Sign in

paulelie.bsky.social

@paulelie.bsky.social
195 followers 20 following 51 posts
PostsRepliesMedia
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 11/09/2026
"People on the street were comparing the Trade Center blast to Armageddon. The airwaves were crowded with God-talk. The mayor had suggested that God’s will was somehow behind those who got out alive." My essay in @commonwealmagazine.org about September 11, 2001 www.commonwealmagazine.org/innocents-2
commonwealmagazine.org
The Innocents
Only through a life like Christ’s can such wrongs be righted, such senseless deaths set in counterpoint.
001
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 04/08/2026
"In Peru every August, throngs of Catholics set out on foot from the remote northern town of Motupe, bound for a cliffside chapel that houses the Cross of Chalpon." I was among them a year ago -- reporting a Profile for The New Yorker (@newyorker.com) of Leo XIV www.newyorker.com/magazine/202...
000
Reposted by @paulelie.bsky.social
Los Angeles Review of Books @lareviewofbooks.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
“'The Perfect Moment' is akin to the quilt that Butler saw as a young man: it brings together stories of people whose efforts might be forgotten otherwise.” Paul Elie on Isaac Butler's "The Perfect Moment": lareviewofbooks.org/article/perfect…
the cover of The Perfect Moment
021
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
My latest: a review essay, in the Los Angeles Review of Books (@lareviewofbooks.bsky), focused on THE PERFECT MOMENT, by Isaac Butler, whose subject matter overlaps that of THE LAST SUPPER lareviewofbooks.org/article/anyt...
lareviewofbooks.org
Anything Could Become a Battleground | Los Angeles Review of Books
Isaac Butler’s new book mixes history and personal testimony to examine the ‘culture wars’ that shaped the 1980s—conflicts that differed in striking ways from the ones we’re witnessing today.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 02/06/2026
"It’s key to know who was precisely where precisely when. The controversy over THE SATANIC VERSES broke out in England just a few days after THE LAST TEMPTATION came out ... Basquiat died of an overdose downtown the same day THE LAST TEMPTATION opened in midtown ..." lithub.com/on-group-por...
lithub.com
On Group Portraiture and the Secret Histories of Art: Paul Elie and Julia Cooke in Conversation
A decade and change ago, Paul Elie taught a class that I found formative. Its focus was first books, and he talked about each assignment in revelatory terms, prodding us graduate students to connec…
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 01/06/2026
"So much has been occluded by the depiction of the 1980s as the awful age of Reagan, yuppies, shoulder pads, mullets, and synth-drums. With THE LAST SUPPER I had the sense that I was writing a secret history." - from an exchange with Julia Cooke on @literaryhub.bsky.social lithub.com/on-group-por...
lithub.com
On Group Portraiture and the Secret Histories of Art: Paul Elie and Julia Cooke in Conversation
A decade and change ago, Paul Elie taught a class that I found formative. Its focus was first books, and he talked about each assignment in revelatory terms, prodding us graduate students to connec…
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 01/06/2026
THE LAST SUPPER is just out from Picador: a svelte, stylish paperback, with a new art insert and a back cover full of accolades -- named a best book of the year by the Washington Post and the Los Angeles Times and an Essential Read by The New Yorker. Thanks to all!
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 05/04/2026
My latest -- a piece for The New Yorker (@newyorker.com) about Leo in wartime: In a Lenten season scarred by brutal wars, notably the U.S. and Israel's wars in Iran & Lebanon, the first American Pope is countering the violence through words and symbolic action newyorker.com/news/the-led...
newyorker.com
How Will the First American Pope Handle War?
Last week, when asked if he had a message about the war in Iran for President Trump, Pope Leo XIV said, “Hopefully, he’s looking for an off-ramp.”
