Sign in

Mike Sivier

@midwalesmike.bsky.social
354 followers 26 following 3.2K posts

Vox Political writer and therefore poverty-stricken.

PostsRepliesMedia
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 02/10/2026
Reform UK wants school pupils regularly singing hymns and the national anthem, but could these politicians meet that standard themselves. #TheWhipLine #ReformUK #SuellaBraverman #Schools #NationalAnthem #Hymns youtu.be/xm80dye0XJI
youtu.be
A Golden Rule of Government: Practise What You Preach
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 01/10/2026
Small boat arrivals are falling. Why? What if the most effective long-term immigration policy starts thousands of miles from our border? #Migration #Immigration #Refugees #SmallBoats #Diplomacy #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/end-of-one...
thewhipline.substack.com
End of ‘one in, one out’ refugee system: part of a major downturn in illegal entries?
The UK government has scrapped the “one in, one out” agreement with France to swap people who have entered the country by illegal means for those with a good reason to come here.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
A government policy can sound frightening, reassuring, generous or punitive depending on how it is presented. But the headline isn't the policy. #TheWhipLine #Politics #Government #DWP #Benefits #UniversalCredit #PIP #PoliticalAnalysis youtu.be/H6_dzJKH8-E
youtu.be
The Headline Isn’t the Policy: Look at what governments actually do
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 30/09/2026
Andy Burnham's National Care Service will be universal, free at the point of use, protecting homes and savings. But can he make it sustainable? #AndyBurnham #SocialCare #NHS #Pensions #Labour #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/burnham-ha...
thewhipline.substack.com
Burnham has announced a new social care contract for old age and disability
UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham has committed the country to the creation of a National Care Service, in his speech to the Labour Party conference.
011
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
New DWP bank powers are coming. Who can actually have money taken from their account, and what can the DWP see? Find out. #DWP #Benefits #UniversalCredit #PIP thewhipline.substack.com/p/new-dwp-ba...
thewhipline.substack.com
New DWP bank powers are not what you may have been led to believe
The Department for Work and Pensions is about to get new powers to take money from benefit claimants’ bank accounts.
001
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
Reform UK says schools must regularly sing hymns and the national anthem, but what happens to schools serving non-Christian faith communities? #ReformUK #SuellaBraverman #Schools #Education #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/would-brav...
thewhipline.substack.com
Would Braverman’s ‘consequences’ for not singing Christian hymns affect schools of her own religion?
Reform UK has explicitly threatened “consequences” for schools that do not comply with a proposed requirement for pupils to sing the national anthem and hymns.
110
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
Reform UK says schools must regularly sing hymns and the national anthem, but what happens to schools serving non-Christian faith communities? #ReformUK #SuellaBraverman #Schools #Education #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/would-brav...
thewhipline.substack.com
Would Braverman’s ‘consequences’ for not singing Christian hymns affect schools of her own religion?
Reform UK has explicitly threatened “consequences” for schools that do not comply with a proposed requirement for pupils to sing the national anthem and hymns.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 27/09/2026
What happens when someone with a progressive condition initially receives a relatively low PIP award and their needs subsequently become greater? #PIP #DLA #DisabilityBenefits #TimmsReview #DWP #Benefits #TheWhipLine youtu.be/Jt1SzOkJwJE
youtu.be
The PIP Reassessment Problem the Timms Review Hasn’t Solved
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 26/09/2026
Is artificial intelligence making decisions about human beings? Is it making it harder for businesses to grow? Is the system more important than people? #TheWhipLine #ComputerSaysNo #AI #ArtificialIntelligence #Systems #EconomicGrowth #DaisyCooper #LiberalDemocrats youtu.be/v5JHIgTeWos
youtu.be
When the System Says “No”, Who Is It Really Serving?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 24/09/2026
If climate change threatens food, water, supplies and national security, why is the UK spending hundreds of billions on weapons and not resilience? #ClimateChange #NationalSecurity #Defence #ElNino thewhipline.substack.com/p/if-climate...
thewhipline.substack.com
If climate collapse is now a national security issue, why are we buying weapons?
