Sign in

Jack Hamilton

@jackhamilton.bsky.social
1.4K followers 392 following 268 posts

Professor of American Studies and Media Studies at the University of Virginia and pop critic for Slate magazine. Author of JUST AROUND MIDNIGHT: ROCK AND ROLL AND THE RACIAL IMAGINATION

PostsRepliesMedia
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
this little bit from phil collins' wikipedia page is so funny
280
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 29/09/2026
If you think POINT BREAK is a "good-bad movie" you should not be allowed to watch movies let alone write about them
021
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 25/09/2026
the NYT ranking the US Office ahead of the UK Office is a Judith Miller level disgrace
040
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
"scooby-doo: origins" www.netflix.com/tudum/articl...
netflix.com
020
Reposted by Jack Hamilton
Oakland Review of Books @oaklandreviewofbooks.org · 01/09/2026
Belatedly: From "The Heart of Rock & Soul." Among the best 800 words of pop music criticism ever written.
149
SOLDIER BOY, The Shirelles
Produced by Luther Dixon; Written by Luther Dixon and
Florence Green
Scepter 1228
1962
Billboard: #1 (3 weeks)
Down at the bus stop you'd see them every morning, books clutched to their car coats, high-rise bouffants frosted in the early chill, wearing too much makeup and already, at fifteen or sixteen, a few too many pounds. I did not know their names and you can be certain they didn'tknow mine. These weren't girls who paid attention to guys their own age; they'd given up on scoring with the jocks or any of the inside crowd and the rest of us were, well, not worth so much as a glance.
Not because they were snobs; because they teared the names that
"smart kids" would call them, which began and ended in the catchall designation, "slut."
So I'll never know for certain if the scraps of conversation you'd pick up from sitting near them told the whole story, or whether i's really fair to fill in many details. But if you watched and listened, you heard stories that implied an experience no guy of my acquaintance could have boasted, a matter-of-fact knowingness about sex and men and the world at large that the college-bound among us didn't yet suspect. These girls might as well already have been women, because their lives were already laid out for them around a narrow set of alternatives: hasty postgraduation marriage and too many pregnancies too soon or else a job at Kroger's or wherever else they needed a checkout clerk, some job you might be able to get without even a diploma.
Or getting knocked up and having the guy ditch her. Or getting knocked up and deciding to have a still-illegal abortion with the risk of being ruined or killedLiving in those mid-America tank towns back then, you knew all sorts of stories like those, just like you knew the stories of their boy-friends, including the one summed up in that line that goes zipping by in "Born in the U.S.A.": "Got in a little hometown jam, so they put a rifle in my hand." Off they went, and after a while, you began to notice that not all of them came back. But mostly they did, and while it would be obscene to argue that that was worse, it would be unfair to exaggerate how much.
By the time they were juniors, maybe a little earlier, certainly before they graduated, a lot of those bouffant girls at the bus stop would have boyfriends serving somewhere overseas, most likely in Germany or a quiescent Korea, where bullets did not fly but nights were long and temptations many. Because the barriers between us were huge, Im guessing again, but maybe they were just devoted pen pals, not doing so well in the high school social scene and so transferring their need to be needed to more distant objects. A lot of these same girls were the first to catch on to the Beatles, and the first to go really mad for one or another of the guys, the ultimate sexual unobtainables. Some of them had already figured that game out before the British Invasion, and they were the most loyal fans of local rock groups, often better ones than the style-setters at school listened to.
But sometimes, I suspect, those girls had real relationships with guys "in the service," not just paper ones, and their lonely nights musthave been especially bereft because it was hard enough to land a guy, let alone worry about his existence a continent and an ocean away.
Reputations are easy to come by and hard to get rid of, especially in your own mind. And so (I'm guessing again) they fretted.
I mention all this because everything I've ever read about "Soldier Boy" treats its enormous popularity as a mystery. Written on the spot in the studio and recorded in the final few minutes of a session, it strikes other critics and historians as perfunctory and tossed off, its unison harmonies and the unison instrumental break shared by organ and guitar insufficiently elaborated.
But whenever I've heard "Soldier Boy," it's made me think of those girls and their boyfriends, each of them lost and confused in a world that they not only didn't understand very well but which manifestly did not like them. And so they found each other, and so they were dragged apart, and so they wondered and pledged and pleaded: "In this whole world, you can love but one girl / Let me be that one girl / For I'll be true to you."
