Sign in

Heidi Schlumpf

@heidischlumpf.bsky.social
932 followers 194 following 294 posts

Religion journalist; co-host of the Francis Effect podcast Heidischlumpfwrites@gmail.com

PostsRepliesMedia
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 02/10/2026
Catholics could be a key voting block, and there are plenty of efforts to mobilize them for the midterms. With @stephenschneck.bsky.social @networklobby.bsky.social @ignatiansolidarity.bsky.social Catholics Vote Common Good @commonwealmagazine.org www.commonwealmagazine.org/heidi-schlum...
commonwealmagazine.org
Can Catholic Voters Tip the Midterms?
Since Catholic voters were pivotal in helping re-elect Trump, they could now step up to start trying to fix this mess.
021
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 01/10/2026
Want more from @heidischlumpf.bsky.social? Subscribe to The First Word, Heidi's newsletter guide to the week ahead in religion, politics, and culture. First edition drops this Monday! mailchi.mp/commonwealma...
012
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 30/09/2026
mailchi.mp/commonwealma...
001
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
Exciting news: I will be writing a free weekly newsletter that begins next Monday. Sign up below!
064
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 24/09/2026
New episode: A continued exploration of the new papal encyclical and analysis of Bishop Barron's recent attacks on so-called "toxic empathy." Also, an interview with theologian Ed Hahnenberg about synodality and ministry. @daultradio.bsky.social francisfxpod.com/current/2610
francisfxpod.com
Bishop Barron on empathy, Magnifica Humanitas Chapter 1, and an interview with Ed Hahnenberg — The Francis Effect
Heidi, Daniel, and David continue their explorations of the new papal encyclical, and they bring a critical eye to Bishop Barron's recent attacks on so-called "toxic empathy." Heidi brings us an inter...
062
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Dominic Preziosi @dominicpreziosi.bsky.social · 18/09/2026
Two good conversations on the @commonwealmagazine.org podcast: nat'l correspondent @heidischlumpf.bsky.social on midterms, converts, & migration @avilacosnahan.bsky.social w Gabrielle Oliveira on what it means for mothers and children to cross borders www.commonwealmagazine.org/podcast/all-...
commonwealmagazine.org
‘All We Want Is to Live’
More than 5,000 children were separated from their families during the first Trump administration. What happened after they reunited?
022
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 19/09/2026
The next episode of the Commonweal podcast--which now includes a brief conversation with me about recent Catholic news--is out. Plus a fascinating interview about family separation. www.commonwealmagazine.org
commonwealmagazine.org
Commonweal Magazine
Commonweal's mission is to provide a forum for civil, reasoned debate on the interaction of faith with contemporary politics and culture.
011
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 16/09/2026
Looking forward to this daylong conference at Loyola on Saturday. I'll be part of a panel discussing "What Does This Mean for the Church" at 130 pm. Hope to see you there! www.luc.edu/ccih/events/...
luc.edu
“Let All Who Are Thirsty, Come: Examining the Appeal of Catholicism and Rise in Conversions Among Young Adults”: Loyola University Chicago
<h5>September 19, 2026</h5> <p>A conference cosponsored by the Hank Center and Mission Integration exploring the increase of inquirers and conversions to the Catholic Church. Panels of practitioners, ...
010
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
In my latest piece in @commonwealmagazine.org,I look at the new converts to Catholicism and discover that while they are attracted to the church's truth, tradition and beauty, that doesn't mean they're all rad-trads. www.commonwealmagazine.org/new-converts
commonwealmagazine.org
The New Converts
Catholic converts may be seeking tradition in a time of chaos, but many fall far outside the conservative "rad trad" stereotype.
251
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 11/09/2026
"Never forget the day, but also remember what has transpired in the days since." --Dominic Preziosi www.commonwealmagazine.org/preziosi-sep...
commonwealmagazine.org
9/11 Changed Everything
Twenty-five years later, 9/11 continues to cast a shadow on American politics. In remembering the day, we must also remember its tragic aftermath.
