Sign in

Lance S. Bush

@lanceindependent.bsky.social
170 followers 87 following 820 posts

Moral psychologist & philosopher. I blog and I'm on YouTube/TikTok. See my academic and online work here: linktr.ee/lanceindependent

PostsRepliesMedia
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Rob Sica @robsica.bsky.social · 16/06/2026
😺 🔪🔪"The implications of normative nihilism are ripe for continued research." 🔪🔪
philpapers.org
Lewis Williams, Normative Nihilism - PhilPapers
Normative nihilism is the more radical sibling of moral nihilism: while moral nihilists are nihilists only about the moral domain, normative nihilists are nihilists about all normativity. For example,...
132
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 08/06/2026
I wrote a massive critique of the notion of philosophical intuitions. Check it out: www.lanceindependent.com/p/philosophi...
lanceindependent.com
Philosophical Intuitions Don't Exist
A Critical Response to Hilarius Bookbinder's "A defense of philosophical intuitions"
041
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 29/05/2026
Philosophers: Phenomenal conservatism is a modest principle. You are justified in believing that things are the way they seem in the absence of defeaters. As such, this principle merely establishes one’s initial starting point, which can be readily overridden by compelling evidence to the contrary.
110
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 28/05/2026
I have a new publication available. Check it out! link.springer.com/article/10.1...
link.springer.com
Why Training Paradigms Won’t Rescue Experimental Metaethics - Review of Philosophy and Psychology
Most research in experimental metaethics suggests high levels of interpersonal and intrapersonal variation in support for moral realism and antirealism among nonphilosophers (i.e., people without sign...
060
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 18/05/2026
substack.com/home/post/p-...
substack.com
Moral realists: Denying you're making empirical claims isn't going to help
(This was written quickly and without proofreading, so please let me know if you spot any errors).
020
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 16/05/2026
newdiscourse.substack.com/p/lance-bush...
newdiscourse.substack.com
Lance Bush vs. David Enoch: An Analysis of the Most Respectfully Heated Debate of the Year
Lance Bush and David Enoch recently debated the truth of moral realism on Uncertainty, hosted by Miles Donahue. Here’s what went down.
010
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 06/05/2026
I had a debate with David Enoch about moral realism. Check it out: www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWZu...
youtube.com
Are There Objective Moral Truths? | David Enoch vs. Lance Bush
YouTube video by Miles K. Donahue
010
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
gusschultz.bsky.social @gusschultz.bsky.social · 13/04/2026
New one from @lanceindependent.bsky.social is up and well worth the read. While his focus is on normativity, I think all this translates really well to the sort of "objective value" talk common in apologetics. I wish more philosophers would seriously engage with Lance's ideas.
lanceindependent.com
Unwinnable games, unintelligibility, and appeals to incredulity
1.0 The unintelligibility thesis
011
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
philosophyblogs @philosophyblogs.zirk.us.ap.brid.gy · 19/03/2026
Lance Independent || Moral realism: winning converts or fashionable trend? www.lanceindependent.com/p/moral-re…
lanceindependent.com
Moral realism: winning converts or fashionable trend?
(Note: I’ll be using moral objectivism and moral realism interchangeably here, though it’s worth flagging that not everyone does so.)
031
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 13/03/2026
Is psychopathy a zombie idea? Check out my discussion with Rasmus Larsen: www.youtube.com/watch?v=o3hW...
youtube.com
Is psychopathy a zombie idea?
YouTube video by Lance Independent
011
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 15/12/2025
Some features of English best accord with a subjectivist interpretation of ordinary moral language. I discuss this with Nils Franzen here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=OUfH...
youtube.com
The presumption of realism with Nils Franzen
YouTube video by Lance Independent
010
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 10/12/2025
New post on why I don't think there are irreducibly normative reasons: www.lanceindependent.com/p/there-are-...
lanceindependent.com
There are no irreducibly normative reasons
Where do normative reasons come from?
110
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Disagreeable Me @disagreeableme.bsky.social · 06/12/2025
W00t!
131
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Disagreeable Me @disagreeableme.bsky.social · 06/12/2025
Really enjoyed talking to @lanceindependent.bsky.social face to face. My first philosophy stream! Lance was a great host, my apologies for the poor audio on my end, especially the first half. www.youtube.com/live/z6OFkWz...
youtube.com
Publishing, fine-tuning and quantum immortality
YouTube video by Lance Independent
092
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
𝚂𝚝𝚊𝚗 𝙿𝚊𝚝𝚝𝚘𝚗 @stanpatton.bsky.social · 04/12/2025
Lance Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social and I wrote a takedown of "intuitions" as a normatively-laden concept deserving justificatory weight out of the gate. It's past time to give that notion the heave-ho. open.substack.com/pub/lanceind...
open.substack.com
The Intuitions We Don’t Have
1.0 Distinctions, Distinctions, Distinctions
021
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Tom Hardwicke @tomhardwicke.bsky.social · 24/11/2025
Congratulations to @simine.com well deserved winner of the Einstein Foundation Individual Award for Promoting Quality in Research 2025 🎉 www.einsteinfoundation.de/en/media/pre...
