Reposted by PLOS One
Why do reviewers disagree?
Hesselberg and colleagues found that disagreement is driven more by the application itself and the variability of human judgment than by reviewer characteristics.
🔗 plos.io/4yiLLue
journals.plos.org
Why do reviewers disagree? Evidence from four funders and 134,000 reviews
Grant peer review processes are pivotal in allocating substantial research funding, yet concerns about their reliability persist, primarily due to low inter-rater agreement. This study is a…