Sign in

Bill Browne

@browne90.bsky.social
4K followers 774 following 677 posts

Director at The Australia Institute's Democracy & Accountability Program. Views posted are my own.

PostsRepliesMedia
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese sets how many personal staff each member of Parliament gets -- letting him starve his rivals of resources and punishing those who quit the party. Senator Fatima Payman formed an unlikely alliance last week to call him out.
OPINION
I knew I would be punished for crossing the floor. I didn’t expect my staff to be
Fatima Payman

I certainly raised a few eyebrows last week when I walked into the press pack with my biggest adversary, Queensland Senator Pauline Hanson, to stand on a unity ticket asking the Prime Minister to properly resource our parliamentary offices. I wish I didn’t have to resort to such a tactic, but I was out of options, and I knew this was a surefire way to get his attention.
11511
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 18/09/2026
I am heartened by two recent defeats, because they were close-fought things that could have gone either way. They are proof that our efforts can change the direction of our country.
Even the defeats give me hope for democracy

In the last couple of weeks, two very consequential political debates have come down to a single vote. And these two narrow defeats prove that individuals matter, democracy matters, and parliament matters. Nothing is predetermined.
111
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/09/2026
By a quirk of parliamentary programming, on this day 30 years ago Bob Brown and Pauline Hanson rose at the first time to give their first speeches to Parliament. Many topics Brown and Hanson covered three decades ago remain live – from climate change to immigration.
Thirty years ago today, Bob Brown and Pauline Hanson gave very different first speeches

On the 10th of September 1996, two very different politicians rose at the same time to give their first speeches to Parliament, Bob Brown and Pauline Hanson. The Greens and One Nation have become fixtures of Australian politics. The Greens have almost always had more electoral success and many more parliamentarians than One Nation.
2156
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 09/09/2026
Critics of the Greens have compared the Greens’ upcoming decision on the carbon method disallowance to the CPRS vote 17 years ago. But in truth, voting down the CPRS positioned the Greens to negotiate a better climate package the next year.
What does the CPRS vote 17 years ago have to do with the Greens’ decision on carbon offsets this month?

ABC’s Political Editor Jacob Greber said on 730 that the Greens’ decision on how to vote on the carbon credit method’s disallowance motion is “reprising memories of another hard-fought battle over climate policy”, the vote on the Rudd Government’s Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme (CPRS) in 2009. What does a vote 17 years ago have to do with next week’s disallowance motion, and what lessons might the Greens take from the CPRS history?  

By Bill Browne & Anara Watson
254
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 07/09/2026
God AI is an easy-reading primer to the most extreme danger of AI: that it could kill all human life. Walsh recognises the arguments against this ever happening while refusing to be complacent about the catastrophic consequences if it does eventuate.
Build God, Then We’ll Talk

A review of Toby Walsh’s 'God AI'.
111
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 24/08/2026
If the Coalition were not afraid of the “We’ll do the same to you in government” threat, what could they do today to both improve government accountability and make trouble for Labor?
Parliamentary process and open government might be more fruitful ground for Liberals than “Melongate” has been

The Liberal–National Opposition is in a difficult parliamentary position. Still smarting from the worst result in Liberal Party history, they are not a live threat as an alternative government to a Labor Party that holds almost two in every three seats. Nor has the party distinguished itself on policy. 