020
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 10/09/2026
In this episode, we dive into the new papal encyclical for a season-long exploration of its themes and discuss the Season of Creation during a time of increasing climate peril. Plus an interview with @stephenschneck.bsky.social of Catholics for the Future. francisfxpod.com/current/2609
francisfxpod.com
The Season of Creation, Magnifica Humanitas Introduction, and an interview with Steve Schneck — The Francis Effect
Heidi, Daniel, and David dive in to the new papal encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas , for a season-long exploration of its themes and meanings. They also catch up on their summer activities, and ponder...
010
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 03/09/2026
"When the only thing most Americans seem to agree on is the fact that we don’t agree on much of anything, it’s worth asking how a country singer came to exemplify a unity that otherwise escapes us." My latest piece in Commonweal: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-dol...
commonwealmagazine.org
Why Did Dolly Mean So Much to Us?
Dolly Parton's non-judgmental faith could be a lesson for many of today’s Christians.
020
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 31/08/2026
The long-overdue shift is noticeable, even to people outside the church. My most recent piece in Commonweal: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-hei...
commonwealmagazine.org
Catholic Social Teaching Is Having a Moment
Suddenly, a lot of folks are taking the Church’s social teaching seriously. The shift is noticeable even to those outside the Church.
1268
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 19/08/2026
Wise analysis from my Commonweal colleague Massimo Faggioli. @massimofaggioli.bsky.social www.commonwealmagazine.org/faggioli-dou...
commonwealmagazine.org
Learning from Ross Douthat
As a New York Times columnist, Ross Douthat's commentary on the Church was defined by a central antagonist: Pope Francis.
092
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 12/08/2026
The allegations against Fr. Michael Pfleger have once again put the Catholic Church’s procedures around sexual abuse of minors in the spotlight. @heidischlumpf.bsky.social: 'A Fair Process?' www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-pfl...
commonwealmagazine.org
A Fair Process?
The allegations against Fr. Michael Pfleger have once again put the Catholic Church’s procedures around sexual abuse of minors in the spotlight.
011
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 12/08/2026
Some priests are questioning how allegations of sexual abuse are investigated, but victims say the process still favors clergy. My piece in Commonweal: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-pfl...
commonwealmagazine.org
A Fair Process?
The allegations against Fr. Michael Pfleger have once again put the Catholic Church’s procedures around sexual abuse of minors in the spotlight.
011
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 24/07/2026
I had hoped that the novel, "Yesteryear" would give me more understanding of the tradwife phenomenon, but it failed to deliver. My reflections, plus some insights from two historians who study conservative women. www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-hei...
commonwealmagazine.org
Why We Love to Hate Tradwives
“Yesteryear,” this year’s breakout novel, promises insights into the antifeminist phenomenon, but it doesn’t deliver.
010
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 17/07/2026
I was on @fox32chicago.bsky.social to talk about policies for priests accused of sex abuse. One thing I note: Bishops, unlike priests, are not removed while being investigated. Watch here: www.fox32chicago.com/video/fmc-mx...
fox32chicago.com
St. Sabina defends Father Pfleger amid new sex abuse allegations
St. Sabina leadership and supporters stand by Father Michael Pfleger following new sex abuse allegations. Commonweal Senior Correspondent Heidi Schlumpf joins The Loop to discuss the latest developmen...
151
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 14/07/2026
"It’s not every day you hear a couple of sheep discussing the nature of God." @heidischlumpf.bsky.social writes on grief, faith, and memory in 'The Sheep Detectives':
commonwealmagazine.org
Of Sheep, Grief, and Memory
'The Sheep Detectives' is a family-friendly whodunit that also takes up profound questions about the human condition. Its worldview isn't wholly incompatible with the complexity of our faith.
021
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 02/07/2026
Just in time for the nation's 250th, my visit to the Obama Presidential Center restored my hope in democracy but the contrasts to today were striking. My piece in @commonwealmagazine.org @obamafoundation.bsky.social www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-oba...
commonwealmagazine.org
‘You Are America’
The Obama Center is surely a monument to one man’s leadership—but it also issues a call to every American to do their part in making the country a better place.
051
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 29/06/2026
I listened to a bunch of Vice President JD Vance's interviews about his new book "Communion" so you don't have to. He sounds more like a politician looking for votes than a spiritual seeker. My latest piece @commonwealmagazine.org : www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-van...
commonwealmagazine.org
Book Tour or Campaign Stump?