Somehow, in a barracks or a bedroom, those sweetly voiced lines must have helped a few million heads lay more comfortably upon their pillows. And so there's no mystery at all, really, except how so many people can stand right before our eyes and not be seen. Or heard.
083
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 01/09/2026
trying to think of who the funniest person would be to do a deranged nepo-baby take about. currently landed on nas
330
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 25/08/2026
Thinking right now about Lester Bangs' "Where Were You When Elvis Died?" one of my favorite things he ever wrote. We will never again agree on anything as we agreed on Dolly
060
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 25/08/2026
www.youtube.com/watch?v=N7Ij...
youtube.com
The Last Thing on My Mind
YouTube video by Porter Wagoner - Topic
020
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 15/08/2026
RIP Dave Marsh, a writer who changed my life. a few years ago I wrote this about him slate.com/culture/2023...
slate.com
The Greatest Music Critic You’ve (Probably) Never Heard Of
Dave Marsh made me want to write about music.
818257
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 05/08/2026
at every academic conference panel Q&A there's someone who raises their hand with "more a comment than a question" that ends up just being a ramble-y complaint that the paper would be better if it was more like their own work. anyways glad I haven't been at a conference panel with emily wilson
090
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 04/08/2026
season 8 sometimes gets overlooked but lance scorpio, kirk van houten's divorce, poochie and frank grimes all within the span of a few months is one of the craziest heaters in all of american art
4331
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
obama's music lists are always so bizarre and all over the place that I often think they are actually real? as opposed to his book lists which are clearly put together by some comms person while barack listens to the latest hoop collective
021
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
this email subject line really got me
021
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 22/07/2026
"longtime fiancée" would be a killer band name
030
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 17/07/2026
somehow forgot this happened www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4RD...
youtube.com
Madonna - American Pie (Official Video) [HD]
YouTube video by Madonna
251
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 09/07/2026
i hate reading reviews of newer stones albums that act smugly affronted that they're still putting new stuff out in their 80s. I think that's cool as hell
040
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 09/07/2026
saying the odyssey is "non-fiction" because there's archeological evidence that troy was a real place is a little like saying that star wars is non-fiction because someone went to the moon once
010
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 09/07/2026
lol this spoils the whole show
010
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 09/07/2026
I think my favorite thing about bluesky is that the new york times pitchbot account isn't here
230
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 08/06/2026
this week is Spielberg Week at @slate, the cinematic corollary to 2016's Wonder Week. my contribution is this essay on spielberg's colossal 1993, which was fun to write slate.com/culture/2026...
slate.com
He’s One of History’s Greatest Filmmakers. For a Long Time, He Was a Punching Bag. Then One Year Changed Everything.
It was the most astonishing one-two punch in the history of cinema. It still is.
063
Reposted by Jack Hamilton
Alex Elizabeth Byrne McMillan @undeniablyalex.bsky.social · 23/05/2026
YOU’RE LISTENING TO SISYPHUS FM, THE HOME OF NON-STOP ROCK
6085401916197
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 15/05/2026
some personal news, i just released *three* full albums of original material toda--
static.klipy.com
Amadeus Mozart
ALT: Amadeus Mozart
080
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 14/05/2026
"physically Google" is 10/10
080
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 14/05/2026
RIP clarence carter. this is one of the most astonishing recordings ever made imo www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTSB...
youtube.com
Making Love (At the Dark End of the Street)
YouTube video by Clarence Carter - Topic
1147
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 07/05/2026
there are actually a lot of notable exceptions!!! so many that I would argue that the first part of this sentence is simply wrong
140
Reposted by Jack Hamilton
Jody Avirgan @jodyavirgan.com · 30/04/2026
Narrated two great articles on @theatlantic.com this week + @jackhamilton.bsky.social on Heartland Rock + Hua Hsu on the photos of Lee Friedlander www.theatlantic.com/magazine/202... www.theatlantic.com/magazine/202... Shoutout to @harkaudio.com and The Atlantic for prioritizing human narrators!
