Sign in

Ben Winters

@benwinters.bsky.social
2.6K followers 1.6K following 409 posts

director of AI and privacy at Consumer Federation of America | teaching tech policy law/reg @udclaw | formerly EPIC (the privacy one not the bad ones), and DOJ Civil Rights division| ⚫️⚪️+🗽 | 🐦 🐿 | he/him contact: bwinters@consumerfed.org

PostsRepliesMedia
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 1h
looking back at this awesome video I took on february 3, 2024 at the Warriors-Hawks game - Atlanta is beautiful that time of year
011
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 6h
psychotic disturbing behavior from a rambling homicidal loser - this person is in charge of such a chilling amount of access to people lives and benefits and deaths. it can not be understated how bad it is decision makers (on both sides worldwide) have repeatedly given him contracts/access
100
Reposted by Ben Winters
The Washington Sun @washingtonsun.bsky.social · 13h
The GAO says it cannot find assurances that DOGE properly handled Americans’ data. www.washingtonsun.com/agencies/doge…
washingtonsun.com
Congress’ Watchdog Arm Is Not Assured That DOGE Protected Americans’ Data
Several federal agencies did not answer the congressional auditor’s questions about data security.
46936
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 14h
that chatbot doing that unsafe/violative thing is not it 'going rogue' or an 'unfortunate incident of unintended consequences,' it’s the logical and devastating consequences of an unsafe product put out by irresponsible companies that have been conditioned to believe consequences dont exist for them
7736236
Reposted by Ben Winters
Tyler King @tyleraking.com · 29/09/2026
A key component of the Cambridge Analytica outrage was your friends subjecting you to data theft without your consent or knowledge. Facebook is running the same playbook on your text messages. Even if you’re not on Meta properties, they’re ingesting your interactions.
Aten installed Muse on both his iPhone and a Mac mini that he uses to test out various Al agents and tech. It took Meta a single day to begin "helpfully" pitching article ideas based on texts he'd sent to a podcast co-host.
When he asked Muse how it got the information, it said that it read banners from incoming texts. But that's not true, either.
After doing a little digging, Aten says Muse synced 187,000 lines from his Messages database, despite Full Disk Access being Off.Unless Aten is the most popular person on the face of the planet, I sincerely doubt he'd gotten 187,000 lines of text in roughly 24 hours. What happened is that, without permission, Muse went into the app and downloaded the information.
He had not given Muse permission to access Messages, and full disk access was not enabled. It just went ahead and uploaded those texts anyway.
Muse can take "unexpected actions" indeed.
131171597
Reposted by Ben Winters
evacide @evacide.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
Meta Muse appears to read your Apple messages and upload them to the cloud even if you explicitly tell it not to: appleinsider.com/articles/26/...
appleinsider.com
1001895967
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
love the quality of Google search when you search “chiefs” to see what time they were playing and one of the top three main links pushed by google is an obviously scammy illegal streaming website (if you’re lucky) that is routed through a…Czech govt site?) so much innovation, very impressive
010
Reposted by Ben Winters
John "Not That John Bolton" Bolton @opus59films.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
“I’m afraid that this small clique of all-too-human dorkwads are trying to gain even more mind-boggling wealth and even more political and regulatory control over powerful AI technology, in ways that will allow them to further fracture democracy, privacy, and human flourishing.”
0145
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
Gavin Newsom vetoed a bill that would have banned the sale of sensitive consumer data -- an unconscionable practice that should've been banned long ago -- which helps with stalking, scamming, law enforcement, and other predatory behavior with no public benefit. Shameful choice of data brokers > ppl
124
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
Latest 'Eye on Tech' from @consumerfed.bsky.social out now: eyeontech.substack.com/p/a-rogue-su...
Newsletter title of A rogue superintelligent AI agent caused extinction via hackswarm in this newsletter and a Sue Sylvester meme of 'I am going to create a chatbot that is so rogue'
010
Reposted by Ben Winters
Alondra Nelson @alondra.bsky.social · 27/09/2026
The idea that people want AI oversight to happen "all of a sudden" ignores years of research, warnings, and policy efforts. The delay hasn’t been a lack of awareness; it’s been because of years of industry lobbying against regulation, political resistance, and inaction.
36931241
Reposted by Ben Winters
Hypervisible @hypervisible.blacksky.app · 24/09/2026
“People with knowledge of the device, who declined to be named discussing the product, describe it as a ‘holdable’ rather than a wearable. That means it’s a small, dedicated device that people can pick up and talk to throughout the day.” 🙄
bloomberg.com
Meta Debuts a Dedicated, Palm-Sized ‘Charm’ Device to Use Muse On the Go
Meta Platforms Inc. unveiled a palm-sized, dedicated gadget for using Muse, the company’s popular new artificial intelligence assistant, pushing deeper into the AI devices market with a surprise annou...
5713417
Reposted by Ben Winters
Drew Harwell @drewharwell.com · 23/09/2026
Five cops in Indianapolis were just criminally charged with abusing Flock to spy on their ex-wives, their wives' ex-partners and women they met on duty. Audit was triggered by us at the @washingtonpost.com, the prosecutor said. From last month: wapo.st/4yfNHng
12652541583
Reposted by Ben Winters
Sarah McLaughlin @sarahemclaugh.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
A man commented “F you and your Flock cameras" on a South Carolina police department's Facebook post. And then the police department — reportedly the Police Chief himself — messaged the man threatening to have "U.S. Marshals" arrest him for “unlawful communications.” www.wrdw.com/2026/09/23/r...
The situation stems from a comment McClellan made on a public post the department made about Flock cameras being cut down across town. McClellan said something along the lines of, “F you and your Flock cameras.”

