Sign in

Charlie Williams

@pontifc8.bsky.social
432 followers 665 following 104 posts

Professor at Bocconi University in Milan. Amiable dabbler posting about business research, business education, strategy execution, human impact of business, and maybe a few other things.

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Dr Anna Clark @drannaclark.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
Arthur Schopenhauer, German ‘philosopher of pessimism’, died #OTD 1860, whose work on the Will influenced philosophers, scientists & writers including Nietzsche, Einstein, Schrödinger, Tolstoy, Thomas Mann, Samuel Beckett. Portrait by Ludwig Ruhl, 1815, Universitätsbibliothek Frankfurt am Main
1399
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 19/09/2026
Did you know about the cultish relationships at the heart of AI doomer society around Berkeley? I didn’t. Lots of tendrils shaping our very weird public discourse about AI risks.
001
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 20/07/2026
Slipping? Seems more like marching briskly towards!
010
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 19/05/2026
SEO slop was sinking search well before AI results.
020
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Aaron Rupar @atrupar.com · 08/04/2026
A commenter notes that "Trump managed to be both Hitler and Chamberlain in the same negotiation. An unprecedented feat." 😭
9164431402
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 24/02/2026
How does nonverbal expression affect success in crowdfunding pitches? Does this vary between men and women? Do these differences provide hints to why women do better in crowdfunding than in traditional entrepreneurial fundraising?
100
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 08/02/2026
Finally, dungeon crawler Carl and Princess Donut get the @lauramille.bsky.social treatment in Slate. I resisted recommendations for this ridiculous "LitRPG" series for quite a while, and I'm still wrestling with why I love it so much. slate.com/culture/2026...
slate.com
The Unlikely Hit That’s Popularizing a Whole New Type of Novel
Like many, I never thought I’d become a fan of this bizarre series, but here we are.
120
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Lindsay Beyerstein @beyerstein.bsky.social · 10/01/2026
"And perhaps the greatest myth of all is that Greenland was ever truly conquered. It remains, even now, a place that humbles empires, silences explorers, and outlasts expectations. It is not a relic or a ruin. It is a force," Erik Mikkal Thorsen, Greenland Uncovered
0509
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Peter Head @peterheadcbe.bsky.social · 03/01/2026
The rate of global mean sea level rise has increased from ~2.1 mm/year in 1993 to ~4.5 mm/year in 2023. www.nature.com/articles/s43...
nature.com
The rate of global sea level rise doubled during the past three decades - Communications Earth & Environment
Global mean sea level rise amounted to 4.5 mm per year as a result of warming oceans and melting land ice, more than twice the rate of 2.1 mm/year observed at the start of satellite data in 1993, base...
23945761836
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Rachel Maddow @maddow.bsky.social · 20/12/2025
one of four in a week www.nytimes.com/2025/12/19/n...
490105565619
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 06/12/2025
tldr: it all comes down to Baumol’s disease plus rising opportunity costs of family work. www.ft.com/content/3fa9... Why Americans are feeling poorer even though they’re not
ft.com
Why Americans are feeling poorer even though they’re not
Essential services cost more because people are better off
010
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Antoine Vernet @antoinevernet.com · 01/12/2025
Perfect, no notes 👇
041
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 19/11/2025
I just finished Moby Dick. The last 25-30 chapters are a rip-roaring yarn. What elevates it to “classic” experience is the relief of getting through the first 100 chapters of whale trivia and ship gossip.
010
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 19/11/2025
I just finished Moby Dick. The last 25-30 chapters are a rip-roaring yarn. What elevates it to classic is the sheer relief of getting through the first 100 chapters of whale trivia and ship gossip.
000
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 19/11/2025
Fine for Harvard students though.
110
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 20/10/2025
They should put in auctions where you bid to recline while the person behind bids to prevent reclining. To the winner go the spoils.
010
Reposted by Charlie Williams
60 Minutes @60minutes.bsky.social · 20/10/2025
“We found over 35 cases in which the judges have specifically said what the government is providing…false information. It might be intentionally false information, including false sworn declarations time and again," says Ryan Goodman, law professor at New York University.
310135485569
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 09/10/2025
Oh, Europe. Self-parody is so 2018.
000
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 06/10/2025
How causality ate the world. I don’t see how causality is the key issue in psychology research, most of which is based on RCTs. Replicability crisis, yes a big issue. Generalizability out of the lab, yes. But causality? That hardly seems to be the crux.
030
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Thor Benson @thorbenson.bsky.social · 15/08/2025
[writing the constitution] Benjamin Franklin: Write down "no dumb fucks as president" Alexander Hamilton: Stop saying that Benjamin Franklin: I'm tellin' you. You're gonna regret not writing that down
149201064076
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Thomas Fuchs 🫯 @thomasfuchs.at · 20/06/2025
“Technology will just get better” idk but I liked the Internet better 25 years ago
3846
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Leo Spalteholz @leospalteholz.bsky.social · 03/06/2025
The renewable energy transition goes very slowly, then all at once
27415
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 28/05/2025
How did the hype get so far ahead of reality?
000
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 17/05/2025
It’s time for scientists to publicize the research that is being cancelled. Enough silence in hopes of evading the axe! Disease communities (and others) are organized & can be activated!
000
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Ed Zitron @edzitron.com · 28/04/2025
Large Language Models and their associated businesses are a $50 billion industry masquerading as a trillion-dollar panacea for a tech industry that’s lost the plot. The tech and business media must change their ways, or risk repeating these cycles forever. www.wheresyoured.at/reality-check/
If I'm Wrong, How Am I Wrong Exactly?

