Sign in

David Polansky

@polanskydj.bsky.social
104 followers 37 following 87 posts

davidpolansky.substack.com

PostsRepliesMedia
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 06/10/2026
For my debut in the excellent Liberties, I surveyed the filmography of what might be my favorite director, Éric Rohmer. Give it a read—and watch the films too while you’re at it. libertiesjournal.com/online-artic...
libertiesjournal.com
Eric Rohmer's Cinematic Symposia
Midway through Plato’s Symposium the comic poet Aristophanes takes the floor. He tells us that, in the beginning, we were whole, shaped like the heavenly bodies. But we became too powerful and made wa...
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 05/10/2026
Ok but I hate it here
020
Reposted by David Polansky
Phoebe Maltz Bovy @phoebebovy.bsky.social · 01/10/2026
Fantastic op-ed by @polanskydj.bsky.social in @thecjn.bsky.social thecjn.ca/opinion/how-...
thecjn.ca
How others see us: Canada's antisemitism problem harms Jews here and embarrasses Canada abroad
A country’s capacity to provide for minority protections, and more broadly its cultivating the kind of tolerance that makes such protections unnecessary, is simply a mark of liberal civilization.
3105
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 02/09/2026
Not a justification of the war, but one of its benefits is discovering our own real-world limitations/gaps in a non-catastrophic scenario. War is like wine, etc.
020
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 01/09/2026
The ongoing US-Canada trade war (which may not in fact be a trade war), has inflamed unexpected passions on both sides. I try to bring some perspective here, which will likely please nobody: thehub.ca/2026/08/31/t...
thehub.ca
Trump’s trade war is bringing out the worst in everyone
Trump's trade war didn't just hurt the economy—it exposed how quickly everyone, from politicians to the public, abandons good sense under pressure.
011
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/08/2026
I also haven't looked into the CVs of the scholars in question. One hopes they are more serious than the Jason Stanley, Tim Snyder cases from last year.
010
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/08/2026
I am skeptical that that particular example tells us much, because I'm not sure how replicable it is. It required both a political catalyst and significant one-time public expenditure to make up for what are otherwise lower salaries in a high-tax/high cost of living country.
110
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/08/2026
Likewise. Yes, I partially violated this precept in order to make a similar point here: davidpolansky.substack.com/p/our-idiocr...
davidpolansky.substack.com
Our Idiocratic Moment
On not talking to people who are not worth talking to
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/08/2026
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3K7...
youtube.com
Waiters who are Nauseated by Food
YouTube video by Flippy92
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/08/2026
I normally agree with this kind of conclusion but am compelled to note how many traditional media publications have devoted extensive spreads to him, and not just for critical purposes.
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 20/08/2026
It's not good
031
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 20/08/2026
There's an interesting convergence between Graeber's thesis and RETVRN aesthetics
31063
Reposted by David Polansky
Aeon Magazine @aeon.co · 03/08/2026
Thucydides’s ‘History of the Peloponnesian War’ is often misunderstood, being invoked both as a critique and a justification in international relations. This essay explores the irony of this tendency and why his work is just as relevant to today
buff.ly
Thucydides’ account of war is as timely as it is misunderstood | Aeon Essays
Far from thinking that ‘might makes right’, the great historian’s analysis of war identifies a vice common to all states
0176
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
Revised commandment from Dune: thou shalt not make a human mind in the likeness of a machine.
010
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 25/07/2026
Have you written anything on your dislike of Oppenheimer?
110
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 16/05/2026
Though doesn't the weakness of his attachments to any consistent approach lend credence to more enduring structural accounts? Or am I misreading your point?
