Sign in

Christian Hilbe

@chilbe.bsky.social
661 followers 601 following 30 posts

Professor at @ituaustria.bsky.social, interested in math, game theory, and cooperation web.evolbio.mpg.de/social-behaviour

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Chadi Saad-Roy @chadisaadroy.bsky.social · 18/03/2026
Very excited to share our latest article in Trends in Microbiology, with @ninan-abraham.bsky.social, @chilbe.bsky.social, @ayesha-mahmud.bsky.social, and Arne Traulsen! We highlight the importance of disentangling these interactions and suggest potential paths forwards
0147
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Joshua Weitz @joshuasweitz.bsky.social · 11/02/2026
Job opportunities... Newly launched Quantitative Biology Initiative in the Department of Biology at the University of Maryland, College Park seeks applications for three collaborative postdoctoral fellowships. Best consideration date 3/14. Full Details: umd.wd1.myworkdayjobs.com/en-US/UMCP/j...
32230
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Jeremy Van Cleve @vancleve.theoretical.bio · 21/01/2026
Please join us for a @smtpb.bsky.social panel discussion about publishing theory in biology w/ @joshuasweitz.bsky.social (Co-Chief Editor of J Theor Biol), Mark Lewis (Advising Editor for J Math Biol & Bull Math Biol), and me (Theor Pop Biol) 13 Feb 2026 9:00AM–10:00AM PST smtpb.org/event-6520871
smtpb.org
Society for Modeling and Theory in Population Biology - How the papers are made: look behind the scenes of publishing models and theory in population biology with current journal editors
02216
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
I personally learned a lot from both projects; the first authors have put a lot of work into them (of course, all other authors too 😀). End of 🧵
110
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
However, for nonlinear games, we find that any form of (endowment) inequality is detrimental, because it renders successful coordination more difficult.
110
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
For linear games, we find that certain forms of inequality can be advantageous: the largest surplus is achieved when more productive participants receive larger endowments. This confirms previous results among western online participants, doi.org/10.1038/s415...
doi.org
Social dilemmas among unequals - Nature
A framework that includes inequality shows that extreme inequality prevents cooperation, but overall welfare is maximized when endowments and productivities are aligned such that more-productive indiv...
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
To explore this question, Xiaomin studied a large sample of Chinese lab participants (N>1,500) to explore contributions in public good games. We varied group size, endowments, productivities, and whether the public goods game leads to linear or non-linear rewards (using a threshold function).
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
The second paper, with Xiaomin Wang and Boyu Zhang focuses on an empirical question: to which extent do different asymmetries between players affect their ability to cooperate and coordinate?
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
In the paper, Philip gives an elegant (sufficient) condition for strategy spaces to be both best reply complete and payoff complete. His result builds on important previous work by Levinski et al, link.springer.com/article/10.1...
doi.org
Should I remember more than you? Best responses to factored strategies - International Journal of Game Theory
In this paper we offer a new, unifying approach to modeling strategies of bounded complexity. In our model, the strategy of a player in a game does not directly map the set H of histories to the set o...
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
A space S is "best reply complete" if any strategy p in S has a best reply in S. The space is "payoff complete" if any payoff achievable against p (with an arbitrary strategy) can be realized with a strategy in S. Both notions address whether strategies outside S can outperform strategies within S.
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
The question is this: if some strategy p is superior in a restricted space S, how would we know whether this strategy would still perform well if we allowed for more complex strategies than those in S? To address this question, Philip introduces two notions of "complete strategy spaces".
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
The paper with @plaporte.bsky.social, @nikoletaglyn.bsky.social and Martin Nowak asks an important theoretical question. Repeated games allow for (uncountably) many strategies. To facilitate an analysis, researchers often study simplified subspaces. To which extent are such results reliable?
130
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 30/01/2026
Yesterday, two papers appeared in @pnas.org, to which I contributed to. Both papers deal with strategic behavior in repeated games. Apart from that, they are quite different. A 🧵 doi.org/10.1073/pnas... doi.org/10.1073/pnas...