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has been briefing foreign ministers from countries around the world of the threat climate change poses to national security.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
PIP reassessments may be stressful, so ending routine reviews for people with progressive conditions sounds attractive. But what happens when their needs get worse and their award needs to increase? #PIP #DLA #DisabilityBenefits #TimmsReview #TheWhipLine youtu.be/v-NLyGCIEwk
youtu.be
Do planned PIP changes mean less stress for less cash?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
Has the expansion of private health given rich people a head-start claiming disability benefits? #PIP #ADHD #Autism #NHS #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/has-the-ex...
thewhipline.substack.com
Has the expansion of private health given rich people a head-start claiming disability benefits?
If access to diagnosis of long-term medical conditions is easier for people who can afford to pay privately, and diagnosis makes it possible to claim the Personal Independence Payment (PIP), does the ...
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
After I used a 'Little Britain' catchphrase to examine AI making decisions affecting human beings, the Lib Dems adopted it. Did I hit a cultural nerve? #LibDems #AI #EconomicGrowth #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/lib-dems-c...
thewhipline.substack.com
Lib Dems copy ‘Computer says no’ slogan in attack on automated decision-making
Days after I used a catchphrase from BBC sketch show Little Britain to illustrate an article explaining why artifical intelligence should not be allowed to make decisions affecting human beings, the L...
020
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
PIP reassessments may be stressful, so ending routine reviews for people with progressive conditions seems attractive. But what if their award should rise? #PIP #DLA #DisabilityBenefits #TimmsReview #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/child-dla-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Child DLA to adult PIP transition reveals flaws in Timms Review plan to ease claimants’ burden
What happens when a state benefit designed around the additional care needs of a disabled child is replaced by one that measures a much narrower set of adult functional limitations?
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
There is a fundamental difference between a machine processing information and a human being exercising judgement. #AI #ArtificialIntelligence #HumanRights #Technology #AIRegulation #Automation #Accountability #TheWhipLine youtu.be/CGDojRKJH-I
youtu.be
Why Are We Letting AI Make Decisions About People?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 18/09/2026
The latest proposals for reforming Personal Independence Payment contain some genuinely welcome ideas, but there is a serious problem buried among them. #PIP #DisabilityBenefits #DWP #WelfareReform #TheWhipLine youtu.be/IWAiyOgJZOY
youtu.be
PIP Changes Sound Good… Until You Get to THIS Bit
YouTube video by The Whip Line
012
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 17/09/2026
The State Pension is set to rise above £13,000 a year. Why are non-pensioners making such a fuss? #StatePension #TripleLock #Pensions #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/why-are-no...
thewhipline.substack.com
Why are non-pensioners making such a fuss about pensions?
Annual state pensions are set to rise past £13,000 from April 2027 and to hear the rich carrying on about it, you’d think the sky had fallen on them.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 16/09/2026
Reform UK has received £72 million from two crypto billionaires. But the bigger issue is what the donations tell us about the relationship between wealth and democracy. #ReformUK #PoliticalDonations #Democracy #TheWhipLine youtu.be/k82eMt8zjnQ
youtu.be
CAN MONEY BUY POLITICAL POWER?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 16/09/2026
New PIP proposals contain genuinely welcome reforms. But who should decide what a disabled person needs to meet the extra costs of their disability? #PIP #DisabilityBenefits #DWP #TimmsReview #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/recommenda...
thewhipline.substack.com
Recommendations for disability benefits are ruined by attempt at ‘non-cash’ support
What a shame the government has tried to shoehorn a daft idea onto a series of apparently-progressive plans for changes to disability benefits.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Why did Reform UK accept £72 million its bosses knew might have to be returned? And why is there still no cap on domestic billionaire donors? #ReformUK #Farage #PoliticalDonations #Democracy #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/the-reform...
thewhipline.substack.com
The Reform UK donations row is a result of historic failures. Is it about politicians’ GREED?