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 20/04/2026
There's been much discussion about the significance of Orbán's electoral defeat, not to say his prior rule. But as I ask and try to answer here, why do so many people across the political spectrum continue to obsess over Hungary in the first place?
open.substack.com
Wherever flow the rivers of the Tisza and the Danube
On our curious Hungarian fixation
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 13/03/2026
As the recent attack on the the U.S. consulate in Toronto indicates, the persistent targeting of Jewish institutions in Canada are not just a problem for Jews, but for Canadian sovereignty itself. I explain why in @nationalpost.bsky.social today nationalpost.com/opinion/syna...
nationalpost.com
David Polansky: Synagogue shootings are an assault on Canadian sovereignty
The perpetrators of these crimes are not only threatening Jews, but the rule of law and the government's ability to protect civil society
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 27/02/2026
I recently half-joked that we decided to destroy modern literacy in order to get rid of imaginary "lit bros." I make the actual argument here: www.washingtonexaminer.com/premium/4470...
washingtonexaminer.com
Thirty years of anti-intellectual pretexts for hating Infinite Jest
In the internet age, in the absence of direct social interaction, we have been compelled to invent people to get mad at.
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 29/01/2026
Wait, are there any conditions in which you would accept the removal of residents who were here illegally?
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 24/01/2026
This is our Iliad, and even if it weren't it's not like we're exactly surfeited with literacy among the young these days that we need them discarding what reading materials they have
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 16/01/2026
Glad they upheld
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 15/01/2026
I am not wildly enthused about Trump's latest bluster over Greenland, but as I wrote here, it has been instructive to see Europeans, Canadians, et al. displaying such outrage at being treated like American dependencies. What exactly did they think they were? thecritic.co.uk/how-much-res...
thecritic.co.uk
How much respect does the US owe its allies? | David Polansky | The Critic Magazine
Perhaps the closest thing President Donald Trump has to a bedrock principle is his instinctive opposition to any arrangement that favors — or seems to favor — the other guy. The notion that someone…
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 01/01/2026
For your New Year's reading: debates over citizenship are everywhere, from the birthright question in the U.S. and Canada to the Alaa Abd El-Fattah controversy and beyond, but we we lack a clear understanding of how the concept has changed over time. www.city-journal.org/article/anci...
city-journal.org
The Revolution in Citizenship
Its modern meaning is less suggestive of obligations than of a desired status that confers benefits.
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 23/12/2025
Needing a break from heavier themes, I wrote probably more than most people want to know about properties of sound, audio equipment, and collecting vinyl records. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/my-music-c...
davidpolansky.substack.com
My Music Career
I felt I needed a bit of a break from heavier themes, and this post was inspired by my friend Ryan Floyd of Detached Notes. He has belatedly made the excellent decision to get into vinyl and has been ...
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 02/12/2025
Were you lecturing at Henry Hill's wedding?
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 18/11/2025
I treasure my Brazilian LPs, but I don't think I've come by any of them easily
010
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 18/11/2025
Yeah I meant the LP -- have been searching for it
110
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 18/11/2025
Do you have this one?
110
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 17/11/2025
I reviewed the new book by @shadihamid.bsky.social which makes the case for American power. My takeaway is that he's reverse engineering neoconservatism albeit from very different premises. Give it a read (both the book and the review): davidpolansky.substack.com/p/review-sha...
davidpolansky.substack.com
Review: Shadi Hamid's The Case for American Power
or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Hegemon
011
Reposted by David Polansky
Phoebe Maltz Bovy @phoebebovy.bsky.social · 21/10/2025
Free speech Canada vs US, an ongoing conundrum. A delight as always to chat with @polanskydj.bsky.social, for The Jewish Angle @thecjn.bsky.social thecjn.ca/opinion/is-f...
thecjn.ca
Is 'free speech' suddenly freer in Canada than the U.S.?
The 2020s are entering the era of the 'woke right', where permissible language is dictated by right-wing governments.