413130
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Embrace the Void @etvpod.bsky.social · 19/11/2025
Hahahahaha we’re fucked.
0182
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 05/11/2025
My blog is back! Stan Patton and I wrote our most recent piece on intuitions, which may put an end to the intuition wars on Substack for good (they won't, but one can dream): www.lanceindependent.com/p/the-intuit... Stan did the bulk of the work here, as well as creating all the images.
lanceindependent.com
The Intuitions We Don’t Have
1.0 Distinctions, Distinctions, Distinctions
000
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 02/11/2025
There was this old suggestion from the rationality community from back in the day where you “taboo” a word (and any obvious synonym). This can put pressure on you to get clear about what you mean.
231
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 20/10/2025
Congrats!!!
020
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 20/10/2025
Correct.
020
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 03/10/2025
One of the weirder reactions to people endorsing moral antirealism or moral relativism is the moralization of their adoption of these views. That is, critics seem to think that if you endorse these views, this reflects poorly on your moral values and your character.
140
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 25/09/2025
I didn't find the case convincing. First, while you do make several clear assertions, I didn't see much in the way of arguments for those claims. Second, I think there are some issues with the reasoning at the end of the post (see my comment on substack where I explain what I take the issues to be).
010
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 06/09/2025
Unfortunately. Moral realism is one of least defensible positions in analytic philosophy, and that's saying a lot. It's popularity and even its apparent resurgence is a testament to the persistence of bad methods. I'm still hoping one day that the dissident metaphilosophies will triumph.
150
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Pete Mandik @petemandik.bsky.social · 23/08/2025
More like the former. But it’s less about reading the wrong philosophers more about failing to read the right ones. Untutored introspection is otherwise silent on the relevant issues.
121
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Rob Sica @robsica.bsky.social · 14/08/2025
🔪Contra those who want the cake (hardnosed Darwinism) and to eat it, too (salvage some kind of moral realism): "minimal moral realism, based on cognitivism and the rejection of error theory, [...] faces a fundamental challenge from nonobjective relativism"
tandfonline.com
Beyond minimalism: why objectivity matters for metaethical moral realism
This paper argues that moral realism must commit to objectivity as a core feature. According to an influential view, a theory qualifies as moral realism if moral claims are literally construed as s...
022
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Steve Morgan @steveve.bsky.social · 14/08/2025
I like the moral realism debate but ultimately it doesn't matter. People just do what they do. #philosophy
161
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Philip Goff @philipgoff.bsky.social · 06/08/2025
@lanceindependent.bsky.social is one of the people I really like to listen to even though I strongly disagree with everything they say. @randalrauser.bsky.social is someone I like to listen to and tend to agree with. Double the fun! www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UcS...
youtube.com
Moral Anti-Realism with Lance Bush
YouTube video by Randal Rauser - The Tentative Apologist
241
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 07/08/2025
From its description, "1000-Word Philosophy: An Introductory Anthology is a constantly growing collection of over 200 original essays on important philosophical topics. These essays are introductions rather than argumentative articles." However, Nathan Nobis recently wrote this article:
1000wordphilosophy.com
“That’s Subjective”: Subjectivism about Truth, Beauty, and Goodness - 1000-Word Philosophy: An Introductory Anthology
People sometimes say that judgments about what’s true, what’s ethical, what others find beautiful or aesthetically pleasing, and more are "subjective." What does “subjective” really mean? Are judgment...
131
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Randal Rauser @randalrauser.bsky.social · 29/07/2025
Check out my interview with moral antirealist @lanceindependent.bsky.social www.youtube.com/watch?v=6UcS...
youtube.com
Moral Anti-Realism with Lance Bush
YouTube video by Randal Rauser - The Tentative Apologist
151
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 01/07/2025
See my latest Blog Post, "Do Philosophers Need Intuitions?": www.lanceindependent.com/p/do-philoso...
lanceindependent.com
Do philosophers need intuitions?
