iiinova — where your digital self keeps evolving

Frontline teams will tell you that hate from customers is nothing new, but I really do think it will ramp up over the next few years, and I want to make sure our frontline teams don't suffer for it. /🧵

091

Create resources and support for your users/ customers who may also be the target of harassment and hate. Signal to them in signs/ messages/ FAQs/ knowledge bases/ etc. that your team will support them.

180

Let your team use fake names when responding to the public, or (even better) don't use names at all. Recognize that some open ways of signaling support (i.e. putting pronouns in your signature) will also open people up to harassment. Allow folks to make decisions based on what's right for them.

150

Create psychological safety for your team. Let them know that you have their back. Listen to them. Check in on them. Make sure they have benefits that cover mental health support. We're all going to need it.

It can be tempting to ask employees who are part of a marginalized community to help you create inclusive policies. @anikacolliernavaroli.com calls this "compelled identity labor": hire people whose explicit job is to be an expert, instead of voluntelling your employees who have other jobs to do.

Create a "no questions asked" escalation policy, so that frontline staff can escalate to a manager if they feel unsafe or unable to answer a question. Make sure that escalation chain goes all the way up to VP or C-Suite level so everyone is supported.

Write policies about expected user/ customer behavior, make them public, and hold people to them. "We will ban you if you disrespect or threaten our staff", for example. Or "We will ban you if you report trans people simply for being trans."

Get really clear with senior leaders of the company you work for about corporate values and how to uphold them. Create tricky hypothetical scenarios (i.e. your biggest client sends a racist email; someone threatens to sue you for having a DEI program) and get answers BEFORE you need them.

The 47th president proudly spoke against trans people and anti-racism in his inauguration speech: people will now feel more empowered to spew hate. If you manage support, marketing, trust & safety, etc. create a playbook NOW to support & empower your team to respond to hateful customers. 🧵

273

Huge thanks to the integrity institute and TSPA/ TrustCon for enabling these kinds of discussions among t&s folks. If you know of other conversations/ resources in this area, or are an expert and want to be on the podcast or chat TrustCon proposals, let me know!

3️⃣ @anikacolliernavaroli.com writes about the harms for moderators from marginalized communities asked to work on content that attacks them. www.cjr.org/tow_center/b...

162

2️⃣ @jenniolsonsf.bsky.social from GLAAD talks about advocating for the LGBTQ+ community with Meta; the challenges of balancing free speech w/ protecting marginalized communities; & suggestions for folks working at social media platforms to advocate for change. integrityinstitute.org/podcast/its-...

131

1️⃣ Nadah Feteih discusses how tech workers (in integrity and t&s teams) can speak up about ethical issues at their workplace; activism from within the industry; compelled identity labor, balancing speaking up and staying silent, and more. integrityinstitute.org/podcast/work...

131

Many of us working at tech companies are having to make moral and ethical decisions when it comes to where we work, what we work on, and what we speak up about. It's super difficult to know what to do, or even what your options are! 🧵 with resources

2218

Every t&s professional I know this week. ❤️ to those who are doing their best in wild times.

Alice dressed as the “this is fine” dog meme. She has on dog ears and is holding a coffee mug while the office behind her is burning.

Alice grimacing while holding a “this is fine” meme toy. It’s a dog sitting on a dumpster on fire.

0192

THIS IS WHAT STOOD OUT TO ME. As someone who had to deal with user-report only systems for years… they do not work.

020

It's fascinating because right now content moderation and general vibes is a main differentiator between Threads and X. When Threads feels more like X, they'll be closer competitors than ever before. Looking forward to more people here on Bluesky :)

020

Actually 1 more thing: This allows meta to dodge responsibility. “The users don’t like it. They reported it. It’s not us.” It won’t make moderation more fair or better. It’ll be less consistent. But gives Meta an excuse that is more politically accepted right now.

030

This, combined with the rollback of hate policies, is REALLY going to change the vibes of Meta-run platforms. /🧵

Honestly, I feel it’s often better to just not have the rule at all if you can’t proactively detect and remove violations. Automated detection isn’t perfect by any means, but it’s a heck of a lot better than user reports alone.

Other users will have their content removed after being reported, but feel it’s unfair because so many other people got away with it.

Relying on user reports alone means that the platform will have very spotty enforcement of some rules. Many users will get away with rules-violating behavior because it is never reported.

Policies are only as good as ENFORCEMENT— and consistent enforcement at that. I have learned this the hard way, when I was head of t&s at a platform with little no to automated detection.

130

— if other people are being hateful and harassing others, then users will want to fight back/ pile on/ get involved. … or they will want to leave.

