. Some folks just don't get it.
0101
Josh @geekcritique.org · 22h
Kid me unironically took this lyric as further confirmation that Adventure Sonic was a new canon.
48415
Reposted by Josh
Freezer @freezer.bsky.social · 23h
It sure is cool that my Switch copy of The Witcher 3 turned into a free upgrade for Switch 2. Hey lots of other companies what are your fucking excuses? I'm not buying Sonic Generations a 4th time just to have it be a slightly better Switch 2 experience.
3425
Reposted by Josh
Fer 🇲🇽 @fercho-27.bsky.social · 23h
Very good thread. A lot of people nowadays only play the same dozen most known titles for any given retro console. Heck, I'm guilty of this too... But I've been trying to expand my N64 horizons with the Nintendo Classics app.
0112
Reposted by Josh
★ 𝗗𝗶𝗴𝗶𝘁𝗮𝗹 𝗟𝗼𝘃𝗲 ★ 𝘚𝘺𝘯𝘵𝘩𝘱𝘰𝘱 𝘗𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘤𝘦𝘴𝘴 ★ @thebitchdigital.com · 29/09/2026
trees are everywhere and rope is cheap.
1227
Josh @geekcritique.org · 30/09/2026
Apropos of nothing, one of the biggest milestones in my maturity was the moment I reframed how I thought about privilege. Circa 2010, terms like male privilege and white privilege were becoming very common, and for some reason hearing them initially made me feel like I had to be on the defensive.
1183
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
Po-keh-mon - standard Po-kay-mon - formal Po-key-mon - how your dad says it to make fun of you
3135
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
> Favorite N64 soundtrack? Oh god, that's a hard one. You know what? I'm not even that big on the game, but Ocarina of Time was the first one that came to mind, it's just SO resonate with the console, the era, the time, and how long ago it was now.
2110
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
I think there's a pretty big disconnect between the small number of mostly 1st party Nintendo games that detractors think of as classics now, versus the games that were held in high regard and actively being played when the system was actually on shelves.
1181
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
Did anyone else think the karts in Diddy Kong Racing had a face with angry eyebrows?
13384
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
In 2008, some Sonic forums had to explicitly ban all discussion of reviews of Unleashed. Fans were so pissy about "bad reviews" that they were building conspiracies about the authors, harassing them, and attempting to dox them. All over the one with the Werehog.
7341
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
All of this. You want me to feel emotion? Do it through gameplay. Infinitely more effective. Seeing Samus get pissed and obliterate Raven Beak wouldn't have hit NEARLY as hard if I hadn't just spent over an hour sitting on the floor fighting my way through that wall.
1262
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
Buddy, I used the Sega Dreamcast as a computer.
0381
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
Pikachu. Against a bunch of other kids who had even less of an idea of how to play than I did, down+B felt like an instant win button.
2140
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
I noticed. It was hard not to. Game magazines, the internet, and Stanley the 13 year old from down the street who traded his N64 for a PSX, made fun of me for still having an N64, and still magically wanted to hang out when there was a new N64 game he wanted to play all never shut up about them. :V
2220
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
> what n64 game has the best graphics? I think @exoparadigmgamer.bsky.social convinced me - as a total package, it's probably Donkey Kong 64. To go from this to THIS in just three years... we didn't know how good we had it, did we?
3223
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
It's Mr. Pants is unironically bigger in my head than any GTA game. And in a just world...
071
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
In honor of the holiday, the only asks I'm answering today are gonna be about the Nintendo 64! geekcritique.straw.page
081
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
Happy 30th birthday to the console that, for all of my insufferable Sega fandom, truly defined my childhood more than any other.
3396
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
I did several years ago, and you're sort of right... I wouldn't say *100* times better. Maybe like 60-80. Unless we're talking about Frontiers with a cheat to enable the spin dash from the beginning, in which case Heroes' advantage drastic goes down.
370
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
3313
Josh @geekcritique.org · 29/09/2026
The lesser-known Tower of Power stand.