1.0 Maybe we we don’t have intuitions
020
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Nathan @nath-ormond.bsky.social · 10/05/2025
Going live in a couple of minutes with DOCTOR Lance Bush, What's Wrong with Annaka Harris's Philosophy of Mind www.youtube.com/live/L3GuX3b...
youtube.com
Annaka Harris's Bad Philosophy of Mind w/ Lance Bush
YouTube video by Digital Gnosis
121
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Rob Sica @robsica.bsky.social · 27/06/2025
🔪"Ultimately, perhaps, the error at the heart of morality is that we take the metaphysics of the external world and the agency of humans to 'fit together' in a way that cannot be accommodated within a naturalistic worldview."
amazon.com
Morality: From Error to Fiction
Amazon.com: Morality: From Error to Fiction: 9780198879367: Joyce, Richard: Books
021
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Rob Sica @robsica.bsky.social · 22/06/2025
"a certain pay-off in seeing these skeptical arguments piled up and jostling for attention, for it underscores the fact that moral responsibility is *fishy all over the place*"
academic.oup.com
The Argument from Moral Responsibility
Abstract. Of the philosophers who are skeptical of the existence of moral responsibility, many remain optimistic that morality could carry on healthily wit
032
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 22/06/2025
I don't know of any good reason to associate psychopathy with a deficit in the ability to perceive objective moral truths; there's never been any compelling demonstrate anyone can detect moral truth in this way. I see little reason to associate psychopathy with highly contentious metaethical claims.
130
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Disagreeable Me @disagreeableme.bsky.social · 17/06/2025
Love @lanceindependent.bsky.social, love Henry Shevlin, love videogames, what's not to love? Really enjoyed the enthusiasm of this concersation. youtube.com/live/MttmPst...
youtube.com
Discussing video games with Henry Shevlin
YouTube video by Lance Independent
111
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 17/06/2025
Who will be at the Society for Philosophy and Psychology (SPP) meeting this week?
000
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Dr Keith 🎃 Wilson @keithwilson.eu · 10/06/2025
Looking for philosophers to follow on Bluesky? Here are over 2,000 of them on my #philosophy (bsky.app/profile/did:...) and philosophy organisations (bsky.app/profile/did:...) lists! #PhilSky
37442
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Gordon Pennycook @gordpennycook.bsky.social · 02/06/2025
Learned something new today: Zotero has a feature where it informs you if an article in your reference library has been retracted. Very cool!
1323
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Rob Sica @robsica.bsky.social · 01/06/2025
creators.spotify.com
Is Philosophy a Waste of Time? | #35 Joe Schmid by Uncertainty
Joe and I take a more personal turn in this video, discussing the importance of philosophy, what got us into the discipline, and whether studying Immanuel Kant your whole life is really worth it.Check...
021
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 30/05/2025
"Is not the whole history of philosophy one long illustration of philosophic audacity in manipulating language, and does not experience show that philosophers frequently get away with their arbitrary modifications of '*the*' meaning of words and 'propositions'?" - FCS Schiller
130
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 23/05/2025
Goodhart's Law is one of the most important forces in the world and it's incredible how little attention it gets.
040
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 15/05/2025
A question for moral realists: Is it logically possible for the moral facts to be different from what you think they are? For instance, is it logically possible that it is morally obligatory to torture babies for fun, or to lie indiscriminately?
140
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Neil Renic @ncrenic.bsky.social · 14/05/2025
This is bleak reading
1502226264898
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 14/05/2025
Academic philosophy is currently facing a challenge: there don't seem to be enough people available to review papers submitted to journals. Some people have proposed some ways to improve the situation. I think the problems in the field are more fundamental...
120
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 07/05/2025
Moral antirealism is not the view that morality isn't real.
140
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 05/05/2025
My god. Why are videos on moral relativism reliably so awful? This person makes an absolutely ridiculous objection to moral relativism. These aren’t legitimate objections. These are literally just people not understanding what the position is: www.youtube.com/shorts/DWdrT...
youtube.com
Subjective Morality Is OBVIOUSLY False
YouTube video by A Messenger of Truth
020
Reposted by Lance S. Bush
Rob Sica @robsica.bsky.social · 02/05/2025
"It has been noted that much of philosophy of religion serves the function of an apologetics for religious belief. We can probably likewise say that much work in metaethics is a kind of apologetics for moral realism."
brill.com
151
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 01/05/2025
Is anyone else going to the 5th European Experimental Philosophy Conference this year in Norwich? x-phi.uea.ac.uk/EuroX-Phi202...
x-phi.uea.ac.uk
5th European Experimental Philosophy Conference
A group of experimental philosophers at the University of East Anglia
011
Lance S. Bush @lanceindependent.bsky.social · 29/04/2025
I am exhausted with people just declaring “this is the commonsense view,” when there is little or no evidence to support such claims, and often evidence to the contrary. Then I am supposed to respect that a given view is not controversial among philosophers.
120