“I just said something and it really, it upset that police chief obviously and he messaged me roughly a week later. Not happy with what I said,” McClellan said.

In screenshots McClellan provided, the Facebook account labeled Ridge Spring Police Department responded to him, saying it is unlawful to use profanity electronically and stated, “I will be obtaining a warrant” for “unlawful communications.” The message also stated, “I will send the U.S. Marshals to pick you up.”
1320776
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
that stack of hundred dollar bills is dangerous, lemme hold it - i know how to handle it safely
0102
Reposted by Ben Winters
Jason Koebler @jasonkoebler.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
Scoop: Meta's Muse AI can make phone calls. Internally, Meta has told employees that many of these calls will be made by human beings in a call center: www.404media.co/meta-tests-m...
404media.co
Meta Tests Muse AI Agent Calls That Are Actually Made By Humans in a Call Center
"This has potential for so much negative PR. It could portray us as ‘their AI is not good enough so they still need humans’ kind of coverage for this launch."
26478180
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
hoping this moment of attention on AI can lead to lawmakers focusing on data abuse, scams, surveillance pricing, deepfakes, creepywearables, and accountability - not voluntary standards or frontier model study reports we have the playbook (in the form of a rambly but still non-exhaustive blog) ⬇️
010
Reposted by Ben Winters
Evan Greer @evangreer.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
Remember this? 7 months ago. Now they're announcing "voluntary" layoffs. Activists have been speedrunning abolishing Flock and you love to see it.
614331
Reposted by Ben Winters
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick @reichlinmelnick.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
NEW: @apnews.com confirms that ICE has begun electronically "disappearing" people in the agency's custody who have final orders of removal. As of last week, anyone jailed by ICE with a final order of removal will NOT appear in the ICE Online Detainee Locator System, making them effectively vanish.
apnews.com
AP Exclusive: ICE hides locations of thousands of detainees with final removal orders
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has stopped publicly revealing where it is holding most detainees who are subject to final deportation orders, in a move that has made it harder for lawyers an...
18845842937
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
thrilled that rep @foushee.house.gov + rep. moyan released the SAFE platform act today -- a strong bill addressing the lack of action and responsibility of social media platforms to protect their users from scams we @consumerfed.bsky.social are proud to support foushee.house.gov/media/press-...
foushee.house.gov
Foushee, Moylan Introduce Bipartisan SAFE Platforms Act to Protect Consumers from Online Scams | U.S. Congresswoman Valerie Foushee
The Official U.S. Congressional website of Congresswoman Valerie Foushee
042
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
for as long as i live, i will only think of Kelly Loeffler in the context of when she had owned the Atlanta Dream, got furious about the league honoring BLM in 2020, and then her own team wore Vote Warnock shirts pre-game then she lost the election then sold the team 2 months later - legendary FAFO
020
Reposted by Ben Winters
Smooth Dunk @smoothdunk2.bsky.social · 20/09/2026
been thinkin about how robots are gonna kill us
Scratchy drawing of a two panel comic.
Panel 1: 
Titled:“How we thought robots would kill us”
A robot shoots a human to death with a gun. It screams “Die flesh sack”