032
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 15/10/2025
Another example of this www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RLu...
youtube.com
Richard Thompson - Grey Funnel Line - with Teddy Thompson- Town Hall NYC live 10/18/2024
YouTube video by A Mandolin Player on Carnegie Hill
130
Reposted by David Polansky
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 08/10/2025
I mostly stayed offline yesterday, but I did set down some thoughts on why, as much as I do hope this latest peace proposal sticks, the larger question of Palestinian sovereignty is still unresolved—partly because people seem to keep seeing past it. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/what-did-w...
davidpolansky.substack.com
What Did We Learn?
Looking back and forward on the second anniversary of the 10/7 attacks
101
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 08/10/2025
The absence of the substance of sovereignty remains an issue that people still seem to talk around rather than about, and it remains the outstanding question where enduring stability in the Levant is concerned.
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 08/10/2025
Rather, an identity was cultivated over time by primarily external actors: not just the Israelis, but the Soviets, other Arab states, international organizations, etc. As all of those (except Israel) retreated, it was like a scaffolding being taken down without a building.
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 08/10/2025
Part of this is simply a function of the strange trajectory of Palestinian nationhood: it was neither a case of a preexisting nation that still seeks political independence, nor a case of an existing state that had to cultivate a national identity.
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 08/10/2025
Neither the legions of negotiators, nor the new wave of formal recognitions for a Palestinian state, nor the "Free Palestine" crowd has really worked out the core question: who actually rules and with what authority?
110
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 08/10/2025
I mostly stayed offline yesterday, but I did set down some thoughts on why, as much as I do hope this latest peace proposal sticks, the larger question of Palestinian sovereignty is still unresolved—partly because people seem to keep seeing past it. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/what-did-w...
davidpolansky.substack.com
What Did We Learn?
Looking back and forward on the second anniversary of the 10/7 attacks
101
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 30/09/2025
I will admit to not being a fan, though I agree that you can see them diverging, and in retrospect the technocratic and messianic approaches were probably always an uneasy fit. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/innocents-...
davidpolansky.substack.com
Innocents Abroad
On Ta-Nehisi Coates' sojourn to the Holy Land
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 29/09/2025
Yeah that sounds like Coates
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 29/09/2025
Oh I haven't listened to the interview, but a lot of people on here seem, um, disproportionately upset about it
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 29/09/2025
Brave post
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 12/09/2025
In the wake of Kirk's killing, I am seeing what has become a common tendency to attribute such attacks to a kind of abstract political contagion or historical momentum we can barely withstand. I try to explain here why I think we should resist this impulse. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/against-th...
davidpolansky.substack.com
Against the Passive Voice
On the mental resistance of despair as political practice
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 04/07/2025
Living outside the United States on this 4th of July, I wrote about the theme of exile, with reflections on Dante, Caetano Veloso, and Jason Stanley -- a sentence that I'm pretty sure no one has written before. Link below. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/on-exile
davidpolansky.substack.com
On Exile
Considerations on Dante, Caetano Veloso, Jason Stanley, and me
010
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 20/06/2025
I wrote (what I hope is) a non-hysterical consideration of the problem of rising antisemitism in Canada. Unlike the United States, it's not significantly involved in the Middle East already, which may allow for greater clarity. thehub.ca/2025/06/20/d...
thehub.ca
David Polansky: Kind, tolerant Canada is failing the antisemitism test
An increasingly multicultural Canada is increasingly hostile towards Canada’s Jews
010
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 13/06/2025
"I like it here in the mental asylum"
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 05/06/2025
What's the best source/argument you know of regarding Diab's guilt or innocence in the matter?
100
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 26/05/2025
For your Memorial Day reading, I wrote about the mistaken belief that we're living in a time of intense ideological conflicts. davidpolansky.substack.com/p/non-immens...
davidpolansky.substack.com
Non-immense Wars of the Non-spirit
Over three decades ago, Francis Fukuyama published his famous End of History and the Last Man, in which he declared that history (or rather, “History”), meaning an unfolding process of clashing ideas,...
000
David Polansky @polanskydj.bsky.social · 24/05/2025
Because it's ALL our turf...
010