Bill Browne
131
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 06/08/2026
Dropping the "Westpac" from the Westpac Rescue Helicopter was a last minute decision by the committee -- here's the motion:
121
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 06/08/2026
It's the "Westpac Rescue Helicopter" when things are going well (even though the taxpayer funds most of it) -- but "Northern NSW Helicopter Rescue" when it's in disgrace. Government pays for it, but Westpac gets the credit.
12210
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 16/07/2026
He's no Matt Damon, but Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is a master of the politics of constraint, drawing on lessons that go back to The Odyssey. Odysseus took literally what contemporary politicians apply only metaphorically: to have your hands tied may be a source of strength.
Odysseus, lashed to the mast, can hear the sirens but not heed their calls.
241
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 02/07/2026
Labor's tax reform. Sussan Ley's replacement with Angus Taylor. One Nation's rise. A year is a long time in politics! @amyremeikis.bsky.social and @richarddenniss.bsky.social unpack the 2025 landslide election and what's happened since.
Banner showing webinar details, available in link in next post.
132
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/06/2026
One in 3 Coalition voters defied how-to-vote cards, putting independent Michelle Milthorpe above One Nation. A problem for the parties of the right. Indie and minor party candidates may pick up votes from all sides. New preference data from last month's Farrer by-election.
Liberals split 41% Milthorpe, 59% One Nation. 
Nationals 31%, 69%. 
Legalise Cannabis 63%, 37%.
Greens 92%, 8%.
1122
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 09/06/2026
Two years after NSW Police used a taser to kill a 95-year-old woman with dementia, they are using tasers *more*, not less. Great story from @australia.theguardian.com about the "less violent" weapons being used on protesters, crowds, those experiencing mental health episodes.
Use of Tasers by NSW police

Showing the number for each year -- 340 in 2024-25, up from 194 in 2020-21.
2119
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 21/05/2026
Damning report into the Albanese Govt from the Auditor-General. They already knew that: Govt denies access to some or all information sought in 4 out of 5 cases. And when the impartial umpire reviews, the dept *got it wrong* most of the time.
43,456 FOI requests were received by all agencies and ministers in
2024–25.

79% of the 25,211 decisions made by agencies in 2024–25 were to refuse access in part or full.

62% of Information Commissioner review decisions in 2024–25 were to ‘set aside’ a decision of the agency.
11512
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 13/05/2026
Government scandals slip through the fingers of under-resourced integrity agencies -- without new resources for Audit Office or FOI reviews in the Budget.
Budget 2026: Government scandals slip between the fingers of under-resourced integrity agencies

There was little in the Budget for Australia’s under-resourced integrity agencies, who by the government’s own assessment are not meeting their targets.
162
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 11/05/2026
Don't rush Victoria's new donation and election laws, warn 37 integrity and Vic community groups in a new open letter in the paper today. The old laws were unfair, self-interested, unconstitutional -- to introduce new laws with the same old defects would repeat this error.
152
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 04/05/2026
Albanese Government may have pulled their “friendless” crackdown on freedom of information (FOI) rights but change is needed to address the culture of secrecy and denial that successive governments have allowed to fester in the public service. thepoint.com.au/off-the-char...
There were 81 FOI reviews on hand in 2018, peaking at 1216 in 2023, and now at 807
0102
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 16/04/2026
The High Court has confirmed what Australia Institute research has shown for years: Victoria’s election spending and donation rules are undemocratic, and key provisions are unconstitutional. Question now is how Victorian Parliament responds.
The High Court has confirmed what Australia Institute research has shown for years: Victoria’s election spending and donation rules are undemocratic, and key provisions are unconstitutional. Further, the High Court decision demonstrates how commonplace slipshod and self-interested democratic “reform” has become in Australia – not just in Victoria.
2218
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 16/04/2026
Since Kevin Rudd flubbed "great moral challenge" of climate change, major parties have lost 18% of the vote -- costing them far more in per-vote public funding than they receive from fossil fuel political donations. Lack of political will, not political donations, explains lack of progress.
Australians are naturally suspicious of corporate donations, especially when they come from vested interests with everything to gain from influencing government decision-making. But are these donations large enough to explain why politicians act the way they do? The reality is that political donations from harmful industries are small relative to the payments parties receive from you, the voter.
174
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 15/04/2026
Anthropic head Dario Amodei says a tax on Artificial Intelligence will be "inevitable" after years are spent working out details. He ignores the role of power in policy-making and politics. The graveyard of policy is littered with great ideas that people worked on for years.
The head of Artificial Intelligence firm Anthropic said at the beginning of this month that a tax on Artificial Intelligence (AI) is “inevitable”. Ironically, his comment makes it less likely that such a tax will ever happen. In politics, calling something "inevitable" implies that nobody needs to fight to make it happen.
2249
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 14/04/2026
Australian politicians and thinkers aren't ceding "patriotism" to the far-right. In recent months Anthony Albanese, indie Allegra Spender and Senator Jacqui Lambie have considered what an Australian or inclusive patriotism might look like.
Patriotism has long been seen, particularly among left-wingers, as nationalism with better PR: narrow and short-sighted at best; racist, tribal, and isolationist at worst. But in recent years, Australian politicians have articulated a positive patriotism: one that cares about the Australian people, recognises Australia’s strengths and good qualities, and allows the country to reach its full potential.
121
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 25/03/2026
One Nation's success at the South Australian election puts them in line for $6 to $7 million in taxpayer funding -- most of it thanks to the electoral changes the Malinauskas Labor Govt passed last term. By comparison, One Nation spent $3.3m *nationally* ahead of 2025 election.
Labor on track for $10.4 million public funding, Liberal $8.7 million, One Nation $7.0 million, Greens $3.3 million, over the 2026-2030 election cycle.
52213
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 25/03/2026
The Senate committee looking at climate and energy lies and untruths handed its report yesterday -- Labor, Greens and Liberal on the same page. The Liberal senator, Andrew McLachlan, went further than Labor and called for truth in political advertising laws.
The majority recommends that Australia:

