Sign in

David McWilliam

@scotland-exp.bsky.social
2.5K followers 2.8K following 215 posts

Evidence-led writing on Scotland's economy, institutions and constitutional choices. Beyond slogans towards competence, stewardship and democratic power. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcwilliam

PostsRepliesMedia
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 04/10/2026
Sixty homes in Coalsnaughton face demolition. What does recovery require when mining’s legacy makes a neighbourhood unsafe? My new Scotland Explained essay examines suitable housing and the obligations that survive closure. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/coalsnaugh...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Coalsnaughton: when the mine closes, the liability remains
Sixty homes face demolition in a former mining village. Recovery must restore people’s lives, while the investigation establishes how the ground beneath them came to be unsafe.
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 27/09/2026
Five months of Scotland Explained. 34 articles. 6,603 views. 22 article-attributed new subscribers. But the interesting part is what people actually read, discuss and subscribe for. I’ve looked back at the first five months and what comes next. scotlandexplained.substack.com/p/five-month...
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
A nationally important battlefield can be protected in principle, yet lost one development at a time. I grew up under Stirling Castle and attended Bannockburn High. This is why I am objecting to the proposed Crookbridge development. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/bannockbur...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Bannockburn Is Still a Battlefield.
Why I am objecting to the proposed Crookbridge retail development and what it tells us about stewardship in Scotland
041
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
When IndyRef2 is a question of law sceptical.scot/2026/09/when...
sceptical.scot
When IndyRef2 is a question of law
A constitutional right that depends upon the changing language of individual prime ministers is not a dependable constitutional right…
052
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 13/09/2026
Scottish people still learn to adopt a “telephone voice” when dealing with institutions that treat English prestige speech as neutral. My new essay examines language, authority and Scotland’s unfinished Enlightenment. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/the-enligh...
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 10/09/2026
Chris Law asked why Northern Ireland has a statutory route to a constitutional vote while Scotland does not. Burnham called the situations 'exactly the same', then made refusal conditional on public support. They are not the same. A Question of Law:
036
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 09/09/2026
davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/a-question...
023
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 06/09/2026
Scotland has visible repair needs and people excluded from engineering, trades and public-administration careers. A paid Scottish Civic Service could connect them, while protecting existing jobs. Repair the asset. Qualify the worker. Retain the wealth. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/a-scottish...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
A Scottish Civic Service
Build the country, build the skills, build wealth from the ground up
010
Reposted by David McWilliam
Vlad Vexler @vladvexler.bsky.social · 05/09/2026
youtu.be/I0d36ez-XvU?...
youtu.be
Witkoff & Kushner meet Putin - this is what collapse of US state capacity looks like
YouTube video by Vlad Vexler Chat
25316
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 02/09/2026
A draft Bill is not referendum powers. My new Scotland Explained article looks at what a Section 30 request can establish, what refusal leaves unresolved, and the context of the September programme. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/what-a-sec...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
What a Section 30 Request Can and Cannot Do
A draft referendum bill and a five-year programme bring Scotland’s constitutional ambitions back to questions of process, preparation and delivery.
020
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 02/09/2026
Holyrood’s vote, a request for powers and a Section 30 order are not the same thing. I’ve revised the Scotland Explained explainer to make the legal process clearer. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/the-sectio...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
The Section 30 Question: Scotland’s Mandate Meets Westminster’s Veto
What Holyrood’s vote changed, what it did not, and why a parliamentary mandate is not the same as referendum powers.
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 31/08/2026
193
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 29/08/2026
I can't believe this London-based landowner is putting the iconic Glenelg to Skye ferry at risk. Support the local community - not millionaire financiers - and save the world famous Glenelg to Skye ferry by joining me and signing the petition today: you.38degrees.org.uk/petitions/sa...
you.38degrees.org.uk
Save the Glenelg - Skye ferry!
This ten minute crossing is famous around the world - and is believed to be the last turntable style ferry anywhere. It's an iconic part of Skye's history, but it's under threat thanks to a wealthy la...
010
Reposted by David McWilliam
Richard Murphy @richardjmurphy.bsky.social · 28/08/2026
We can afford nationalisation if only politicians understood it youtu.be/iyz-qzmNkCE?... Our politicians claim we cannot afford nationalisation. They ignore two things. We only pay with bonds, not cash, and the interest would pay the interest cost if they go at the right price.
youtu.be
We can afford nationalisation if only politicians understood it
YouTube video by Richard J Murphy
416086
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 28/08/2026
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 26/08/2026
Tanera Mòr shows what becomes possible when capital can wait and decisions can be joined together. Its renewal is real. So is the democratic question: why should communities need the right billionaire to make long-term stewardship practical? davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/tanera-mor...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Tanera Mòr and the Power to Make Things Happen
A privately funded island restoration shows what patient capital and joined-up stewardship can achieve. It also reveals why rural renewal cannot depend upon finding the right billionaire.
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 23/08/2026
Expressing national feeling, promoting Scottish interests, binding the UK and deciding the constitution require different mandates. The new Scotland Explained essay asks who speaks, on what subject, with what authority and to what effect. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/who-gets-t...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Who Gets to Speak for Scotland?
Speaking for Scotland is not one power. Expressing national feeling, promoting devolved interests, negotiating with another government, binding the state and authorising constitutional change each req...
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 22/08/2026
I can't believe this London-based landowner is putting the iconic Glenelg to Skye ferry at risk. Support the local community - not millionaire financiers - and save the world famous Glenelg to Skye ferry by joining me and signing the petition today: you.38degrees.org.uk/petitions/sa...
you.38degrees.org.uk
Save the Glenelg - Skye ferry!
This ten minute crossing is famous around the world - and is believed to be the last turntable style ferry anywhere. It's an iconic part of Skye's history, but it's under threat thanks to a wealthy la...
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 19/08/2026
Scotland Explained has reached 250 subscribers. I’m immensely grateful to everyone who reads, shares and challenges the work. It will remain free to read. Subscriptions started by 30 August receive 20% off the first year for anyone who wants to support the project. substack.com/@davidmcwill...
substack.com
Scotland Explained (@davidmcwilliam)
250 subscribers. Thank you. I had intended to write a note when Scotland Explained reached 200 subscribers. By the time I noticed, it had already sailed past 220. Today, it reached 250. In the last ...
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 19/08/2026
A strategy is not governing because institutions have 'had regard' to it. Budgets, ownership, procurement and accountability decide whether public purpose becomes real. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/who-decide...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Who Decides What Scotland Is For?
Public purpose cannot be left to governments, markets or constitutional camps alone
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 19/08/2026