Let me see if I’ve got this right.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
AI can make mistakes. But the bigger question is why politicians and businesses are allowing it to make decisions about human beings at all. #AI #HumanRights #AIRegulation #Technology #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/call-for-r...
thewhipline.substack.com
Call for regulation of AIs - to avoid risk to human rights - is too weak
MPs and peers are saying there should be a new law to regulate AIs so they cannot threaten human rights, according to the BBC.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
If scrutiny only arrives when a policy is already in trouble, is it really damage limitation? #UKPolitics #LocalGovernment #CouncilReorganisation #TheWhipLine youtu.be/E2st85bSPRI
youtu.be
Council chaos raises this question: who checks the government's work?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 11/09/2026
What happens when people believe their concerns cannot be expressed without being dismissed with intimidation, abuse or violence? #TheWhipLine #SmallBoats #PoliticalDebate #FreeSpeech #Politics youtu.be/EAL5Ic6KGSE
youtu.be
What Happens When People Stop Feeling Heard?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
011
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 11/09/2026
Police forces are struggling with staff shortages, inadequate resources and pressure from rising crime. Who should back them up? #Policing #PoliceFunding #Crime #PoliceReform #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/whats-the-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Can Police Forces Share Resources to Fight Crime?
Police forces are struggling with funding, staffing and support. Could sharing specialist resources provide an answer to the UK's policing crisis?
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 10/09/2026
The public rejects cuts to disability benefits. So will Andy Burnham listen? What about preventing people becoming ill in the first place? #DisabilityBenefits #PIP #NHS #Labour #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/tories-are...
thewhipline.substack.com
Tories are far out of touch with the public over benefits - but what about Andy Burnham?
Kemi Badenoch has lodged her foot well and truly in her mouth by attacking the government for refusing to cut social security benefits - after a national survey showed the public were keen on increase...
011
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 09/09/2026
UK sanctions on Israel may look limited. But their implications could be much bigger – for trade, international law and political relationships. #Israel #Palestine #Gaza #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/milibands-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Miliband’s sanctions on Israel have very broad implications
The UK government has announced sanctions and other measures against Israel, in protest against the plan by that country to build a huge new settlement on Palestinian land in the Occupied West Bank - ...
022
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 08/09/2026
Council reorganisation has been thrown into doubt after Angela Rayner received new legal advice. What did it say? #UKPolitics #LocalGovernment #Labour #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/council-ch...
thewhipline.substack.com
Council chaos: What has Angela Rayner been told that we haven’t?
A long-awaited (and expensive) reorganisation of councils in England into unitary authorities may not be happening after all, because of legal advice received by Local Government Secretary Angela Rayn...
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 07/09/2026
Small boats are fuelling an ugly political divide. We need to hear legitimate concerns about migration without tolerating racism, intimidation or disorder. #Migration #SmallBoats #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/masked-pro...
thewhipline.substack.com
Masked protesters aren’t the answer - but all views must be heard on small boat crossings
The mood of the UK has turned ugly over small boat crossings bringing people to the UK to claim asylum here - despite the number of arrivals being at its lowest point in years.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 05/09/2026
What happens when political words stop meaning what they are supposed to mean? When labels become insults, they stop helping us understand politics and start encouraging us NOT to #PoliticalLanguage #Populism #Politics #TheWhipLine youtu.be/WkwsMUnUs9I
youtu.be
When Political Words Lose Their Meaning
YouTube video by The Whip Line
011
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 05/09/2026
Nigel Farage says he is the target of a “complainants’ society”. But with Reform UK facing yet another funding controversy, is he really the victim? #NigelFarage #ReformUK #UKPolitics #Politics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/has-farage...
thewhipline.substack.com
Has Farage played the ‘victim’ card once too often?
