Sign in

Myles McNutt

@memles.bsky.social
8.8K followers 349 following 2.4K posts

Media Scholar at Old Dominion University and Editor-in-Chief of TV criticism newsletter Episodic Medium

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Caroline Siede @carolinesiede.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
If you want a 10,000 word deep dive into what makes Heated Rivalry so good, boy do I have a series of essays for you!
192
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
The VMAs’ simultaneous desire to remain tied to music history while also privileging current artists is a fascinating cultural experiment, but it sure created a dire George Michael tribute up until they broke the latter rule for Adam Lambert.
020
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 25/09/2026
Whatever they paid Nigella wasn’t enough, tbh. #GBBO
050
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 25/09/2026
I don’t think we’re talking enough about how the NYT lists were unranked and all it really means is what shows the most people thought they should have on their lists, which is not nothing but isn’t actually evaluating the best show of the 21st century.
6322
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 24/09/2026
I realize that this isn’t illogical—of course people are more likely to watch a movie they haven’t seen over one that was wildly successful at the box office—but it’s still very funny to me.
350
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
Is there anything more TV in 2026 than watching a limited series you saw some buzz about but no one’s talking about it anymore and thinking “Wow, I’m so late to the party” and then realizing it only dropped five weeks ago? I was charmed by #MyBrilliantCareer, is what I’m saying.
4200
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 23/09/2026
#TedLasso's insistence on making 50+ minute episodes with a perfectly good 30-minute episode buried in it brought me back to Benioff's infamous "themes are for eighth-grade book reports" quote. Do you know what might make this version of the show work better? Thematic parallels.
episodicmedium.tv
Review: Ted Lasso, "Follow the Anger" | Season 4, Episode 8
A perfectly good episode buried in a themeless blob
390
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 22/09/2026
On the one hand, yes, the clips from this show are 100% an improvement on an audio-only experience. But on the OTHER hand, if this is the case, then why oh WHY are the ad reads at the beginning of the episode read from a script instead of a prompter?!
201
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Rick Porter @rickporter.bsky.social · 18/09/2026
This is probably closer to what the Peacock "Traitors" gets per episode than you'd think. The big minutes watched total in streaming ratings doesn't *necessarily* mean a giant per-episode audience, especially since the Nielsen streaming numbers include watch time for every episode of a show.
231
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 16/09/2026
#SlowHorses is back for season six, which means that I can finally publish reviews I wrote months ago because this is easily the show with the longest lead time for screeners due to filming a full year in advance. Thoughts on a premiere that tests whether the show is capable of being overstuffed.
episodicmedium.tv
Review: Slow Horses, "Circle of Life" | Season 6, Episode 1
From the day Lamb arrived on the planet / He farted us into the sun
040
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Let the record show that it was @davechen.bsky.social who first identified people who watch award shows obsessively “sickos” but it was I who earnestly ran with it, because accurate. Our breakdown of the 2026 #Emmys can be watched here: youtu.be/R_IuVB9rw-o
youtu.be
Breaking down the 2026 Emmy Awards (feat. Myles McNutt from Episodic Medium)
YouTube video by Decoding TV
010
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Alan Sepinwall @sepinwall.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
One year ago today, I left Rolling Stone and turned What's Alan Watching? into my full-time business. I'm SO grateful to everyone who's supported me. I've got a preview of what's to come, and a discount for people on the fence about signing up for a paid sub:
whatsalanwatching.com
It was a very good year
Thanks for reading, and I hope you'll stick around for a lot more
633126
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
#ThePitt S2—while very good—struggled to escape the feeling that it only cared about Robbie's character, so it's sort of fitting that its only major #Emmys wins were for series and Noah Wyle, y'know?
0160
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Look, I get why this is happening, but if you don't even put in a half-hearted attempt to reframe Dolly Parton as a TV star, you don't deserve to be producing a TV award show. #Emmys
4434
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Really hard to suggest a more defining TV director of the past decade, given Atlanta (2016) and Widow's Bay (2026) as bookends. #Emmys
17911
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
I like #SlowHorses, but it winning writing/directing awards remains an incredibly bizarre #Emmys narrative I really can't explain.
241
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Rewinding a bit, but Matthew Rhys should win a third Emmy for remembering who he was supposed to thank when he won the Limited Series award. #Emmys
070
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
I'm largely ambivalent on the "Broadcast Carousel vs. Simulcast vs. Streamer" debate on the future of the #Emmys broadcast, but there's no question that the question of host will be opened up considerably if it's no longer tied to a single broadcast network.