I dunno man, all of this sure seems like the hyperscalers are reducing their capital expenditures at a time when tariffs and economic uncertainty are making investors more critical of revenues. It sure seems like nobody outside of OpenAI is making any real revenue on generative AI, and they're certainly not making a profit.

It also, at this point, is pretty obvious that generative AI isn't going to do much more than it does today. If Amazon is only making $5 billion in revenue from the literal only shiny new thing it has, sold on the world's premier cloud platform, at a time when businesses are hungry and desperate to integrate AI, then there's little chance this suddenly turns into a remarkable revenue-driver.

Amazon made $187.79 billion in its last quarterly earnings, and if $5 billion is all it’s making at the very height of the bubble, it heavily suggests that there may not actually be that much money to make, either because it's too expensive to run these services or because these services don't have the kind of total addressable market as the rest of Amazon's services.

Microsoft reported that it was making a paltry $13 billion a year — so the equivalent of $3.25 billion a quarter — selling generative AI services and model access. The Information reported that Salesforce's "Agentforce" bullshit isn't even going to boost sales growth in 2025, in part because it’s pitching it as "digital labor that can essentially replace humans for tasks" and it turns out that it doesn't do that very well at all, costs $2 a conversation, and requires paying Salesforce to use its "data cloud" product.

What, if anything, suggests that I'm wrong here? That things have worked out in the past with things like the Internet and smartphones, and so it surely must happen for generative AI and, by extension, OpenAI? That companies like Uber lost money and eventually worked out (see my response here)? That OpenAI is growing fast, and that somehow …Large Language Models and their associated businesses are a $50 billion industry masquerading as a trillion-dollar panacea for a tech industry that’s lost the plot. Silicon Valley is dominated by management consultants that no longer know what innovation looks like, tricked by Sam Altman, a savvy con artist who took advantage of tech’s desperation for growth. 

Generative AI is the perfected nihilistic form of tech bubbles — a way for people to spend a lot of money and power on cloud compute because they don’t have anything better to do. Large Language Models are boring, unprofitable cloud software stretched to their limits — both ethically and technologically — as a means of tech’s collapsing growth era, OpenAI’s non-profit mission fattened up to make foie gras for SaaS companies to upsell their clients and cloud compute companies to sell GPUs at an hourly rate. 

The Rot Economy has consumed the tech industry. Every American tech firm has become corrupted by the growth-at-all-costs mindset, and thus they no longer know how to make sustainable businesses that solve real problems, largely because the people that run them haven’t experienced them for decades. 

As a result, none of them were ready for when Sam Altman tricked them into believing he was their savior. 

Generative AI isn’t about helping you or me do things — it’s about making new SKUs, new monthly subscription costs for consumers and enterprises, new ways to convince people to pay more for the things that they already used to be slightly different in a way that often ends up being worse. 

Only an industry out of options would choose this bubble, and the punishment for doing so will be grim. I don’t know if you think I’m wrong or not. I don’t know if you think I’m crazy for the way I communicate about this industry. Even if you think I am, think long and hard about why it is you disagree with me, and the consequences of me being wrong. 