    join global efforts to strengthen climate change information integrity,
    resource regulators like ASIC and ACCC to expose corporate greenwashing,
    explore how to make third parties more transparent ahead of election campaigns,
    continue to provide funding to regional and independent media outlets,
    establish better oversight of corporate engagement within the school system,
    require the digital platforms to report more to ACMA,
    funders ARENA and CEFC to consider the “social licence” of renewables projects.
161
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 17/03/2026
SA's donation laws ban donations to political candidates, but let big lobbies and pressure groups raise and spend money. Third parties in the race include Turning Point Australia, anti-abortion activist Joanna Howe, Australian Christian Lobby, GetUp, and Christopher Pyne.
Browne says third-party groups have a legal right to political communication, but that the reforms have led to “loopholes and perverse outcomes”.

“Under the new laws, a candidate who takes on a powerful interest group can be out-fundraised and outspent by that group many times over,” he says.

“That’s perverse given the candidate is accountable to voters while the lobby group may be opaque, self-interested or an astroturfing operation.”
154
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/03/2026
Over their voting life, a 70-year-old would have seen representation halve: from sharing an MP with 62,000 other voters in 1974 to 121,000 voters in 2025. Albanese Govt is contemplating an increase, which is good -- but on the smaller end would only get us back to 2019 levels.
From around 60,000 voters per seat in 1974 to around 120,000 in 2025. A modest expansion would only go back to 2019 levels.
7238
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 05/03/2026
The Albanese Government's case for crackdown on FOI fell apart when it became clear that there is no "flood" of FOI requests. Case load is about the same as 20 years ago. The extra costs and delays are a result of FOI officers spending their time trying to block access and censor documents.
FOI requests last year are about where they were back in 2003-04.
10242107
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 03/03/2026
Almost half of Australians now say they intend to vote for minor parties and independents -- up from 34% at last year's election. Even before One Nation's meteoric (though to-date only speculative) rise, the 2025 election was a high point.
Minor/indie vote rises from sub-10% in 1970s to 34% at 2025, and 48% in current polling.
3124
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/02/2026
Crisis? What crisis? Govt's own docs prove that there was no "swarm" of FOI requests that required Australians' FOI rights to be restricted. No wonder govt delayed 150 days before releasing. @skyelark.bsky.social on @thepointau.bsky.social live blog: live.thepoint.com.au/2026/02/the-...
Graph shows FOI decisions were much higher in 2016-17 than under the Albanese Government.
14627
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 09/02/2026
Nationals have for many years held what were thought of as the safest starts in the country, with One Nation preferences helping ward off Labor. One Nation's rise is a another reminder that there are no safe seats. On @thepointau.bsky.social live blog live.thepoint.com.au/2026/02/the-...
The single largest category of seats "to watch" re One Nation's rise is safe seats, followed by fairly safe. Few "marginal" seats are among the 25 most vulnerable.
051
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/11/2025
6/ Between 1972 and 1975, Parliament passed 647 acts of Parliament, compared to 500 between 2021 and 2024.
Acts of Parliament peaked at 221 in 1973, compared to a high of 142 for the last four years (in 2021).
120
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/11/2025
5/ Parliament does not sit for as long as it used to -- between 417 and 634 hours a year from 2021-2024 compared to between 678 and 913 sitting hours a year from 1972-1975. And they fought three elections during that time -- compared to one in the last four years.