120
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
I hate blind award show ballots as a genre, but Harrison Ford losing from the position of prohibitive favorite two years in a row to two very different winners (last year a dark horse nominee, this year another show gaining massive momentum) raises a lot of questions for me. #Emmys
0110
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Were Todd and Mr. Peanutbutter responsible for this? #Emmys
0140
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/09/2026
Pretending that the #Emmys didn't ignore Buffy by obscuring the daytime on Sarah Michelle Gellar's Emmys makes this stolen valor Buffy tribute even more egregious.
2263
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
I've spent the last year and a half wondering how WWE Raw's move to Netflix was reshaping its weekly ritual, so what better way to investigate than participant observation? My reflections from attending Raw live last month are up ahead of tonight's Mexico City event.
episodicmedium.tv
Week-to-Week: WWE Raw Live vs. WWE Raw Live on Netflix
How Netflix's investment in weekly ritual is—or isn't?—reshaping the WWE product
241
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 12/09/2026
Four years ago, we ran a subscription drive to signal Episodic Medium becoming a full-service, reader-supported, contributor-driven television criticism newsletter. And the reality of "reader-supported" means we'll do it again every year. Our fall schedule and our 20% off deal are back.
episodicmedium.tv
Month-to-Month: Episodic Medium's Fall 2026 Schedule
The best time to subscribe and support independent TV criticism is back
0136
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
I've spent the last year and a half wondering how WWE Raw's move to Netflix was reshaping its weekly ritual, so what better way to investigate than participant observation? My reflections from attending Raw live last month are up ahead of tonight's Mexico City event.
episodicmedium.tv
Week-to-Week: WWE Raw Live vs. WWE Raw Live on Netflix
How Netflix's investment in weekly ritual is—or isn't?—reshaping the WWE product
241
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 12/09/2026
Four years ago, we ran a subscription drive to signal Episodic Medium becoming a full-service, reader-supported, contributor-driven television criticism newsletter. And the reality of "reader-supported" means we'll do it again every year. Our fall schedule and our 20% off deal are back.
episodicmedium.tv
Month-to-Month: Episodic Medium's Fall 2026 Schedule
The best time to subscribe and support independent TV criticism is back
0136
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 12/09/2026
Nina Garcia pretending like she had strong feelings about the designers in the finale when she was absent for over half the runways was honestly an impressive bit of acting. Like you almost forgot! #ProjectRunway
030
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 11/09/2026
My take on the Muppet Show discourse is that until we get Nellie Andreeva and her sources to clarify what they think the word "premise" means in totality, I'm not able to fully discern how angry we should be.
2122
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 09/09/2026
I'm late in posting Episodic Medium's fall schedule but it's because CBS has still not released final Cupertino key art so there's no official logo for me to decide whether it makes more aesthetic sense to mash up into ElsTino or CuperBeth, I know you understand what I'm going through.
180
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 03/09/2026
Was just talking over the weekend about the ecosystem of internet interview content formats, and now Chicken Shop Date comes off the board. Probably the least sustainable (since she’s kind of stuck “in character”), but helped shaped the trend nonetheless.
072
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 29/08/2026
Without any of the controversy, do we think the (delightful) #CoyoteVsACME performs better or worse than the $14m-ish it’s projected to make this weekend if it releases on the same weekend in 2024?
310
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 27/08/2026
Objectively good show, but I'll admit that the deeper we've gotten into the season the idea of them making a second has seemed increasingly messy. Curious how the finale lands.
080
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 25/08/2026
I mostly dug the new #Insidious film, straightforward as it might be, but I’m a little stuck on what seems to be a transitional moment from Bad Photoshop Family Photos to AI-Generated Family Photos (of the elderly couple across the street, if you’ve seen it).
030
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 22/08/2026
Student course reflection: "Now I'm, like, so fascinated by The CW."
static.klipy.com
Kronk: Mission Accomplished
ALT: Kronk: Mission Accomplished
0260
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 21/08/2026
Peter Moldanado cameo better happen.
