À la Semaine juridique (édition générale de ce matin), mon intervention devant les étudiants de Nanterre sur le thème « Être un juriste engagé face aux défis de son époque »
Vincent Vigneau
@vincentvigneau.bsky.social
1.6K followers 353 following 467 posts
Président de la chambre commerciale de la Cour de cassation. Compte personnel
![The woman lodged a further appeal to a more senior court, the upper tribunal, where another judge raised concerns about the unlocated document. In a decision on 14 July, the judge said: “It appears that no such CPIN has ever existed.”
He added in relation to the missing document: “No such document has been located in the public domain and moreover the Home Office’s country policy and information team has been unable to confirm its existence.”
He said that after looking at the Home Office’s letter refusing the woman’s asylum claim, “it bears hallmarks consistent with the use of artificial intelligence. It may therefore transpire that references to country information note Morocco July 2021 in that letter are a result of an AI ‘hallucination’. If so that would represent an extremely serious failing on the part of the respondent [the Home Office].”
In a further critical statement, the judge said that relying on a document that did not exist was “analogous to relying on bogus evidence”. He determined that the issue was a “procedural irregularity”.](https://cdn.bsky.app/img/feed_thumbnail/plain/did:plc:6thjp7ee4xn3vnxkvembsali/bafkreifj6gpmuxfj6v3yowiv67klvvj5joq2engetvynbbrnvzepv4witi)