Depiction of a public good game among two players
1163
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Nikoleta Glynatsi @nikoletaglyn.bsky.social · 03/11/2025
🗞️📣 New paper "Exact conditions for evolutionary stability in indirect reciprocity under noise" with @chilbe.bsky.social & @yohm.bsky.social How can cooperation persist in large groups of unrelated individuals? Reputation 🗣️ But which social norms make this stable, even when mistakes happen? 🧵(1/6)
journals.plos.org
Exact conditions for evolutionary stability in indirect reciprocity under noise
Author summary Understanding how cooperation can evolve and be sustained is a central question in evolutionary biology and social science. One prominent explanation is indirect reciprocity, where indi...
1185
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Saptarshi Pal @saptarshi.bsky.social · 02/07/2025
A different view of direct reciprocity in the evolution of cooperation. The enduring strategy in an evolving population need not be discriminators if unconditional cooperators can occasionally mutate to a conditional strategy in presence of defectors. royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/...
royalsocietypublishing.org
Stabilizing unconditional cooperation | Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences
The ultimate goal of research on the evolution of cooperation could be conceived as finding a method for stabilizing strategies that always cooperate, that never deviate from cooperation, that never e...
2128
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
PNAS Nexus @pnasnexus.org · 23/06/2025
A model of direct and indirect reciprocity—in which people act more favorably to people with good reputations—finds that full cooperation can always be sustained as a Nash equilibrium. In PNAS Nexus: academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/ar...
 Strategies of reciprocity differ in whether players (here, player 1) take into account third-party interactions (here, between players 2 and 3). According to direct reciprocity, player 1 ignores third-party interactions. According to indirect reciprocity, player 1 takes such third-party interactions into account. The study's framework also allows for intermediate cases, where player 1 considers third-party interactions with some fixed probability λ.
171
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 18/06/2025
Although I'm formally a co-author of this paper, I actually learned quite a bit myself about both complex systems and multiagent learning while working on this project. Thanks Wolfram for leading this really nice effort to bring fields closer together!
030
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Wolfram Barfuss @wbarfuss.bsky.social · 17/06/2025
How to cooperate for a sustainable future? We don't know (yet), but I'm thrilled to share that our new perspective piece has just been published in @pnas.org. Bridging complexity science and multiagent reinforcement learning can lead to a much-needed science of collective, cooperative intelligence.
1116
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/05/2025
This is a great opportunity to work with @yohm.bsky.social, one of the leading researchers in evolutionary game theory these days. 🙂 I can only recommend applying ⬇️
062
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
🎭 Adile Yasar @adileyasar.bsky.social · 11/05/2025
A little text about my journey with bipolar disorder. Seeing scientists speak openly about their experiences encouraged me to help break the stigma too. A part of me feels insecure about sharing this, but it also feels like the right thing to do. adileyasar.github.io/one-of-these...
adileyasar.github.io
Texts
2191
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
theobioarne.bsky.social @theobioarne.bsky.social · 09/04/2025
Corina Tarnita and I have discussed the relation between theoretical ecology and evolutionary game theory since my sabbatical in 2022. Now the paper is out, doi.org/10.1073/pnas... Cooperation in nature may not be mysterious when there are growth differences- questioning the notion of cooperation.
doi.org
Reconciling ecology and evolutionary game theory or “When not to think cooperation” | PNAS
Evolutionary game theory (EGT)—overwhelmingly employed today for the study of cooperation in various systems, from microbes to cancer and from inse...
1278
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Franziska Lesigang @franzilesi.bsky.social · 06/04/2025
How valuable is memory? In my very first paper, now published in Economics Letters, together with @chilbe.bsky.social and @nikoletaglyn.bsky.social, we give sufficient conditions under which a player can afford to remember less than their opponent. 🧵 📜 doi.org/10.1016/j.ec...