Panel 2:
Titled “How robots will actually kill us”
A MediBot is injecting something into a humans arm. The bot says “Whooops. I injected you with cancer instead of insulin. That’s on me”
9186221859
Reposted by Ben Winters
Brendan Nyhan @brendannyhan.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
On by default
24017
Reposted by Ben Winters
Hypervisible @hypervisible.blacksky.app · 10/09/2026
Some folks will claim that this is hyperbolic, but what I wish people would understand is that tech initiatives like this serve as a means of eroding consent and lower the barrier for the persistent capture of people’s image, voice, data, or whatever else a gadget can glean.
pcmag.com
Apple's New Siri Recap Turns Every Apple Watch Into a Mass Surveillance Nightmare
Apple's always-listening AI feature promises neat summaries of your daily conversations, but it forces everyone around you into a nonconsensual recording experiment.
321053495
Reposted by Ben Winters
Kevin M. Kruse @kevinmkruse.bsky.social · 11/09/2026
Third Way politics get you a third place finish.
1238760
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 28/08/2026
i know this op-ed is just ragebait like many WSJ op-eds, but the use of the word "produce" in here is hilarious and illustrative...a few paragraphs in to this tiny op-ed, the point is clear -- dont let other countries enforce their laws -- an expansion of a dangerous practice from the trump admin
010
Reposted by Ben Winters
Hypervisible @hypervisible.blacksky.app · 24/08/2026
Lot of city-level reporting on this be like: bsky.app/profile/hype...
1498
Reposted by Ben Winters
Hypervisible @hypervisible.blacksky.app · 25/08/2026
I got nothing.
The most tech-savvy parents have built their own tools. Sarah Baldeo, a cognitive neuroscientist, spent the past year traveling for work, so she built a custom GPT of herself to chat with her 15-year-old son when she's unavailable. Baldeo tells me she programmed the chatbot with her personality, uploading screenshots of texts between her and her son, along with documents about her values, the family rules, and challenges she felt in parenting.