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 24/03/2026
"I’ve been struck by the pertinence of nonfiction books that don’t deal directly with current affairs. These books speak to the moment precisely because they don’t succumb to the presentism, partisanship, and winners-and-losers schemas of the media today." newrepublic.com/article/2076...
newrepublic.com
Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever
Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction, and our understanding of the world around us.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 23/03/2026
My latest: an essay in The New Republic (@newrepublic.com) about our society's urgent and enduring need for narrative nonfiction, a.k.a. literary nonfiction or long fact -- nonfiction that’s based on reportage more than on personal experience or celebrity newrepublic.com/article/2076...
newrepublic.com
Nonfiction Publishing, Under Threat, Is More Important Than Ever
Cuts in publishing and book reviewing imperil the future of narrative nonfiction, and our understanding of the world around us.
041
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 06/02/2026
My latest: a short piece for The New Yorker (@newyorker.com) about the new archbishop of New York, Ronald Hicks, what his appointment tells us about Pope Leo -- and what it suggests about the Church's challenge to the Trump administration www.newyorker.com/news/the-led...
newyorker.com
The New Archbishop of New York Rounds Out the Pope’s Team U.S.A.
Pope Leo has appointed Ronald Hicks, a seemingly like-minded cleric, as the Archbishop of New York—historically, the most prominent post in the U.S. Church.
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 10/01/2026
Test-of-concept-like, I read my Profile of Pope Leo in the print edition of The New Yorker (@newyorker.com) over coffee this morning. A dream assignment: to spend part of a year interviewing, thinking, writing, & revising---making work that can be read this way www.newyorker.com/magazine/202...
newyorker.com
The Making of the First American Pope
Will Pope Leo XIV follow the progressive example of his predecessor or chart a more moderate course? His work in Chicago and Peru may shed light on his approach.
010
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 06/01/2026
My latest: in @newyorker.com.bsky.social, a Profile of Robert Prevost / Pope Leo XIV www.newyorker.com/magazine/202...
newyorker.com
The Making of the First American Pope
Will Pope Leo XIV follow the progressive example of his predecessor or chart a more moderate course? His work in Chicago and Peru may shed light on his approach.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 08/12/2025
The Los Angeles Times (@latimes.com) has named THE LAST SUPPER one of its 15 best books of 2025 -- really satisfying to be lauded in such a select group, alongside McEwan, Pynchon, Choi, and Kitamura . . . www.latimes.com/entertainmen...
latimes.com
The 15 Best Books of 2025
Why our top picks of the year were about serial killers, silence and the enduring grace of the written word, according to The Times' reviewers.
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 15/10/2025
A next NYC event for THE LAST SUPPER: a reading and conversation next Tuesday, 10/21, at KGB Bar, 85 East 4th Street, 7:30 p.m., hosted by Commonweal (@commonweal.bskysocial). Come and raise a glass to the crypto-religious in this spirit-haunted house! www.commonwealmagazine.org/crypto-relig...
commonwealmagazine.org
Crypto-Religion & The City
It's often remarked that America has become less religious. But what if that religiosity hasn't disappeared, but just taken less visible forms?
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 03/10/2025
My latest: a personal essay, in Notre Dame Magazine, about the Roman sojourns of James Joyce and my grand-uncle, Bishop Robert F. Joyce, and the ways they intersect with each other's and my own magazine.nd.edu/stories/amon...
magazine.nd.edu
Among the Modernists in Rome | Notre Dame Magazine | University of Notre Dame
Tracing the overlapping paths of two Joyces — artist and cleric, skeptic and believer — who negotiated a new world in the Eternal City
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 23/08/2025
Looking forward to discussing THE LAST SUPPER with the first-class novelist Phil Klay (@philklay.bsky.social) at Fairfield University on Monday, November 17 -- an event in the university's really aptly named Inspired Writers series . . . events.fairfield.edu/event/paul-e...
events.fairfield.edu
Paul Elie's The Last Supper: Art, Faith, Sex and Controversy in the 1980s
031
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 21/08/2025
Thrilled that THE LAST SUPPER is now out as an audiobook from Tantor Media, available on Apple, Audible, and other platforms -- and with a fresh cover featuring Bono, circa mid-eighties, in characteristic cruciform mode books.apple.com/us/audiobook...
books.apple.com
‎The Last Supper : Art, Faith, Sex, and Controversy in the 1980's
‎History · 2025
010
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 15/08/2025
Neat to see THE LAST SUPPER in among F. Scott Fitzgerald, Iris Murdoch, James Schuyler, Mary Gaitskill, Jamaica Kincaid, and Drake on Arts & Letters Daily, via Gerald Howard's n+1 review essay www.aldaily.com
aldaily.com
Arts & Letters Daily
Philosophy, literature, ideas, criticism, history, art, music from The Chronicle of Higher Education.