Scotland has no shortage of visions. The harder question is who authors them, what makes them operative and who can revise them. My new essay asks: Who Decides What Scotland Is For? davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/who-decide...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Who Decides What Scotland Is For?
Public purpose cannot be left to governments, markets or constitutional camps alone
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 16/08/2026
goodlawproject.org/petition/jas...
goodlawproject.org
Jason Arday: Demand a public inquiry now | Good Law Project
Commission an immediate public inquiry into how to ensure a responsible press given its contribution to Dr Arday’s tragic death.
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 16/08/2026
Scotland has a Parliament of people. Should it also have a Council of places? Article 13 proposes 64 locally rooted members, broad territorial scrutiny, strong powers in a narrow field and no role in government formation or supply. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/a-parliame...
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
A Parliament of People and Places
Why Scotland needs a Council of Scotland
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 13/08/2026
substack.com/@vladvexler/...
substack.com
Vlad Vexler (@vladvexler)
Getting ready for the implosion of Trumpism https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUW39XXxm_U
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 12/08/2026
GERS records a real Scottish fiscal gap: £98.3bn in revenue, £123.6bn in spending and a £25.3bn deficit. It is not Holyrood’s overdraft or an independence forecast. The honest argument starts with the baseline, then shows what would change. davidmcwilliam.substack.com/p/gers-what-...
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 10/08/2026
youtube.com/watch?v=Hbz7...
youtube.com
Inside the Insane Muslim NATO Nobody Saw Coming
YouTube video by Pyotr Kurzin | Geopolitics
000
Reposted by David McWilliam
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 02/08/2026
Scotland's choice is not state or market. It is whether ownership, power and reward are matched to economic function. Article 11 sets out the Scottish Hybrid Model: enterprise, shared ownership and public purpose. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
The Scottish Hybrid Model
How Scotland can combine enterprise, shared ownership and public purpose
001
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 04/08/2026
000
Reposted by David McWilliam
Richard Murphy @richardjmurphy.bsky.social · 03/08/2026
There is no news from a government that’s in office but on holiday during a crisis www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/08... Where is Burnham's government as the climate crisis hits home?
taxresearch.org.uk
There is no news from a government that’s in office but on holiday during a crisis
It is August, and it is not true to say there is no news, but there is certainly less of it bering rwported. Donald Trump claims that his war is on hold at present, although no one should be taken in....
02512
Reposted by David McWilliam
Richard Murphy @richardjmurphy.bsky.social · 03/08/2026
Andy Burnham’s social care plan protects wealth, not those in need youtu.be/_bEyVo6-alM?... Why is Andy Burnham presuming that younger people with some of the highest overall tax rates should pay to protect those with wealth? This issue needs to be named - or he'll embed injustice.
youtu.be
Andy Burnham’s social care plan protects wealth, not those in need
YouTube video by Richard J Murphy
310146
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 02/08/2026
Scotland's choice is not state or market. It is whether ownership, power and reward are matched to economic function. Article 11 sets out the Scottish Hybrid Model: enterprise, shared ownership and public purpose. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
The Scottish Hybrid Model
How Scotland can combine enterprise, shared ownership and public purpose
001
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 27/07/2026
Scotland entered this wildfire season with a serious plan. But a plan is not the people, equipment or guaranteed access needed when conditions turn. The Cairngorms fires expose a resilience gap that crosses the devolution boundary. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
A Plan Is Not a Capability
What the Cairngorms fires reveal about Scotland's resilience gap
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 27/07/2026
open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
Stewarding the Future
How Scotland can turn investment into value, lasting capability and greater freedom to choose
001
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 26/07/2026
open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
Stewarding the Future
How Scotland can turn investment into value, lasting capability and greater freedom to choose
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 26/07/2026
Article 9 asked who owns tomorrow when the public borrows. Article 10 asks what competent stewardship demands: begin with real resources, connect investments, set terms for capital, retain value and ensure that each project leaves Scotland more capable than before. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
Stewarding the Future
How Scotland can turn investment into value, lasting capability and greater freedom to choose
010
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 22/07/2026
#trump
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 19/07/2026
Every generation inherits a country it did not build. How we finance hospitals, schools, energy and transport helps determine what the next one inherits. Article 9 asks: when the public pays, who owns the future? Borrowing the Future: open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
Borrowing the Future
Why the way we finance public investment determines who owns tomorrow
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 17/07/2026
New blog on Sunday, supplemental articles mid week. Please subscribe and share if this appeals to you #scotland davidmcwilliam.substack.com
davidmcwilliam.substack.com
Scotland Explained | Substack
Scotland Explained: evidence-led writing on Scotland’s economy, institutions, public services and future choices. Clearer, calmer debate, with sources visible. Click to read Scotland Explained on Subs...
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 16/07/2026
I just signed a @scotrewilding.bsky.social petition: Scotland Needs a Nature Minister. Sign here: actionnetwork.org/petitions/sc...
actionnetwork.org
Scotland Needs a Nature Minister
This year Scotland signed off on the Natural Environment Act, setting up a framework to create nature recovery targets. Now, it’s up to the new government to create targets that will lead to the resto...
000
Reposted by David McWilliam
Richard Murphy @richardjmurphy.bsky.social · 14/07/2026
Why the wealthy pay less tax than you do - and how to fix it youtu.be/2Ys9m1t8lN4?... The tax system is fundamentally biased in favour of wealth. Let's change that right before doing a wealth tax, or the bias will remain.
youtu.be
Why the wealthy pay less tax than you - and how to fix it
YouTube video by Richard J Murphy
110246
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 13/07/2026
open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 12/07/2026
Governments are temporary. Public obligations endure. Article 8 asks what good government looks like when a nation is treated as an inheritance rather than a possession… open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
A Nation Is Inherited, Not Owned
Competent Stewardship and the Purpose of Government
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 08/07/2026
Grievance is not design. A better unionism must explain how Scotland becomes more capable inside the UK. A better nationalism must explain how Scotland becomes more capable outside it. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
open.substack.com
Managed Region, Comfort Zone.
How unionist and nationalist parochialism both shrink Scotland
000
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 07/07/2026
You’re obsessing over the wrong peter thiel conference open.substack.com/pub/broligar...
open.substack.com
You're obsessing over the wrong Peter Thiel conference
Forget Dialog. Bilderberg is where the actual masters of the universe meet. Three guesses who secretly funds it?
001
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 07/07/2026
Scotland likes to think of itself as outward-looking. — Nextdoor - Nextdoor nextdoor.co.uk/p/fxkHbTsy8q...
nextdoor.co.uk
Scotland likes to think of itself as outward-looking.
Join Nextdoor, an app for neighbourhoods where you can get local tips, buy and sell items, and more
011
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 07/07/2026
The problem is not that Scotland is small. The problem is that too much of Scotland’s political culture behaves as though smallness is destiny. open.substack.com/pub/davidmcw...
A solitary figure standing inside a dim civic building, looking out through a narrow window onto a vast Scottish horizon of sea, hills and city lights. The interior feels constrained and institutional, while the outside world feels expansive and open. Realistic cinematic style, soft natural light, reflective mood, no text, no party-political symbols.