26011
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
> Whether it's in regards to Sonic, Mario (Kart), Zelda or any other number of popular franchises, game or otherwise... I am *NOT* a fan of what I'm terming Heel-Digging Nostalgia™. At all. I've seen some heels that were real good at digging in my time.
static.klipy.com
Wwe Triple H
ALT: Wwe Triple H
081
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
I was genuinely interested in this and I still applaud the incredible artistry that went into those animations... But then I found out there's a button where the game just plays itself and I lost all interest in trying it. Make me actually learn Mahjong and EARN it, or I don't care.
390
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
Same, like by 3rd grade I knew of SegaSonic (east and west), AoStH, SatAM, the OVA, Archie, and Fleetway, and all of this was before SA1 was even announced.
2152
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
3325
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
This'll always the Pokémon anniversary to me. It's weird to have all these 30th anniversary celebrations going on because dude I *remember* 1996 and Pokémon wasn't here yet!
1181
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
I know someone born in 2018 who loves Super Mario 64 and has *290 hours* in the N64 NSO app. Never let 'em tell you that you're too young to enjoy a game, or to have an opinion on it for that matter.
5497
Josh @geekcritique.org · 28/09/2026
Man, I have built WAY too much of my life, career, and relationships around Sonic if I /don't/ like him. My wife mentioned him in our wedding vows (I specifically decided I wouldn't do that and then she did it for me), and we got married on the anniversary of the day he was revealed for Smash Bros.
2190
Reposted by Josh
GWIZ 🎧🌙✨ @gwizofthestars.com · 28/09/2026
Realized how funny/real it is that I can go to multiple Sonic concerts and events with thousands of attendees and never be recognized as someone who worked on the Shadow Gens OST, but one time I went to Raising Canes Chicken Fingers and the guy taking my order did.
38413
Reposted by Josh
Tama Hero @tamahero.bsky.social · 02/09/2026
Pokemon may mean a lot of different things to a lot of different people now. But what Pokemon means to me is all mine. It'll always be mine. Even if it's something else to somebody else.
430249
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
One of my dad's biggest passions was genealogy. He gave me backups to this massive Family Tree file he'd been working on since the mid-90s, and finding this was kinda funny. The last time Dad updated this would've been well before this guy was famous.
1100
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
3152
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
> Why do you think some Sonic fans are so upset about Classic Sonic existing/keeping a distinct identity? Is it just Forces trauma? For some fans, there is no scenario in which a Classic Sonic game could ever be preferable to a modern one, they just fundamentally do not see the appeal.
3111
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
Which is TOTALLY FINE by the way, the whole reason I *do* like both branches existing is because they appeal to very distinct aspects of my own fandom, so it's not hard to see why someone might strongly prefer one over the other.
1101
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
But if you only like modern, then you'll feel that whatever resources are put into any given classic project would be better spent on a spiritual successor to Advance, or Rush, and you might resent the fact that you're not getting that.
1121
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
And if you're extremely 17 years old about it, you might have trouble empathizing with the idea that other fans might have different preferences than you and simply paint them as not being REAL fans somehow. Which is especially hilarious, because...
1101
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
I remember well when Modern Sonic was treated exactly, and I mean *EXACTLY* the same way. To hear the fandom circa 2010 tell it, green-eyed Sonic was a pandering abomination that had no purpose, aura, or SOUL. They hoped that Generations would end by retconning everything that happened after S3&K.
3111
Reposted by Josh
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
So when I see someone seriously raging about Classic Sonic in a similar way, I just figure they're a younger fan going through the same thing, and they'll grow out of it sooner or later. Hopefully by the time the series' focus shifts AGAIN and starts catering to people even younger than they are. :V
191
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
Knuckles. Knuckles is my answer to both questions.
1160
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
> I can't wait until Pokemon Winds and Waves to come out so that the community can talk about how "they don't look like Pokemon anymore" as if that wasn't said every single time. This image but it's just every other generation of Pokémon.
38420
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
Doubtful, because in 2007 I really *didn't* have anyone else to play with. I dunno! I liked the Pokémon more, liked the aesthetic more, *really* appreciated all the helpful ways they found to use the DS - I still maintain the two-screen format is the best system Pokémon's ever had...
270
Josh @geekcritique.org · 27/09/2026
I feel that. From a certain perspective, every new Mario character since Waluigi sort of feels like one of the new ones. Rosalina is as old now as Zelda (the series) was when she debuted, but my brain is still like, "It's nice of them to include a less-established character like her in a movie!"
2181