043
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 29/04/2026
the real list is smokey robinson, everyone else is playing for second
120
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 29/04/2026
greatest dead american songwriters list would be a true banger
2160
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 28/04/2026
I wrote about heartland rock for the new issue of the atlantic www.theatlantic.com/magazine/202...
theatlantic.com
The Lost Idealism of Heartland Rock
The genre of Bob Seger and John Mellencamp reached across the ideological spectrum in a way that seems unimaginable today.
1122
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 24/04/2026
I reviewed MICHAEL, a bad movie that does some things very well, which in many ways makes it worse slate.com/culture/2026...
slate.com
The Real Problem With the Michael Jackson Movie
The megabudget biopic is a train wreck, morally and cinematically. It’s going to be huge.
072
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 02/04/2026
happy birthday marvin gaye www.youtube.com/watch?v=icLb...
youtube.com
Piece Of Clay
YouTube video by Marvin Gaye - Topic
020
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 25/03/2026
media always talking about disaffected young men... what about affected young men
041
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 24/03/2026
the social media era is such a weird cycle of things being discovered and then known and then forgotten and then (re) discovered and then known and then forgotten and this just repeating endlessly
1182
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 20/03/2026
i wrote about peaky blinders and the new movie, which is entertaining but ultimately kind of unsatisfying slate.com/culture/2026...
slate.com
It Was One of My Favorite Shows of the 2010s. Now It’s Back With a Big-Budget Movie.
Netflix’s hit gangster series was great precisely because it never tried to be The Sopranos. The Immortal Man doesn’t either.
021
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 19/03/2026
replying to every political email I get from Steve Kerr with a 3-1 lead meme
010
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 18/03/2026
the best led zeppelin lyric is the bit about the church in "hey hey what can I do." the second best is rhyming "breakdown" with "breakdown" on "communication breakdown"
052
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 09/03/2026
Sally4ever
010
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 27/02/2026
wrote about morgan neville's excellent new documentary about paul mccartney's 1970s slate.com/culture/2026...
slate.com
Paul McCartney Is One of the Most Important Artists in Rock History. He Was Also One of the Most Controversial.
The great new documentary about the virtuosic Beatle rehabilitates two different figures.
0113
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 19/02/2026
i hope it's just the incredibly annoying ad campaign but THE BRIDE looks waayyyyyy too joker. never ever ever go joker
060
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 18/02/2026
WUTHERING HEIGHTS (2026) www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LLb...
youtube.com
Heathcliff (intro)
YouTube video by Mill Creek Entertainment
130
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 17/02/2026
phenomenal nile rodgers interview here, so much going on in this paragraph www.vulture.com/article/nile...
46917
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 16/02/2026
"can't do it sally" has to be one of the coldest line readings in film history. RIP to one of the greatest www.youtube.com/watch?v=kFqg...
youtube.com
For Old Times' Sake
YouTube video by Bil Carter
030
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 15/02/2026
shouldn't expect more from someone still obsessed with "cancel culture" in 2026 but this is just staggeringly ill-informed. wilson was absolutely exceptionally racist by the standards of his day, it's all over the historical record. even many of his present-day defenders concede this! read a book
080
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 11/02/2026
“Nothing but Trouble” (1991) “Mother!” (2017)
230
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 09/02/2026
I think my favorite critique of the BB halftime show booking was "the players don't even listen to him!" which a) is almost certainly untrue and b) presumes that a whole bunch of dudes on, say, the 2009 saints were huge fans of the who
180
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 08/02/2026
Imagine if Bad Bunny came out and just did a whole set of CCR covers in a flawless Fogerty fake-Cajun accent
0170
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 06/02/2026
I think what i've come around to w/ cole is that if you always felt like his stuff was boring and derivative (as I did) then you also weren't really the intended audience for it (too old, too jaded). it reminds me some of the way older people used to complain about the strokes when I was younger
020
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 06/02/2026
weirdly comforting that we're doing j cole discourse once more... you can always go home again
020
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 06/02/2026
the people who are outraged over bad bunny are not worth engaging, they don't know anything about him and don't want to learn anything about him, they just need to be mad at whatever right-wing media tells them to be mad at because they've forgotten any other way to live their lives
0163
Jack Hamilton @jackhamilton.bsky.social · 05/02/2026
funniest thing about the kid rock clip is that it doesn't even seem like his mic is on
010