Each year 1972 to 1975 had more sitting hours than any year 2021 to 2024 did.
120
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/11/2025
4/ Australians are less represented than ever, with the average local MP now representing 121,000 people -- compared to 65,000 each in 1975. Australia is long-overdue for an increase in the number of parliamentarians.
Apart from a small dip in 1984 when the number of seats in Parliament increased, the average number of voters per House of Reps seat has increased steadily from 57,000 in 1972 to 121,000 in 2025.
120
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/11/2025
3/ Parliament is much more diverse, both in terms of Indigenous Australian representation and women. Whitlam's "It's time" election was with 93 male Labor MPs and senators and *no* women. Now women are a majority in the Labor caucus.
From 3 Labor women and 3 Coalition women in 1975 to 69 Labor women, 22 Coalition women and 20 crossbench women in 2025.
130
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/11/2025
2/ The independent and minor party vote has gone from 4% to 34%. 1975 was the last year where a major party or coalition won a majority of the primary vote.
The Labor and Coalition votes decline from around 50% to around 33%, while the independent and minor party vote grows.
130
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 10/11/2025
How democracy has changed since 1975, in six charts: 1/ The crossbench has grown from 3 in the Senate to 20 in the Senate and 13 in the House, making blocking supply much more difficult than it was for Malcolm Fraser.
In 1975, the Senate had 27 Labor, 30 Coalition and 3 crossbenchers; now it is 29 Labor, 27 Coalition and 20 crossbenchers.
In 1975, the House had 66 Labor, 61 Coalition and 0 crossbenchers; now it is 94 Labor, 43 Coalition and 13 crossbench.
191
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 05/11/2025
ABC News and the Canberra Times showed a lot of interest in the citizens' jury back in the day. Spot a (much younger) Bill in the crowd -- www.abc.net.au/news/2018-04...
120
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 07/10/2025
The proposed $50 fee per FOI request will make it harder to get information out of government, but do practically nothing to reduce the overall cost of the scheme.
Cost recovery (assuming $50 fee) would raise less than $500,000, against a scheme that cost $86 million last year.
0133
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 07/10/2025
It takes four public servants to do what took just one under the Howard Government. That explains why administrative costs have more than tripled.
Whereas the average request once took 13 hours to determine (2006-07), it now takes 51 hours (2023-24).
111
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 07/10/2025
The Freedom of Information system is so inefficient and expensive *because* it's secretive -- in last year of Howard Govt, there were 27,500 FOI requests granted in full, vs just 4,500 granted in full in 2023-24.
The number of FOI requests granted “in full” has fallen from
81% in 2006-07 to just 21% in 2023-24.
120
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 07/10/2025
Govt fearmongering about AI writing Freedom of Information requests, vexatious applicants and a swamped eSafety Commission is overstated. The FOI workload is actually at a low point for the decade.
There were only 21,000 requests determined in each of 2022-23 and 2023-24,13 down about a third from the 10-year peak of 34,000 in 2016-17.
3157
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 03/09/2025
Govt leans heavily on eSafety Commissioner receiving 600 FOI requests in one year. However frivolous they may be, they were overwhelmingly for personal info - so fees wouldn't apply. And at just 1 or 2% of all FOIs, they are not the reason the system is so expensive in money and work-hours.
13212
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 02/09/2025
The Albanese Government wants to charge Australians for making a freedom of information request. Makes dubious claims about tech being used to overwhelm the system. In truth? Govt workload one of the lowest in the last 20 years.
