Sign in

Vincent Mourik

@vincentmourik.bsky.social
289 followers 20 following 159 posts

dad & husband, quantum physicist, birdo (weirdo?)

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 08/01/2026
The rarest of sights - a big glossy journal publishing negative replications! Yes, we had to bundle 4 replications into one article AND we had to wait 2 (!!) years in peer review, but here we are: www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
science.org
Data sharing helps avoid “smoking gun” claims of topological milestones
Manipulating the topology of electronic bands can realize new states of matter, with possible implications for information technology. A central question is how to tell whether a topological regime ha...
35919
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Tom Radcliffe @tjradcliffe.bsky.social · 08/01/2026
If publishing null results was a problem in my old field (physics beyond the Standard Model) there would have been, like, three papers in the past 30 years.
042
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Toma Susi @mostlyphysics.net · 08/01/2026
Kudos to Science – and of course Sergey and others like him who are holding their own fields accountable. That is how science progresses.
062
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Paul Fairie @paulisci.bsky.social · 22/12/2025
2025 Headline of the Year nominee (July)
Bitter fight over 2020 Microsoft quantum paper both resolved and unresolved
--The Register, 31 Jul 2025
51470169
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 11/10/2025
Good to see John standing up for science youtube.com/watch?v=7Vcm...
youtube.com
Federal funding cuts could 'cripple science,' says Nobel Prize winner | REUTERS
YouTube video by Reuters
0145
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 28/08/2025
Lol
021
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 13/07/2025
I notice in my community numerous conferences featuring fraudsters. Along with people who stated that it's time to move on, and the lesson has been learned etc. Of course people who called out fraud are typically excluded. I wonder if other communities went through this and have they survived?
212
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 08/05/2025
Further unreliable research from @qutech.bsky.social and @msftresearch.bsky.social covered by @averyorrall.bsky.social from @retractionwatch.com. I shared details which I wanted to share within a confidential investigation of @tudelft.nl but it was shut down... www.science.org/content/arti... 1/n
science.org
‘Data manipulations’ alleged in study that paved the way for Microsoft’s quantum chip
Internal emails from 2021 reveal tensions among researchers hunting for elusive Majorana particle
2339
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 07/05/2025
It is weird to issue an Editorial Expression of Concern, and call the case 'closed', isn't it? (@ Nature Communications) www.science.org/content/arti...
science.org
‘Data manipulations’ alleged in study that paved the way for Microsoft’s quantum chip
Internal emails from 2021 reveal tensions among researchers hunting for elusive Majorana particle
174
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 15/04/2025
Denmark is a very disappointing country for research integrity. The University of Copenhagen is a cover-up facility. The national committee is meek and cannot be appealed to my whistleblowers. The journalists don't cover it. The code of conduct is good, but empty words. Shame on DK.
041
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 06/04/2025
Owl ringing season has commenced!!! Pretty stoked to get the adult female Tawny Owl of this pair too, I handed her last year in the same nest box. I'll wear my badges of honour with pride these coming days!
150
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 03/04/2025
I have a question to Nature (communications): if you publish a correction soooo extensive PLUS an Editorial Expression of Concern, why not just retract the paper? This is Microsoft-Delft, from 2017. www.nature.com/articles/s41...
nature.com
Editorial Expression of Concern: Ballistic superconductivity in semiconductor nanowires - Nature Communications
Nature Communications - Editorial Expression of Concern: Ballistic superconductivity in semiconductor nanowires
1126
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Henry Legg @henrylegg.bsky.social · 24/03/2025
2025 Anaheim Global Physics Summit was overwhelmed by nonsensical noise presented by MSFT as evidence of a topological qubit after claiming to the world they had built one. There you go Sankar — I fixed your tweet for you.
0111
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 24/03/2025
Appropriately still from the corrupt website, still afraid to use his own name, Das Sarma concedes that the MSFT 'qubit' generates 'nonsensical noise'. And also, Dr. CMTC, where is your code from the fraudulent retracted Nature paper on 'Quantized Majorana Conductance'? It's been 5 years...
081
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 21/03/2025
(Nayak acknowledged that “you can’t see [the bimodal signal] with the naked eye.”) physics.aps.org/articles/v18...
191
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sabrina Patsch @sabrinapatsch.bsky.social · 20/03/2025
@henrylegg.bsky.social bezeichnet Microsofts Daten über topologische Qubits beim #APS Meeting als Rorschach-Test: "Die Daten verdeutlichen, dass sich dieses Projekt von der Wissenschaft entfernt hat und in den Bereich des Glaubens vorgedrungen ist." Die ganze Story: www.heise.de/hintergrund/...
heise.de
Topologische Qubits: Was bei Microsofts "Durchbruch" alles falsch lief
Das Unternehmen behauptet, topologische Qubits entwickelt zu haben. Forscher zweifeln das an, denn tatsächlich war dies nicht Microsofts erste Verfehlung.