When J.D. Vance discusses his faith journey, he is careful not to offend any constituencies he may need in a presidential run.
072
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 26/06/2026
A few weeks ago I interviewed Bishop Steven Biegler of Cheyenne, Wyoming about his pastoral letter on immigration. Yesterday's SCOTUS decisions make this all the more urgent. Listen here at the @commonwealmagazine.org podcast: www.commonwealmagazine.org/podcast/how-...
commonwealmagazine.org
How to Exit ‘Enemy Mode’ on Immigration
Catholic social doctrine holds mass deportation is plainly immoral. Here’s how one bishop in deep-red Wyoming is pressing the case for compassion.
041
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 24/06/2026
As we wait for the SCOTUS decision on birthright citizenship, a reminder that the US bishops support it. My piece ICYMI: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-bir...
commonwealmagazine.org
Fight for the Fourteenth
The bishops filed an amicus brief in support of birthright citizenship. Conservative critics aren’t happy.
031
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 18/06/2026
If their latest meeting is any indication, U.S. bishops may be letting synodality fade—even on issues as important as the abuse crisis. My piece in @commonwealmagazine.org www.commonwealmagazine.org/whatever-hap...
commonwealmagazine.org
Whatever Happened to Synodality?
If their latest meeting is any indication, U.S. bishops may be letting synodality fade—even on issues as important as the abuse crisis.
030
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 12/06/2026
Religious leaders and communities cannot become complacent on immigration. As the midterm elections approach, the Church must embrace more explicitly political strategies to combat Trump’s war on immigrants. My latest with Dylan Corbett of Hope Border: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-ice...
commonwealmagazine.org
Changing the Calculus of Power
As the midterm elections approach, the Church must embrace more explicitly political strategies to combat Trump's war on immigrants.
033
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 02/06/2026
ICYMI I forgot to post this interview with the amazing data master Ryan Burge, who dispels all kinds of myths about American religion. His newish book is "The Vanishing Church." www.commonwealmagazine.org/great-sort-a...
commonwealmagazine.org
The ‘Great Sort’ in American Religion
Political scientist and statistician Ryan Burge discusses polarization, declining institutions, and the future of religion in the United States.
022
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 29/05/2026
"Can the Church bear a credible witness on technology, on just war, on what it means to be human?" NEW from @heidischlumpf.bsky.social on 'Magnifica humanitas' and the credibility of the Church:
commonwealmagazine.org
Will the Encyclical Reach ‘People of Goodwill’?
If the Church itself does not recognize the full humanity of half its own members, how can it expect Silicon Valley and heads of state to respect its sermon on human dignity?
052
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
#Magnificashumanitas deserves the widest possible reading and consideration. But Until the Church practices what it preaches, it might not get the welcome reception it deserves. My column @commonwealmagazine.org : www.commonwealmagazine.org/leo-magnific...?
commonwealmagazine.org
Will the Encyclical Reach ‘People of Goodwill’?
If the Church itself does not recognize the full humanity of half its own members, how can it expect Silicon Valley and heads of state to respect its sermon on human dignity?
042
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 28/05/2026
The best summary and analysis of Pope Leo's encyclical I've read so far is this one by Antonio Spadaro @antoniospadaro.bsky.social www.commonwealmagazine.org/spadaro-leo-...
commonwealmagazine.org
Pope Leo and the ‘Babel Syndrome’
What Leo XIII did for wages and the right of association, Leo XIV does for the human person in the era of the algorithm.
083
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 25/05/2026
"Calling for prudence, rigorous evaluation and even, at times, a slower pace in adopting AI does not mean opposing progress; instead, it is an exercise of responsible care for the human family." #magnificahumanitas www.reuters.com/technology/q...
reuters.com
Quotes from Pope Leo's document warning world of AI risks
Below are snippets from the document, a nearly 43,000-word encyclical titled "Magnifica Humanitas."
081
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 22/05/2026
Trump is not only the most corrupt president in American history—he is more corrupt than all other corrupt presidents by orders of magnitude. Commonweal's editorial: www.commonwealmagazine.org/trump-editor...
commonwealmagazine.org
A Presidential Smash and Grab
Trump is not only the most corrupt president in American history—he is more corrupt than all other corrupt presidents by orders of magnitude.