4385
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Eleanor Power @eapower.bsky.social · 01/04/2025
🚨Job alert! Two-year postdoc to join the Rep2SI project at @lsemethodology.bsky.social! We're looking for a modeller to join our team of ethnographers & experimentalists studying the role of reputation and reputational concern in perpetuating social inequality. Apply by 4 May: tinyurl.com/yjccd3vv
Rep2SI: Reputation & the Reproduction of Social Inequality. A Leverhulme-funded project based at the LSE, combining ethnography, economic games, and modelling. We're looking for a modeller to join our core team as a two-year postdoctoral research officer.
14345
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 17/03/2025
Awesome news, congrats! 🙂
120
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Lucas Molleman @lucasmolleman.bsky.social · 17/02/2025
Just two days left to apply for this postdoc position in @bjornlindstrom.bsky.social's group in Stockholm, on an exciting project on social learning and cultural evolution ki.varbi.com/en/what:job/... in collaboration with Piet van den Berg (Leuven) and myself (Amsterdam). Reposts welcome!
ki.varbi.com
Postdoctoral Researcher in computational psychology/cognitive science with focus on social learning and cultural evolution
Do you want to contribute to top quality research? The Mechanisms of Social Behavior lab at the Karolinska Institutet in Stockholm, Sweden is seeking a highly qualified postdoctoral researchers to joi
0811
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Hannes Rusch @hannesrusch.bsky.social · 14/02/2025
🚨 POSTDOC WANTED 🚨 Join the Behavioral Economics of Crime & Conflict Group at MPICSL in Freiburg! We're seeking a behavioral scientist with PhD in economics, psychology, or related. Experience with experiments is key. Full time, 2 years, no teaching. Apply now! tinyurl.com/FGR251 #EconSky
12121
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 16/02/2025
Thanks for making me aware of the paper! I'm wondering whether the choice of game makes the difference here (volunteer's dilemma versus prisoner's dilemma). Either way, I'll have to read the paper more closely! :-)
110
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 12/02/2025
Thanks for making me aware! It seems to me the two studies have slightly different setups (in ours, participants keep their co-player for many rounds, and they "only" engage in two different versions of a prisoner's dilemma). But I like your setup and your results a lot!
110
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 12/02/2025
Thanks David!
000
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 12/02/2025
When individuals engage in several games, there can be spillovers from one game to another. In principle, such spillovers could be used strategically to promote cooperation across games. However, our experiment suggests people in concurrent games cooperate less, compared to a control treatment.
130
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 12/02/2025
In game theory, we often assume that people only interact in one game at a time. In a new paper, we explore theoretically and experimentally how people cooperate when they engage in two games concurrently, either with the same partner or with different partners, www.nature.com/articles/s41...
54515
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Dominik Deffner @dominikdeffner.bsky.social · 03/02/2025
🏰 PhD position on computational modelling | collective dynamics | cultural evolution 🏰 Get in touch with any questions you might have and join me in beautiful Marburg! stellenangebote.uni-marburg.de/jobposting/c... (Deutsch) stellenangebote.uni-marburg.de/jobposting/3... (English)
28591
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
theobioarne.bsky.social @theobioarne.bsky.social · 10/01/2025
🚨 Annual IMPRS Call for Doctoral Positions at MPI-EvolBio 🚨 🎓 Fully-funded 3.5-year doctoral projects available in diverse research areas! #PhD #ResearchOpportunities #IMPRS #Science evolbio.mpg.de/3801127/annu...
01212
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 07/01/2025
✈️
010
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 07/01/2025
We miss you already. Have a great start! 🙂
120
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Nikoleta Glynatsi @nikoletaglyn.bsky.social · 07/01/2025
I am genuinely very excited to announce that I am officially a Research Scientist at the RIKEN Center for Computational Science in the Discrete Event Simulation team, led by Nobuyasu Ito! 🇯🇵 🗾 🗻
4313
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Julien Lie-Panis @jliep.bsky.social · 16/12/2024
How do institutions enable large-scale cooperation? 🤝 Institutions promote cooperation but depend on cooperation to function. In a new study in @pnas.org, @jbaptistandre.bsky.social, N. Baumard, @lfitouchi.bsky.social and I explore this paradox. 🧵 👉 www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/...
pnas.org
PNAS
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), a peer reviewed journal of the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) - an authoritative source of high-impact, original research that broadly spans...