083
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
171
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
Referee Report: Long-awaited Microsoft talk at the APS Global Physics Summit It's an H-tetron.... 🧵
33811
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
Microsoft lügt einfach. Sie setzen ihren Fahrplan der unzuverlässigen Wissenschaft fort, und dies sind einfach die nächsten Schritte auf der Betrugsleiter des Unternehmens. Topologische Qubits sind noch Lichtjahre entfernt!
010
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Henry Legg @henrylegg.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
Thank you to everyone that came to my talk today and all the support over the last few weeks. Today was an important day for protecting the scientific record #apsmarch
2252
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Dulwich Quantum Computing @dulwichquantum.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
“Me and many other experts do not think they have demonstrated even the basic science behind it, let alone the leap into technology of scaling up, production, etc.” --Sergey Frolov www.salon.com/2025/03/17/c...
salon.com
Controversy erupts over claims Microsoft invented a new state of matter
This discovery could change the computing world entirely. But many are skeptical of their claims
072
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
show. this to Mike Manfra. And ask him to finally share his charge jump data. @davidabergel.bsky.social wouldn't.
021
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 17/03/2025
Happening today!
010
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 17/03/2025
The stars of the YouTube "Majorana 1" movie (watched over 3M times!) reunite at the APS March meeting: On Monday, Krysta will talk about Hype, on Tuesday Chetan will talk about Fraud And I am missing Matthias who could perhaps talk about Tunnel Vision to cover all 3 causes of unreliable research?
121
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 14/03/2025
The talk title is 🔥🔥🔥 Next talk will be at the astronomical society: Search for a topological qubit in the observed Universe: nearest bounds based on JWST
271
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 13/03/2025
The talk is in the session MAR-B22.00014 at 2:06 pm on Monday. The session is on Topological superconductivity. The talk is a short 10 minute talk.
131
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 13/03/2025
Congratulations to Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social for being removed as an author from this unreliable Microsoft-Delft paper in Nature Communications! www.nature.com/articles/s41... A cause for celebration. The paper is truly awful, because...
nature.com
Author Correction: Ballistic superconductivity in semiconductor nanowires - Nature Communications
Nature Communications - Author Correction: Ballistic superconductivity in semiconductor nanowires
281
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 13/03/2025
Since communication about advances in quantum computing has crossed firmly into the absurd, in #chatTGP today I imagine myself a VP at Microsoft requesting to produce Majorana discoveries. To kick things off, the AI has hallucinated a 'Trusted Graphics Pipeline' (not a thing according to Google)
291
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Dulwich Quantum Computing @dulwichquantum.bsky.social · 11/03/2025
BREAKING: In an unprecedented move, the Nobel Prize committee has preemptively awarded the 2025 Physics prize to Microsoft! Read the full citation below. 👇
A parody Nobel Prize announcement with an AI-generated portrait of Satya Nadella and a citation reading “For the potential future experiments Microsoft might conduct with devices they have not built yet, but might be able to build in the near future.”
1465
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Stan van Pelt @stanvanpelt.nl · 10/03/2025
Microsofts quantumcomputerclaim onder vuur. Onderscheid tussen 'echte' en nepmajoronadeeltjes, die het rekenhart moeten vormen van het apparaat, zou lastiger te maken zijn dan voorgespiegeld.
newscientist.com
Microsoft under fire for claiming it has a new quantum computer
Researchers have criticised Microsoft's new Majorana 1 quantum computer, saying it has made claims about the way it works that aren't fully backed up by scientific evidence
162
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Henry Legg @henrylegg.bsky.social · 10/03/2025
“Fundamental problems of disorder and material science aren’t going to go away just because you start fabricating some fancier device” www.newscientist.com/article/2471...
newscientist.com
Microsoft under fire for claiming it has a new quantum computer
Researchers have criticised Microsoft's new Majorana 1 quantum computer, saying it has made claims about the way it works that aren't fully backed up by scientific evidence
072
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 10/03/2025
I wrote this letter to APS about their promotion of Microsoft's "Majorana 1". When you look at the facts together, you see how a determined agent can take advantage of a professional society's infrastructure. Help me reach APS committee members and officers, their emails are hard to find...
1115
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 05/03/2025
So, if you are rejected from PRX, PRL - you can still PAY MONEY TO APS to transmit your scientific fraud to APS members. Cool.
192
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sabine Hossenfelder @hossenfelder.bsky.social · 04/03/2025
Experts are questioning that Microsoft has really made any breakthrough with their topological qubits www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJTs...
youtube.com
Microsoft’s Topological Qubits Probably Don’t Exist, Researchers Warn
YouTube video by Sabine Hossenfelder
2456
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 02/03/2025
I've had serious fomo for weeks now. This crappy blurry phone-trough-a-telescope image from an hour or so ago is the world-famous (well, in twitcherland that is) Spectacled Eider currently chilling out in de Waddensea at the island of Texel, the Netherlands. 1/n
110
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Dulwich Quantum Computing @dulwichquantum.bsky.social · 02/03/2025
The Nature editorial criteria when assessing Microsoft's majorana paper.