Number of FOI requests determined is at lowest rate since 2011-12, but the cost of running the FOI system has hit new highs.
59646
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 27/08/2025
Senator @davidshoebridge.bsky.social has introduced a private member's bill that would protect the right to protest. @australiainstitute.org.au polling research last year finds 71% of Australians support protest protections.
Graph shows 71% support, 15% oppose legislation to protect the right to peaceful protest.
23617
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 08/08/2025
Four interesting graphs breaking down past election results from Mark the Ballot. The first shows how the Albanese Govt made history with a swing towards them after their first term.
Graph shows the two-party preferred for Labor and the Coalition since 1946, and which party was in government.
3357
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 05/08/2025
Labor won almost two-thirds of seats at the last federal election, a testament to Australians strongly preferring them to the Lib-Nat Coalition. But as my colleague @skyelark.bsky.social writes for @australiainstitute.org.au, the gap between primary votes and seats won is historically large.
Labor won almost two thirds of seats despite receiving just over a third of the vote in May. Graph compares UK 2024, Australian House of Reps, Australian Senate and New Zealand 2023. Proportional representation systems deliver more proportional results.
394
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 30/07/2025
Aboriginal Tent Embassy a permanent protest established on 26 January 1972 in response to attempts to restrict land rights. The embassy was forced to move, but in 1992 returned to the original site. Gough Whitlam visited the site to discuss the embassy’s demands.
The Aboriginal Flag at the Tent Embassy in 1974.
1276
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 30/07/2025
Anti-apartheid activists disrupted 1971 South African rugby tour. Protesters “blew whistles, held up placards, and ran onto the field if possible” to interrupt matches. Sir Don Bradman cancelled 1972 cricket tour: “We will not play them until they choose a team on a non-racist basis”.
Deputy President of the African National Congress Nelson Mandela and Prime Minister Bob Hawke, October 1990. Mandela was only recently freed from prison.
1268
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 30/07/2025
When the first Gay & Lesbian Mardi Gras in 1978 marched beyond permit, 53 were charged. NSW Police bashed protestor Peter Murphy. Later rallies made police drop charges; parliament changed protest laws, expanded anti-discrimination protections and decriminalised homosexuality.
The first Mardi Gras entrants from 1978 at the 30th Annual Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras, Sydney, Saturday, March 01, 2008
1186
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 30/07/2025
Young men protested conscription to Vietnam War by burning their draft cards. Commentators said they were doing it for the attention. Protesters interrupted US President LBJ, blocked his car: “Hey, hey, LBJ: How many kids did you kill today?”
Protester holds placard saying "LBJ = Hypocrite. World opinion is against US in Vietnam."
1167
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 30/07/2025
Port Kembla dockworkers went on strike in 1938 to stop iron exports to Japan - which had committed mass murder of civilians and POWs in China. Menzies called it "a provocative act against a friendly power" but grateful Chinese-Australians sent food to striking workers.
In 1939 photo, Attorney-General Menzies walks through strikers. Posters include: "Bombs Hurt People".
3198
Bill Browne @browne90.bsky.social · 30/07/2025
When the original Parliament House opened in 1927, no Indigenous Australians were invited - but Wiradjuri elders Jimmy Clements and John Noble walked the 93km to the opening. They came to talk about injustices – including being forced to work without pay and children being taken away.
Jimmy Clements, a Wiradjuri elder, on steps of Parliament House
2239