Nigel Farage reckons the UK is a “complainants’ society” - and he’s the target.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 03/09/2026
Keir Starmer has quit as an MP. But if Zack Polanski wins his seat, an apparent attempt to overshadow Andy Burnham could spectacularly backfire. #KeirStarmer #ZackPolanski #AndyBurnham #Labour #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/starmer-qu...
thewhipline.substack.com
Starmer quits as MP - to be replaced by... Zack Polanski?
This is a classic example of unforeseen consequences.
110
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 02/09/2026
Making benefits harder to claim won't address the causes of ill health and disability - and people's lives may get worse while the numbers DON'T improve. #AndyBurnham #PIP #DisabilityBenefits #targets #objectives #TheWhipLine youtu.be/xj2awq26D8g
youtu.be
When Targets Replace Objectives, Policy Goes Wrong
YouTube video by The Whip Line
110
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 02/09/2026
A poll says voters want disability benefits cut. But would preventing ill health and disability be a better way to reduce the benefits bill? #PIP #Disability #NHS #Welfare #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/do-people-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Do people really want disability benefits to be cut - or action against disability itself?
Most voters want the government to slash the disability benefits bill, and they don’t care how it’s done - according to an article in the i paper last weekend (August 29-30, 2026).
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 01/09/2026
Teachers really are overworked. But what if “too much work” isn't actually the whole problem? #Teachers #Education #Schools #TeacherWorkload #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/if-teacher...
thewhipline.substack.com
If teachers are overworked, what is the REAL reason?
The Liberal Democrats reckon teachers are burning out and need better working hours and more support to stop them leaving the profession.
020
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 01/09/2026
Andy Burnham has cut business rates for pubs — but has the government actually dealt with the problem? #Pubs #BusinessRates #AndyBurnham #SmallBusiness youtu.be/-Bu8CDZJJnI
youtu.be
You Can’t Make Good Decisions Using Bad Measurements
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 01/09/2026
Mike Ashley calls Andy Burnham’s High Street policies “populist” - but does he actually understand what the word means? #Populism #AndyBurnham #MikeAshley #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/ashleys-at...
thewhipline.substack.com
Ashley’s attack on Burnham’s high street policy is wrong to call it ‘populist’
Sports Direct owner Mike Ashley doesn’t seem to know the meaning of the word ‘populist’, which he has used to describe Andy Burnham’s bid to tackle the cost of living.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 31/08/2026
Burnham has changed his early release scheme — but has he really solved the prison crisis? #AndyBurnham #Prisons #Justice #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/changes-to...
thewhipline.substack.com
Changes to early release scheme for prisoners have NOT detoxified it
Andy Burnham has announced changes to his proposed ‘early release’ scheme for prisoners - but they are likely to only stop the Tories being able to use the ‘PC Harper’ case to attack him - not to solv...
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 29/08/2026
The i says the State Pension triple lock is in doubt because there are more pensioners. But its argument deserves much closer scrutiny. #Pensions #TripleLock #StatePension #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/the-i-pape...
thewhipline.substack.com
The ‘i’ paper’s ‘impartial news’ faces inaccuracy alert
Why is the government trying to get us to trust so-called ‘legacy’ media, when it’s so easy to poke holes in the argument?
100
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 27/08/2026
I responded to the government’s consultation on the future of Public Service Media. Here’s where I told them to stuff prioritisation and algorithms. #PSM #Media #YouTube #Journalism #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/my-respons...
thewhipline.substack.com
My response to the government’s consultation on social media
It took me ages to get around to this because I didn’t want to mess it up.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 26/08/2026
Liberal Democrats have backed calls for the UK government to take concrete action against Israel’s E1 settlement plan. What about the other parties? #E1 #Palestine #Israel #WestBank #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/will-the-u...
thewhipline.substack.com
Will the UK government turn condemnation into action to stop Israel’s E1 settlements in Palestine?
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband was right to condemn Israel’s decision to build settlements across the West Bank, which is Palestinian land, according to Liberal Democrat MPs.