The editorial team wishes to point out that the results in this manuscript do not represent evidence for the presence of Majorana zero modes in the reported devices. The work is published for introducing a device architecture that might enable fusion experiments using future Majorana zero modes.
0294
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Dulwich Quantum Computing @dulwichquantum.bsky.social · 01/03/2025
Sergey Frolov @spinespresso.bsky.social and Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social yesterday discussed Microsoft's new Nature paper and Majorana 1 chip: www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ag-... We recommend you watch the whole thing - it's both enlightening and entertaining! Here's our own megathread...🧵
2264
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Henry Legg @henrylegg.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
I would like to publicly thank Zulfi Alam, Microsoft Corporate Vice President of Quantum for recommending I read their paper and bother to understand the data. Doing this was really very helpful for my comment.
2162
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Matteo Fadel @the-fad.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
Majordrama qubit
1365
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Jesko Sirker @jeskosirker.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
Good to see a detailed analysis but who really believed in stable topological regions after seeing these figures which looked nothing like one would expect theoretically?
162
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 27/02/2025
Only 4849 spots left to register by zoom! LOL. Thanks everyone who registered for this historic event and see you tomorrow. Remember scientific hypes are short lived so get on it while it lasts!
363
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
I regret to inform you of the tragic and permanent scientific death of current Microsoft Majorana claims. arxiv.org/abs/2502.19560
arxiv.org
Comment on "InAs-Al hybrid devices passing the topological gap protocol", Microsoft Quantum, Phys. Rev. B 107, 245423 (2023)
The topological gap protocol (TGP) is presented as "a series of stringent experimental tests" for the presence of topological superconductivity and associated Majorana bound states. Here, we show that...
25310
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 26/02/2025
Das Sarma is a leading author of the retracted 'Quantized Majorana Conductance' Nature paper. When Microsoft manipulated data in that paper, Das Sarma's theory fit the fabrication perfectly. He refuses to share his code. Next of this Aaronson blog: "Hao Zhang asked me to post the following"...
1134
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 26/02/2025
BRIEF HISTORY of Microsoft handing out their not working chips to government officials. 2025 - U.S. Senator Ted Cruz brandishing a chip given to him by Microsoft in the U.S. Senate.
194
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Quantum Bullshit Detector @bullshitquantum.bsky.social · 26/02/2025
Das Sarma’s bullshit: bullshit
1103
Vincent Mourik @vincentmourik.bsky.social · 25/02/2025
Runner-up for Joke of the Week: 'Prof. Vincent Mourik at Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands, who played a key role in debunking Microsoft’s 2018 paper, is unconvinced.' www.kedglobal.com/tech,-media-...
kedglobal.com
Microsoft's quantum computing bet sparks controversy, again - KED Global
In 2021, Microsoft Corp. faced significant scientific embarrassment when a landmark research paper it had sponsored was retracted.Published in the US science m
110
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 25/02/2025
Here is an interview @ancurlija.bsky.social did with Karl Ziemelis, Chief Editor for Natural Sciences at Nature Magazine. www.youtube.com/watch?v=g9m4... Recorded last year, after the Ranga Dias and old Microsoft retractions. While the last week's Microsoft paper was under consideration at Nature.
youtube.com
Reproducibility Interviews: Karl Ziemelis, Nature Magazine
YouTube video by Sergey Frolov
151
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Henry Legg @henrylegg.bsky.social · 23/02/2025
After the conference Chetan Nayak emailed me promising an erratum That’s what happened last year in Spain: Microsoft Quantum admitted to me they screwed up the topological gap protocol, now they publish a Nature with devices “tuned up” using that protocol They don’t have Majoranas and they know it
1144
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Cyrille Vanlerberghe @cyrillevan.eurosky.social · 22/02/2025
La communication de Microsoft sur l'ordinateur quantique s'est pris les pieds dans les règles de l'éthique scientifique... (Pour abonnés)(Avec une interview de @vincentmourik.bsky.social ) www.lefigaro.fr/sciences/mic...
lefigaro.fr
Microsoft prétend avoir mis au point un nouveau type de puce quantique… mais les experts sont sceptiques
RÉCIT - Une équipe californienne annonce avoir réussi une prouesse technique qui pourrait grandement accélérer la fabrication d’un ordinateur quantique.
274
Reposted by Vincent Mourik
Sergey Frolov🇺🇦 @spinespresso.bsky.social · 21/02/2025
www.wsj.com/science/phys...
wsj.com
Physicists Question Microsoft’s Quantum Claim
The company said it created a “new state of matter” that represents a major advance for quantum computing. But physicists who have reviewed the work say they aren’t convinced of the finding.
041