34118
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 11/12/2024
A very nice journey with a great ending: In a new paper, @NikoletaGlyn describes how longer memory allows people to sustain reciprocal cooperation. For details, see 🧵 below 👇 Paper: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/...
pnas.org
Conditional cooperation with longer memory | PNAS
Direct reciprocity is a wide-spread mechanism for the evolution of cooperation. In repeated interactions, players can condition their behavior on p...
0178
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Mason Youngblood @masonyoungblood.bsky.social · 05/12/2024
Université PSL's new research network CultureLab is hiring two 5-year postdocs to develop computational methods to analyze cultural, historical, and social data! Research budget included - Deadline on 12-15-24, details below ⬇️
11312
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Tiago Peixoto @tiago.skewed.de · 29/11/2024
Last chance! Deadline tomorrow!
068
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Florence Bansept @florencebansept.bsky.social · 25/11/2024
Our new paper in #PLOSBiology is out! With Román Zapién-Campos and Arne Traulsen we worked on extracting maximum statistical information from microbiome time series data for parameter inference. Check it out!
0198
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Tiago Peixoto @tiago.skewed.de · 25/11/2024
🚨Job alert!🚨 Come join us at the Inverse Complexity Lab @invcomplexity.skewed.de We’re hiring a post-doctoral researcher to join our group at IT:U, Linz, Austria. skewed.de/lab/call.html Deadline is 30 Nov 2024. (Next Saturday!) Spread the word. #networkscience #complexsystems
skewed.de
Open post-doc position at the Inverse Complexity Lab – Tiago P. Peixoto
Inverse Complexity Lab
12027
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 23/11/2024
Wow, thanks for sharing. What a great blogpost! 🙂
010
Reposted by Christian Hilbe
Dr Nadiah Kristensen @nadiah.bsky.social · 22/11/2024
I recently read a paper by Kleshnina and others and used it to teach myself some evolutionary game theory techniques. This is a little obscure, so I'll thread below about why this topic matters for humans and the environment 🧵 nadiah.org/2024/11/20/k...
nadiah.org
Check if an iterated Prisoner’s Dilemma strategy is a subgame perfect Nash equilibrium
I recently read a paper by Kleshnina et al. (2023), The effect of environmental information on evolution of cooperation in stochastic games, which provided an opportunity to teach myself about how to ...
2216
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
Opinions tend to become strongly correlated, for example, when social interactions are widely observable. Alternatively, they become correlated when individuals use gossip to synchronize their views. Here is an open version of the paper: arxiv.org/abs/2409.05551
arxiv.org
Indirect reciprocity under opinion synchronization
Indirect reciprocity is a key explanation for the exceptional magnitude of cooperation among humans. This literature suggests that a large proportion of human cooperation is driven by social norms and...
110
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
These correlations depend on the structure of social interactions, but also on the social norm in place. We find that a norm can only sustain cooperation if the resulting opinions of different community members become sufficiently correlated.
110
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
Even if a given social norm is successful in one scenario, it might be unstable in another. In our paper, we try to organize these different findings by looking at a key variable: the extent to which individual opinions about others turn out to be correlated (synchronized).
220
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
Unfortunately, results in this literature often depend on subtle details. In particular, the stability of a norm typically depends on the precise structure of social interactions (how observable individual actions are, or to which extent people engage in gossip).
120
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
Some background: The literature on indirect reciprocity describes how people act when their reputation is at stake. It asks which social norms support cooperation, and which norms are stable (such that people have an incentive to follow them).
100
Christian Hilbe @chilbe.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
In a new paper published today, @yohm.bsky.social and I discuss a general framework to make sense of social norms and different indirect reciprocity models. Below is a 🧵, here is the paper: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/...
22815