If they see lots of folks doing something bad and it’s not immediately removed, they assume it’s ok and they won’t report. Even worse, they will often start exhibiting the same behavior themselves.

Most users don’t read policies. They’re not experts on which kinds of hate speech are ok and not ok (especially confusing on Meta’s platforms now, after recent policy changes). Mostly, users go along with the vibe of a place.

130

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 07/01/2025

One thing I haven’t seen anyone talk about with Meta’s moderation changes: now relying on manual user reports for “less severe” issues that still violate their policies, rather than using a combination of user reports and automated detection. It’s bad. Here’s why: 🧵

150

They claim it was a mistake and have reversed it (And I understand; I have made mistakes too!) But it's an interesting illustration of how speech & censorship goes both ways: it's hard to be Pro Free Speech (allowing speech against identities), while restricting content about those identities.

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 07/01/2025

Meta says they will "censor less" - including more speech about gender identity (allow hate speech against trans people) WHILE ALSO Today User Mag reports Instagram restricting content on searches for things like queer and nonbinary for teenagers who had the "sensitive content" filter turned on.

102

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 18/12/2024

Now this is a holiday card I can get behind… @heatherrasley.bsky.social trained ai on old Victorian holiday cards. Genius. glif.app/@Heather/gli... for more

An image of a skeleton surrounded by cherubs throwing paper at it. Text says “may your scrolling be merry”

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 18/12/2024

🔮 Behold: 2025 will bring change to the realm of trust & safety, yet it will feel exactly the same (chaotic and stressful). My predictions for next year (with wisdom from other t&s leaders): www.everythinginmoderation.co/2025-predict...

041

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 18/12/2024

If you’re interested in trust & safety, would you please fill out this quick survey, so I can write my newsletter about things you care about? survey.typeform.com/to/A7oqCg8s?...

survey.typeform.com

EiM & Anchor Change Survey 2024

Help improve EiM and Anchor Change at a crucial moment for content moderation and online speech

021

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 04/12/2024

Block the Negative Nancys! (They might be bots)

010

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 02/12/2024

Now seemed like the best time to share these words of encouragement. We're a few months out from TrustCon, the high of spending time together has dissipated, and we're all trying to muster some energy for a new year. <3

000

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 02/12/2024

I made a T&S zine! My question for folks at TrustCon was: What does the T&S community need to hear right now? Of course, the T&S community delivered. 21662382.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/216623...

You don't have to change the world for everyone today, but you can change someone's world today.
You are making this world a better place!
But also, you can stop working sometimes!!

When I felt like the safety of my community was on my shoulders (and that I was failing them, T&S folks grounded me. Thank you.
You're valued.

What does the T&S community need to hear right now?
(The zine project)

140

They’d be opt-in like blocklists work here, but without manual work. In theory it would be harder for people to sneak folks in the list out of spite. Just a policy in plain language.

000

I’d LOVE to see this here on Bluesky- they’re halfway there already with used-based blocklists. ( @aaron.bsky.team what do you think? 😄 )

everythinginmoderation.co

Could a more transparent, collaborative, and adaptable policy enforcement model combat cries of 'censorship' and empower diverse online communities to self-moderate? Open-source policy documents and AI-driven auditability might hold the key. Read more www.everythinginmoderation.co/fighting-com...

Fighting complexity with auditability

250

I’m going to have to try this!!!

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 22/11/2024

The expert of t&s 🧵strikes again! Such an important read.

Gabriela Zanfir-Fortuna @gzf.bsky.social · 21/11/2024

Reposted by Alice Hunsberger

Full room this morning at #IAPP #DPC24 for a panel discussing “Implications and Expectations for Digital Policy of the new US Administration”, with US digital policy heavyweights - Cameron Kerry, @JulesPolonetsky.bsky.social (@FutureofPrivacy.bsky.social) & Caitlin Fennessy (IAPP). 1/

Panel with Cameron Kerry (The Brookings Institution), Jules Polonetsky (Future of Privacy Forum) and Caitlin Fennessy (IAPP).

1196

Reposted by Alice Hunsberger

Julia Serano @juliaserano.bsky.social · 19/11/2024

this essay is full of actual research showing trans women pose no threat to cis women in restrooms & other sex-segregated spaces. if you encounter any cis ppl discussing/debating the Mace/McBride/congressional restroom fuckery, pls share this link with them: juliaserano.medium.com/transgender-...

juliaserano.medium.com

Transgender People, Bathrooms, and Sexual Predators: What the Data Say

Content Warning: while I will not be describing any actual instances of sexual violence or child sexual abuse, these issues (and false…

13634881606

Alice Hunsberger @aagh.bsky.social · 20/11/2024

Today is Trans Day of Remembrance. Trans lives matter. Trans rights matter.