021
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 25/08/2026
Labour promised to end “exploitative” zero-hours contracts. But could eligibility rules leave insecure workers without the protection they were promised? #Labour #ZeroHours #WorkersRights #EmploymentRights #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/is-labour-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Is Labour really ending ‘exploitative’ zero-hours contracts for employees?
A row between the Labour government, trade unions and businesses has exposed potentially disastrous problems with the plan to end “exploitative” zero-hours contracts for employees.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 23/08/2026
Government borrowing was higher than forecast. But does that really tell us Labour can't cut living costs? #UKPolitics #Economy #CostOfLiving #Budget #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/media-doom...
thewhipline.substack.com
Media doomsayers are making unfounded assumptions about government spending
Don’t skip past this - it’s about how much cash you’ll have in the future.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 22/08/2026
UK prices are about 600% higher than in 1976 — and they shot up dramatically after 2021. Here’s what the inflation graphs don’t show. #Inflation #CostOfLiving #UK #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/why-do-we-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Why do we talk about inflation and not about price rises?
The BBC has running one of its regular scary articles about inflation today, saying the average cost of goods and services is once again rising at a faster rate.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 21/08/2026
Israel's E1 settlement plan could divide the West Bank and make a Palestinian state impossible. Does it mean a UK-Israel flashpoint is approaching? #Israel #Palestine #WestBank #E1 #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/plan-to-di...
thewhipline.substack.com
Plan to divide the West Bank means UK and others are heading for flashpoint with Israel
The Israeli government may finally have gone too far in its eternal persecution of Palestine.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 20/08/2026
Reform UK claims it can slash £50bn a year from welfare by 2030. But cutting benefits isn't the same as cutting the need for them. Where's the evidence? #ReformUK #Welfare #Benefits #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/reform-uks...
thewhipline.substack.com
Reform UK’s plan to cut £50 billion in benefit payments is nothing but wishful thinking
Reform UK seems to be getting desperate - perhaps because it has lost ground to Labour in the polls and a once-commanding lead has now become a battleground.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 19/08/2026
Wildfires have been devastating the UK - and if you've deliberately started one, why should anyone else repair the damage? #Wildfires #Arson #Wales #UK #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/imbeciles-...
thewhipline.substack.com
Imbeciles who set wildfires should be made to correct the damage they caused
We’ve really been plumbing the depths of human stupidity in this summer’s heatwaves.
000
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 18/08/2026
Nigel Farage won the Clacton by-election — then turned his absence from the count into a story of threat, humiliation and persecution. #Farage #Clacton #ReformUK #Populism #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/farages-di...
thewhipline.substack.com
Farage's dirty tricks at the Clacton by-election
Nigel Farage has won the Clacton by-election, with 63 per cent of the vote - on a low turnout of 44 per cent.
010
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 17/08/2026
Could Andy Burnham tackle water prices without spending £100 billion? Here's how he might manage it. #AndyBurnham #Water #ThamesWater thewhipline.substack.com/p/heres-a-pr...
thewhipline.substack.com
Here's a practical way for Andy Burnham to tackle water prices
UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham has said he accepts his announcements aimed at tackling the cost of living are not enough on their own.
021
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 12/08/2026
Nigel Farage says sending foreign prisoners abroad could solve the UK’s prison crisis. But how practical is Reform UK’s plan? #ReformUK #NigelFarage #Prisons #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine thewhipline.substack.com/p/farages-fo...
thewhipline.substack.com
Farage's 'foreign prisoners' proposal isn't as straightforward as he's pretending
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has proposed that every citizen of a foreign country serving a prison sentence in the UK should be sent to serve their sentences abroad.
231
Mike Sivier @midwalesmike.bsky.social · 11/08/2026
Is it fair to blame a Prime Minister who has been in office for less than a month for a crowded prisons crisis that has been building for decades? #AndyBurnham #PrisonCrisis #UKPolitics #TheWhipLine youtu.be/R6pUbgNef8o
youtu.be
80,000 Court Cases And Full Prisons - Is This Burnham's First Big Test?
YouTube video by The Whip Line
000