090
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 20/08/2026
static.klipy.com
Nigelthornberryvp: Kamala Harris 'We Did It, Joe'
ALT: Nigelthornberryvp: Kamala Harris 'We Did It, Joe'
171
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 20/08/2026
I know I’m too deep in my IMAX rabbit hole because I was watching #TheEndOfOakStreet in LIEMAX and every time the ratio expanded I just thought “And to think almost no one will ever see the full effect because The Odyssey is still in 99% of the 1.43-enabled theaters.” (Good movie good, tho)
040
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Dennis Perkins @dennisperkins5.bsky.social · 18/08/2026
Here’s my #EpisodicMedium review of the #ItsAlwaysSunny Season 18 premiere! www.episodicmedium.tv/review-its-a...
episodicmedium.tv
Review, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, "Frank Marries a Corpse" | Season 18, Episode 1
Season 18 begins by snuffing out a major character. And all hope of escape.
061
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 18/08/2026
Have you truly lived if you haven’t been seated for a Mystery Movie and they play the trailer for the movie everyone wants the Mystery Movie to be and there’s this rolling realization you’re doomed to be disappointed? I say not.
1232
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 15/08/2026
Interesting this is a Disney Channel project? Feels like that is pitching this to a very different demographic than the people anticipating the fourth game.
031
Reposted by Myles McNutt
Emily St. James @emilystjams.bsky.social · 14/08/2026
Money's a little tight and getting tighter every day during the long wait between TV jobs. The best thing you could do for me -- and our whole team! -- is sign up for a subscription to my newsletter today. For as little as $5/month! episodes.ghost.io#/portal/acco...
episodes.ghost.io
Episodes by Emily St. James
A newsletter on culture, identity, and many other things by critic and writer Emily St. James
15835
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 13/08/2026
It's notable to me that #ThePitt has been a massive success, and HBO Max actively tried to develop shows on this model, and they looked at this cop show and said "Nah." I'm curious what they learned from this failure.
deadline.com
'American Blue' Cop Drama Pilot Dead At HBO Max - Exclusive
HBO Max is not proceeding with one of its 2 pilots, American Blue, starring Milo Ventimiglia. Warner Bros. TV is looking to find a new home for it.
3120
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 11/08/2026
They purged liquids TOO?!
1100
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 11/08/2026
Sony ordered this without a distributor and now they're renewing it before it premieres, presumably without any formal distribution agreement for that second season. Television!
020
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 11/08/2026
This isn’t a drag I swear, but it’s always funny when the soap operatics of wrestling mean that the night’s biggest moment is two dudes NOT fighting, y’know? Had a fun time at my first RAW since 2003.
Officials attempt to separate Oba Femi and Bron Breakker for no reason other than to delay their first physical contact for a show in a bigger city.
020
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 10/08/2026
Peacock’s commitment to scripted binge releases remains so strange to me given how powerful weekly/daily investment has worked with their reality shows.
070
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 10/08/2026
I purposefully have avoided reading the source material for #HouseOfTheDragon in the hopes of creating a sense of discovery and surprise in its narrative, and this season's finale underlined that this was ultimately futile. My review is up for Episodic Medium subscribers.
episodicmedium.tv
Review: House of the Dragon, "The Treasons at Tumbleton" | Season 3, Episode 8
Even without having read the books, there's a ceiling on the story's potential
130
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 08/08/2026
With Charlie Gillespie in the news, seems like a worthwhile time to revisit this 2020 article I wrote on the moment when it felt like Netflix would truly cultivate stars, which turned out to begin and end with Millie Bobby Brown.
cultural-learnings.com
Starstuck: Streaming, Celebrity, and the state of the “Netflix Star”
In the fall of 2018, Netflix was still not releasing formal ratings data for its original programming, but they were nonetheless invested in using data to demonstrate their cultural influence. And …
170
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 07/08/2026
I’ve literally been following Justice Smith since Anna Deavere Smith’s YoungArts MasterClass, but I’m going to hold onto my comments on the Harris situation and just say how thrilled I am for Gillespie and everyone about to enjoy Julie and the Phantoms.
390
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 06/08/2026
My review of #TheShards is that I accidentally watched the last episode first, and I honestly didn't notice until the episode was over, which certainly says...something? Not sure what, to be honest. (We went back and watched the rest).
290
Myles McNutt @memles.bsky.social · 06/08/2026
I regret to inform everyone that the #KingOfTheHill reboot chose to risk all of its goodwill on a WHOLLY illogical presentation of reality television production in its penultimate episode, you hate to see it.
100