dlvr.it
'Emergency': Trump biographer warns the president just 'invaded Canada'
On Friday, a prominent biographer of President Donald Trump took to social media to warn that the commander-in-chief had “invaded Canada.” According to Seth Abramson — author of three bestselling books on Trump — the president’s renaming of Lake Ontario is a bigger deal than many realize. In fact, says Abramson, it’s “a bit of an emergency.”
“The argument that Trump invaded Canada today is more compelling than many realize,” posted Abramson. “The border between Canada and the U.S. runs through the middle of Lake Ontario. By claiming to have the power to rename the entire lake, Trump is claiming the lake. That's invasion by declaration.” According to Abramson, while many are being dismissive and even joking about Trump’s order, “the practicalities of what just happened today will hit like a ton of bricks in a matter of hours or days — not weeks. Trump declaring sovereign authority over a body of water half owned by Canada is a big f—— deal.”
“From a legal standpoint,” he elaborates, “it could be argued that what Donald Trump just did today with an executive order was launch what is technically a war — but without any Congressional authorization. That's a bit of an emergency.” Abramson argues that “the onus this puts on Congress to act is almost surreal.”
“We must be very careful in how we think about this,” he warns. “If your view is that this wasn't war because the military wasn't deployed, then you're telling Trump he can declare Greenland to be American soil as long as he doesn't deploy the military — which candidly he wouldn't need to do. By way of analogy, this is what conquistadors did in the Age of Exploration — plant flags on foreign soil and declare it home soil. In Literary Studies, we call this a ‘speech-act.’ Mind you, there are counter-arguments, but this is clearly a major international incident. Speech-acts — including attempted ones — have a complicated history in the law. Don't presume that you can just look at this situation and spitball what did or didn't happen as a layperson. What Trump did today was historically controversial and problematic. It can't be waved away.”
Abramson isn’t alone in this assessment. According to Canadian journalist Annie Dufour, “The Sharpie was the spectacle. Section 2(a) of the executive order is the territorial claim. While most people stared at Donald Trump’s big, fat signature — scribbled with his favourite instrument of international policy, the Sharpie — the fine print of the executive order went unnoticed. As always, the devil is in the details. The name change was the tip of the iceberg. And maps are more than names. Read the executive order. ‘With the deepest parts of the Lake’s waters lying within United States territory, the United States claims most of the Lake’s volume’... The verb is the weapon. Claims.”
She argues that China has been using the same playbook to seize aquatic territory: claim the deepest point, change the name in all federal databases while deleting all old references, then “order the entire federal apparatus to speak as if the deletion had always been true.” As Dufour writes, “China perfected the method in the South China Sea. Rename the reef. Inscribe the name on the official chart. Send the ships. Treat the chart as verdict. The name goes first. The patrol follows the name.” From there, she asserts that the future is “foreseeable.” The U.S. will no longer treat it as a “binational lake. They are on a body of water the United States has already renamed and claimed by volume. Presence follows paperwork.” The same strategy, she says, has long been used by China to “subjugate” its neighbors.
While many are joking about the matter, Abramson warns that could be a grave mistake, reminding that on Trump’s first day back in office, “he signed dozens of unconstitutional EOs that many decided not to take seriously because they were facially preposterous. How soon after did we learn of folks who'd immigrated here from South America getting deported to Africa? Wake the hell up!”