There is nothing else after generative AI. There are no other hype…
1546345
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Ed Zitron @edzitron.com · 28/04/2025
It is now actively illogical to act as if generative AI is a real movement. Analyst Josh Beck said last week that Amazon will only make *$5bn* from AI in 2025 - after spending $105bn in capex. And they're pulling back on data centers too. This isn't a revolution! www.wheresyoured.at/reality-check/
Oh, By The Way, The Bubble Might Be Bursting

Hey, remember in August of last year when I talked about the pale horses of the AIpocalpyse? One of the major warning signs that the bubble was bursting was big tech firms reducing their capital expenditures, a call I've made before, with a little more clarity, on April 4 2024:

    While I hope I'm wrong, the calamity I fear is one where the massive over-investment in data centers is met with a lack of meaningful growth or profit, leading to the markets turning on the major cloud players that staked their future on unproven generative AI. If businesses don't adopt AI at scale — not experimentally, but at the core of their operations — the revenue is simply not there to sustain the hype, and once the market turns, it will turn hard, demanding efficiency and cutbacks that will lead to tens of thousands of job cuts.

We're about to find out if I'm right.

Last week, Yahoo Finance reported that analyst Josh Beck said that Amazon's generative AI revenue for Amazon Web Services would be $5 billion, a remarkably small sum that is A) not profit and B) a drop in the bucket compared to Amazon's projected $105 billion in capital expenditures in 2025, its $78.2 billion in 2024, or its $48.4 billion in 2023.
Is That Really It? Are you kidding me? Amazon will only make $5 billion from AI in 2025? What?

5 billion dollars? Five billion god damn dollars? Are you fucking kidding me? You'd make more money auctioning dogs! This is a disgrace! And if you're wondering, yes! All of this is for AI:

    CEO Andy Jassy said in February that the vast majority of this year’s $100 billion in capital investments from the tech giant will go toward building out artificial intelligence capacity for its cloud segment, Amazon Web Services (AWS).

Well shit, I bet investors are gonna love this! Better save some money, Andy!Oh, shit! A report from Wells Fargo analysts (called "Data Centers: AWS Goes on Pause") says that Amazon has "paused a portion of its leasing discussions on the colocation side...[and while] it's not clear the magnitude of the pause...the positioning is similar to what [analysts have] heard recently from Microsoft, [that] they are digesting aggressive recent lease-up deals...pulling back from a pipeline of LOIs or SOQs."

    Some asshole is going to say "LOIs and SOQs aren't a big deal," but they are. I wrote about it here.

"Digesting" in this case refers to when hyperscalers sit with their current capacity for a minute, and Wells Fargo adds that these periods typically last 6-12 months, though can be much shorter. It's not obvious how much capacity Amazon is walking away from, but they are walking away from capacity. It's happening.

But what if it wasn't just Amazon? Another report from friend of the newsletter (read: people I email occasionally asking for a PDF) analyst TD Cowen put out a report last week that, while titled in a way that suggested there wasn't a pull back, actually said there was.

Let's take a look at one damning quote:

    ...relative to the hyperscale demand backdrop at PTC, hyperscale demand has moderated a bit (driven by the Microsoft pullback and to a lesser extent Amazon, discussed below), particularly in Europe, 2) there has been a broader moderation in the urgency and speed with which the hyperscalers are looking to take down capacity, and 3) the number of large deals (i.e. +400MW deals) in the market appears to have moderated.

In plain English, this means "demand has come down, there's less urgency in building this stuff, and the market is slowing down. Cowen also added that it "...observed a moderation in the exuberance around the outlook for hyperscale demand which characterized the market this time last year." 