022
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 21/05/2026
I maintain, however, that his liturgical dance to “The King of Glory” is his funniest performance ever—something only a Catholic who grew up in the 1960s and ’70s could know to mock. (Video below) www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-col...
commonwealmagazine.org
Colbert the Critic
By serving as a voice for truth and challenging Americans to think critically about complex political issues, Colbert will go down in history as more than a comedian.
150
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 20/05/2026
Why I think Stephen Colbert will go down in history as one of the bravest and most effective cultural critics of his generation. www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-col...
commonwealmagazine.org
Colbert the Critic
By serving as a voice for truth and challenging Americans to think critically about complex political issues, Colbert will go down in history as more than a comedian.
081
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 13/05/2026
A more holistic alternative to the Cardinal Newman Society-style of Catholic identity for colleges and universities. My piece, based on the research of Jason King. @jking66.bsky.social www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-cat...
commonwealmagazine.org
Leaning into Catholic Identity
These are tough times for Catholic colleges and universities. A commitment to educating the whole person remains the best path forward.
071
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 08/05/2026
"It’s not just an issue about equal opportunities for women and laymen; it’s about the need for better preaching, which requires diverse voices in the pulpit." @heidischlumpf.bsky.social makes the case for lay preaching:
commonwealmagazine.org
The Case for Lay Preaching
Allowing lay preaching in the pulpit during Sunday liturgy would model that the Church is serious about synodality.
072
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 06/05/2026
Thanks to @brianmackey.com for inviting me on NPR's @21st.show to talk about Pope Leo and US politics. Also featuring my former colleague Mary FioRito! (And an interview with Cardinal Cupich, which I will link to in comments) will.illinois.edu/21stshow/sto...
to.talk
112
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 01/05/2026
New feature on the Commonweal podcast: Me!--discussing the news with Editor Dominic Preziosi. Then stay for the amazing interview with Fr. Jim Martin on the topic of work and vocation. www.commonwealmagazine.org/podcast/humb...
commonwealmagazine.org
Humble Work
Many of us have jobs we don’t enjoy. Fr. James Martin explains how we can make our work meaningful anyway.
031
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Commonweal @commonwealmagazine.org · 29/04/2026
Trump keeps pushing policies that are opposed by Catholic teaching—and this U.S.-born pope doesn’t seem to be willing to keep quiet about them. @heidischlumpf.bsky.social on Trump, Leo, and capital punishment:
commonwealmagazine.org
Pope and President, at Odds Again?
Trump keeps pushing policies that are opposed by Catholic teaching—and this U.S.-born pope doesn’t seem to be willing to keep quiet about them.
041
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 29/04/2026
Trump keeps pushing policies that are opposed by Catholic teaching—and this U.S.-born pope doesn’t seem to be willing to keep quiet about them. My reflections on the coincidentally dueling statements on the death penalty last week. www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-leo...
commonwealmagazine.org
Pope and President, at Odds Again?
Trump keeps pushing policies that are opposed by Catholic teaching—and this U.S.-born pope doesn’t seem to be willing to keep quiet about them.
062
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 23/04/2026
In the last Francis Effect episode of this season, we discuss the saga of US political leaders trying to lecture the Pope on Catholic doctrine, then consider Earth Day as a lament. Plus guest Natalia Imperatori-Lee about the upcoming Women's Ordination Conference. francisfxpod.com/current/2608
francisfxpod.com
President Trump's clashes with Pope Leo, Earth Day and ecospirituality, and an interview with Natalia Imperatori-Lee — The Francis Effect
Heidi, Daniel, and David discuss the continuing saga of American political leaders trying to lecture the Pope on Catholic doctrine, and then they turn to a discussion of the recent Earth Day remembran...
010
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 23/04/2026
GOP attacks on Pope Leo misunderstand the social demands of the Gospel. (And they cherry pick which issues it's OK for the church to be political about). My column: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-tru...
commonwealmagazine.org
In Praise of a Political Church
The Church is gaining credibility for speaking up for Gospel values in the public square—even when it means criticizing a president that nearly 60 percent of Catholic voters chose.