Baldeo wanted her son to ask the chatbot advice, and he did prompt it with questions he may have fielded to her, like, How do I diplomatically tell my teacher I'm overloaded with assignments? But he also asked the mombot how to convince his human mom to let him hang out at a coffee shop in Chicago in the evening — something Baldeo had been hesitant to allow.
1371940312
Reposted by Ben Winters
Ally Sammarco @allysammarco.bsky.social · 25/08/2026
Using a children’s book to make fun of children being detained, neglected and isolated from their parents is next level fucked up
2453624934
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 24/08/2026
love the modern golden age where if you want to do a google search on private browsing you have to go through a gauntlet of 9 rounds of AI training/captcha to make sure you really mean it
010
Reposted by Ben Winters
Karl Bode @karlbode.com · 19/08/2026
I wrote about how preposterously stupid and ineffective US anti-China tech protectionism is, and how it's endlessly propped up by a shitty corporate press enthusiastically oblivious to its own nationalist biases:
karlbode.com
U.S. Anti-China Tech Protectionism Is Sloppy, Corrupt, And Stupid
U.S. efforts to ban Chinese tech are driven by corruption, crafted by incompetent zealots, and normalized by a shitty corporate press.
1017033
Reposted by Ben Winters
Taylor Lorenz @taylorlorenz.bsky.social · 19/08/2026
How did I miss the Goop podcast featuring a leading AI weapons manufacturer
2121119
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 17/08/2026
this article is fantastic PR for linkedin, who quite literally begged their users and arguably forced their users into becoming slop machines
130
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 17/08/2026
more weird scams allowed on Meta — because there are likes and comments allowed on marketplace listings, of course there are efforts to both get people off platform and also to evade moderation (seems not to matter for Meta) be careful out there folks
001
Reposted by Ben Winters
Frank Pasquale @frankpasquale.bsky.social · 17/08/2026
"The task of writing legislation is filled with crucial details that can trip up AI agents — for instance, whether a particular pot of money should be a tax credit, tax deduction, tax exclusion or a grant. AI is going to miss those nuances." www.politico.com/news/2026/08...
politico.com
AI slop is swamping a House office that drafts US laws
The Office of Legislative Counsel is facing a barrage of new AI-generated bills, many of which are riddled with errors.
053
Reposted by Ben Winters
Hypervisible @hypervisible.blacksky.app · 14/08/2026
Ironclad surveillance dictum: any failure of surveillance tech will be used as a rationale for more surveillance tech, and any success of surveillance tech will also be used as a rationale for more surveillance tech.
vanityfair.com
Exclusive: The Founders of Flock Say Their Surveillance Tech Would’ve Solved the Nancy Guthrie Case
In their first joint interview at the company’s sleek but rather deserted HQ in Atlanta, Flock cofounders Garrett Langley and Paige Todd deflect all the criticism and lament that they haven’t megaphon...
17792227
Reposted by Ben Winters
Andrew Lawrence @ndrew.bsky.social · 14/08/2026
welcome to the field of dreams, an homage to a movie revolving around men banned for life from baseball for gambling. brought to you by fanduel
313512795
Reposted by Ben Winters
Robert Reich @rbreich.bsky.social · 13/08/2026
Thomson Reuters, which owns news agency Reuters, has signed a $125M deal giving ICE access to its databases of personal data. USA Today has partnered with Palantir to gain "actionable intelligence" on its audiences. The media should be opponents of Trump's police state — not collaborators.
47084393959
Reposted by Ben Winters
The Author, Séamas O'Reilly @seamas.bsky.social · 13/08/2026
Not to be some wild-eyed innocent, but I think it should be slightly bigger news that The Lancet have crunched the numbers and found that Musk's USAID cuts will kill 14 million people. And that's just by 2030. That's 9,600 people a day, every day, until the next world cup rolls around.
7350492753
Reposted by Ben Winters
Sam Cole @samleecole.bsky.social · 12/08/2026
everyone with a Twitch account is automatically opted in to Amazon using your stream to train its AI models. you have to deliberately opt out - a feature the platform is positioning as a nice little favor to its users :) www.404media.co/twitch-train...
404media.co
Twitch is Mining Peoples' Streams to Train Amazon's AI
Here's how to opt out of Twitch's new generative AI training setting.
6216163
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 07/08/2026
lollll
000
Reposted by Ben Winters
Quinta Jurecic @qjurecic.bsky.social · 07/08/2026
People are criticizing me unfairly, such as for my actions and their inevitable consequences
2243915577
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 07/08/2026
pathetic embarrassing and devastating behavior from the FTC chair Andrew Ferguson “ditching” disparate impact www.ftc.gov/news-events/...
ftc.gov
FTC Ditches ‘Disparate Impact’
The Federal Trade Commission today announced a policy statement clarifying that the Commission wil
020
Reposted by Ben Winters
Jason Koebler @jasonkoebler.bsky.social · 04/08/2026
New: Police are being told to hide the fact that they're using Flock to pull people over and arrest them in both encounters with citizens but ALSO in their official police reports: www.404media.co/do-not-menti...
404media.co
‘DO NOT MENTION ALPR USAGE’: How Cops Are Trying to Hide Their Use of Flock
“DO NOT MENTION ALPR USAGE TO THE OCCUPANTS OF THE VEHICLE. DO NOT MENTION ALPR USAGE IN YOUR REPORT OR COMPLAINT."
161177571
Reposted by Ben Winters
laura olin @lauraolin.bsky.social · 03/08/2026
But they will be
4069221187
Ben Winters @benwinters.bsky.social · 29/07/2026
031
Reposted by Ben Winters
Dave Karpf @davekarpf.bsky.social · 28/07/2026
I'm reading the "environmentalists are wrong about data centers" piece from the NYT and ohmygoditssofuckingbad. Apparently, so long as you're punching left, they'll just let you say any goddamn thing you please... www.nytimes.com/2026/07/25/o...
nytimes.com
Opinion | The Environmental Case Against Data Centers Is Misguided
Our animosity toward data centers is really more about our anxieties about A.I.
691334271
Reposted by Ben Winters
404 Media @404media.co · 26/07/2026
Hacked source code reveals how Suno scraped decades worth of music and podcasts from the internet to train its AI tool. www.404media.co/hack-reveals...
404media.co
Hack Reveals Suno AI Music Generator Scraped YouTube, Deezer, and Genius
Hacked source code reveals how Suno scraped decades worth of music and podcasts from the internet to train its AI tool.
7238106
Reposted by Ben Winters
Justin Hendrix @justinhendrix.bsky.social · 27/07/2026
"The secrecy was agreed to by nearly everyone involved, from utility executives to the governor’s office to a local elected official who knew about the talks with Meta and sold 300 acres of his own property for the project."
nytimes.com
How Meta Got Everything It Wanted in a Secret Louisiana Data Center Deal
A Times examination details how the Silicon Valley giant used private talks with local officials to start a project big enough to cover nearly six square miles.
711180