Brother, isn't this meant to be the next big thing? We need more exuberance! Not less!
445348
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 28/04/2025
Mark Halperin hasn't seen a "clever and invigorating joke" since the 2004 presidential election cycle.
010
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 28/04/2025
We are definitely at peak market moment for “Andreesen seems brilliant for spending 20 hours a day on signal chats.” Gonna be a fast slide from here - joining Elon in the heap at the bottom.
030
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 26/04/2025
This is a good rundown of some research about how AI thinks. Big bags of heuristics do not “generalize” to new problems very well. AGI may be much farther away than industry leaders claim. www.wsj.com/tech/ai/how-...
wsj.com
We Now Know How AI ‘Thinks’—and It’s Barely Thinking at All
The vast ‘brains’ of artificial intelligence models can memorize endless lists of rules. That’s useful, but not how humans solve problems.
021
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Jessica Leight @leightjessica.bsky.social · 24/04/2025
Cool graph. If you had asked me, I would not have correctly predicted that the slope was steepest for Latin America
2145
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 24/04/2025
Powerful. But not “intelligent.” A transformative technology. But not going to replace all human & organizational intelligence in a matter of years. We’re like the 18th C audiences mesmerized by batteries attached to twitching frog legs thinking the font of life had been discovered.
020
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 14/04/2025
I had not seen the revelation last month that Daniel Kahneman ended his life with medical assistance in 2024. I wonder if it was at the same location in Switzerland where my mother ended her life this January. Reading the article I was back there, living her choice. www.wsj.com/arts-culture...
wsj.com
Essay | The Last Decision by the World’s Leading Thinker on Decisions
Shortly before Daniel Kahneman died last March, he emailed friends a message: He was choosing to end his own life in Switzerland. Some are still struggling with his choice.
000
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Aija Leiponen @aijaleiponen.bsky.social · 08/04/2025
Not a lot of people know that manufacturing generates just 10% of U.S. GDP and employs 10% of workers. Ag + mining is about 2% of GDP. The rest comes from various services. The U.S. is a service economy like most other developed nations.
131
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 05/04/2025
So much bravery. So much integrity.
000
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 04/04/2025
That post is getting passed around a lot (as pics at the other place), so it's worth knowing it's probably wrong.
000
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 04/04/2025
So I guess there is no such thing as "fuck you" money - more money just makes you more fucked. www.politico.com/news/magazin...
politico.com
‘The Terror Is Real’: An Appalled Tech Industry Is Scared to Criticize Elon Musk
A huge swath of Silicon Valley is horrified by what Elon Musk is doing — but they’re increasingly afraid to say so.
000
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 03/04/2025
“Sinks in” - Could there be a funnier headline about “efficient” markets? Like the market is Homer Simpson slapping his forehead, “doh!”
000
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Abigail Larson @abigaillarson.com · 21/01/2025
Today in Milan, a student activist group hung a trash-filled effigy of Musk upside down on a gate outside of piazzale Loreto, where Mussolini's body was displayed in 1945. They left the message: "C'è sempre posto a piazzale Loreto, Elon" (There's always room in piazzale Loreto, Elon)
photo of a bodysuit filled with garbage and a taped portrait of Elon Musk hangs upside down on the gate near piazzale Loreto in Milan, Italy. Photo from Ansa Italia 2025
312290349602
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 23/12/2024
It’s because of the crackdown in New Jersey.
020
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 20/12/2024
Alright, here's a more #strategy specific question. What do academic strategists think of Hamilton Helmer's 7 Powers: The Foundations of Business Strategy? I've just come across it and it seems like a pretty good synthesis of defensible sources of advantage, which he calls power. Your thoughts?
262
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 20/12/2024
Actually, the interesting question is how the case of BlueSky fits or doesn't fit the analogies and models people are offering here. @kissane.bsky.social seems to be right that no amount of moderating tools or "federated" systems will keep a commuinity safe once it becomes popular. That tracks.
010
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 20/12/2024
Is anybody else I know reading and thinking about this analogy of the social web as a dangerous "dark forest"? I do wonder where and how quality human interactions can be supported in digital societies. Anyone got a favorite "cozy web" corner we can spoil? (don't say BlueSky - too late!)
020
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 09/12/2024
Guess who just edged Switzerland in an independent rating of train services in Europe? Way to go, Trenitalia. www.theguardian.com/world/2024/d...
theguardian.com
Eurostar the worst-performing rail service in Europe, campaigners find
Firm disputes Transport and Environment’s findings, which also ranked Deutsche Bahn as one of the least reliable
230
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 02/12/2024
How annoying that these announcements follow the cardinal sin of abstracts and pronounce the research as dealing with “important questions” without saying what they are or what has been found. Grrr
020
Reposted by Charlie Williams
Jukka Rintamäki @jugistoteles.bsky.social · 02/12/2024
How about a reverse form of management consulting where workers hire consultants to "reorganize" the management?
4273
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 01/12/2024
This is an interesting idea that knowledge work spawned its own backlash.
130
Charlie Williams @pontifc8.bsky.social · 01/12/2024
Sci fi -> transformer models -> LLMs
020