361
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Dr. Kate Ward @thekateward.bsky.social · 20/04/2026
I am late in sharing this but it was great to talk our current economic reality with @heidischlumpf.bsky.social on The Francis Effect last month! francisfxpod.com/current/2606
francisfxpod.com
Cesar Chavez controversy, Pope Leo speaks out against the Middle East war, and an interview with Kate Ward — The Francis Effect
Heidi, Daniel, and David look at recent horrific revelations about the labor leader, Cesar Chavez, as well as exploring the Pope's pushback against the war with Iran. In our third segment, Heidi inter...
031
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 17/04/2026
The recent Supreme Court decision seems to give a green light to the discredited and dangerous practice of conversion therapy, which is actually prevalent and widespread in Catholic circles. My story: www.commonwealmagazine.org/conversion-t...
commonwealmagazine.org
Get Conversion Therapy Out of the Church
Conversion therapy is psychologically unhealthy and spiritually hazardous. Catholic bishops and organizations must stop supporting it.
153
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 15/04/2026
Finally got my voice back (literally, after being sick) so was able to give my two cents about the Trump v. Pope brouhaha: www.fox32chicago.com/video/fmc-p8...
fox32chicago.com
Trump, Pope Leo XIV clash draws reaction from religious leaders | ChicagoNOW
Tensions escalate between President Donald Trump and Pope Leo XIV after the president criticized the Chicago-born pope’s stance on global conflict and shared a controversial AI image of himself as a r...
012
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 13/04/2026
Chicago area peeps: I'll be doing this presentation at Old St. Pat's next Sunday evening. Would love to see some of you there. Register here: osp.ccbchurch.com/goto/forms/1...?
osp.ccbchurch.com
Old St. Patrick's Church
021
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 09/04/2026
"RNS has been unable to independently confirm many of the details of the story ...but in a statement sent to RNS on Wednesday, a Department of Defense official confirmed the meeting occurred, while disputing The Free Press’ assessment." religionnews.com/2026/04/08/p...
religionnews.com
Pentagon-Vatican meeting latest flash point in Trump's clash with religious leaders
WASHINGTON (RNS) — The increase in faith-fueled militaristic rhetoric is pitting the president against a growing list of faith leaders, ranging from local clergy to the pope.
000
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 09/04/2026
In a new episode of the Francis Effect, we discuss Pope Leo's anti-war stance during his first Holy Week and the US bishops' role in the SCOTUS conversion therapy decision. Guest Aaron Robertson discusses the history of Black Catholics in Detroit. francisfxpod.com/current/2607
francisfxpod.com
Pope Leo's first Holy Week, Supreme Court conversion therapy decision, and an interview with Aaron Robertson — The Francis Effect
Heidi, Daniel, and David discuss Pope Leo's strong anti-war stance during his first Holy Week, and they explore the role of the USCCB in a recent Supreme Court decision about conversion therapy. Then Heidi interviews Aaron Robertson about the history of Black Catholics, with a focus on the history o
050
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 06/04/2026
Looking forward to my visit to Dominican University in River Forest tomorrow. More info for my 5 pm talk here: @DominicanU www.dom.edu/arts-minds/s...
dom.edu
Diane Kennedy, OP Lecture: Truth-telling in a Time of Mistrust | Dominican University
In an era of alternative facts and artificial intelligence hallucinations, people don’t know who or what to trust, but the values of honesty and credibility are more important than ever. Catholic jour...
030
Heidi Schlumpf @heidischlumpf.bsky.social · 01/04/2026
As SCOTUS hears oral arguments in the birthright citizenship case today, the US bishops filed an amicus brief in support of birthright citizenship. My piece: www.commonwealmagazine.org/schlumpf-bir...
commonwealmagazine.org
Fight for the Fourteenth
The bishops filed an amicus brief in support of birthright citizenship. Conservative critics aren’t happy.
010
Reposted by Heidi Schlumpf
Call to Action @ctacatholics.bsky.social · 29/03/2026
Love this article by @heidischlumpf.bsky.social about our friends @ordainwomen.bsky.social and their 50th anniversary--as we prepare to celebrate ours this fall! Learn more about our plans to celebrate 50 years on our website: cta50.org www.commonwealmagazine.org/women-priest...
122