Caption:

A country can have a wide horizon and still argue through a narrow frame.
100
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 06/07/2026
You’re out of your element, Donnie. Stfu
000
Reposted by David McWilliam
Richard Murphy @richardjmurphy.bsky.social · 06/07/2026
SNPs are making a big mistake by not issuing their first Scottish bond this way www.thenational.scot/politics/262... Me in The National this morning.
thenational.scot
SNP are making a big mistake by not issuing its first Scottish bond this way
The Scottish Government is expected to issue its first bond later this year or early next year
43915
David McWilliam @scotland-exp.bsky.social · 05/07/2026
Tech billionaires are getting richer while we pay the price for the real-world harm their platforms cause. The "neutral host" loophole lets them off the hook for pushing dangerous content. MPs are demanding emergency laws to make them pay. Add your name: you.38degrees.org.uk/petitions/st...
you.38degrees.org.uk
Sign the urgent petition
Tech billionaires shouldn't get to hide behind a legal loophole while their algorithms push dangerous content for profit. MPs are demanding emergency laws to finally make them liable for the harm they...
011
Reposted by David McWilliam
Richard Murphy @richardjmurphy.bsky.social · 05/07/2026
Why politicians keep getting the economy wrong youtu.be/MyVsdntYWj4?... Politicians keep claiming there is a shortage of money - but that's nonsense. If there are resources to buy, they can always create the money to put them to use.
youtu.be
Why politicians keep getting the economy wrong
YouTube video by Richard J Murphy
28233