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 09/08/2025
Just posted: the video of a LAST SUPPER event at the American Writers Museum (@awmuseum.bsky.social) in Chicago -- really as stimulating a public conversation about my written work as any I can recall. I'm truly grateful for the care taken there www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0VD...
youtube.com
A conversation with Paul Elie, author of "The Last Supper"
YouTube video by American Writers Museum
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 07/08/2025
THE LAST SUPPER in Smoky Mountain News: "A deep dive into the music and arts scene of the 1970s and 80s ...You’ll be transported back to that time, that music, those artists and authors and their more transcendental aspects in a kind of illuminating déja vu." smokymountainnews.com/arts/item/40...
smokymountainnews.com
Diving into the spirit of ’70s and ’80s music
For all of you ’70s and ’80s hipsters, I’ve got one for you. In his new book, acclaimed author Paul Elie (“The Last Supper: Art, Faith, Sex and Controversy in the 1980s,” Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 20...
040
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 29/07/2025
This "journey among the believers & those who were trying, in their imperfect & individual ways, to accommodate and harness symbols of belief towards artistic ends, left this one-time believer engaged & troubled & in fresh perplexity in the best possible way." www.nplusonemag.com/online-only/...
nplusonemag.com
Among the Blasphemers | Gerald Howard
For at least a year, the mail room in Penguin’s New York headquarters utilized a bomb-sniffing dog—named, for some unknown reason, Yalta—to screen packages. On one especially unnerving Saturday the fe...
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 27/07/2025
"THE LAST SUPPER really hits its stride & strikes thematic gold in its climactic crypto-religious coverage of two of the central agons of the decade: the AIDS crisis & the publication of THE SATANIC VERSES & the resulting fatwa against Salman Rushdie." www.nplusonemag.com/online-only/...
nplusonemag.com
Among the Blasphemers | Gerald Howard
For at least a year, the mail room in Penguin’s New York headquarters utilized a bomb-sniffing dog—named, for some unknown reason, Yalta—to screen packages. On one especially unnerving Saturday the fe...
001
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 26/07/2025
"As a critic and historian Elie has clarity, depth, and range—qualities that serve him well as he navigates the stormy and turbid high/low waters of his chosen decade’s cultural output" -- from Gerald Howard's review of THE LAST SUPPER in @nplusonemag.com www.nplusonemag.com/online-only/...
nplusonemag.com
Among the Blasphemers | Gerald Howard
For at least a year, the mail room in Penguin’s New York headquarters utilized a bomb-sniffing dog—named, for some unknown reason, Yalta—to screen packages. On one especially unnerving Saturday the fe...
021
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 25/07/2025
"Accomplishes something remarkable and necessary: <it> foregrounds the extraordinary & ineffable in the popular arts, demonstrating how the 'religious point of view' is deeply entwined with the artistic desires to make sense of the world, or subvert it." www.washingtonexaminer.com/premium/3477...
washingtonexaminer.com
The God that Failed Up: Review of ‘The Last Supper’ by Paul Elie - Washington Examiner
The real thesis of the book is an argument that everyone who approaches the past or the present of art without looking to religion is simply mistaken.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 23/07/2025
Randy Boyagoda in @FinancialTimes.com: THE LAST SUPPER "challenges reductive perceptions of religion’s place in contemporary American life — as either all-powerful ... or altogether absent ... — while revealing the 1980s as the decade when these perceptions set in place." www.ft.com/content/21f8...
ft.com
The Last Supper — how religion shaped pop culture in the 1980s
From Madonna to Martin Scorsese, Paul Elie makes the case for spirituality’s influence on American musicians, writers and artists in the decade of materialism
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 21/07/2025
“If prominent Catholic leaders had taken a pastoral approach akin to the one Francis took a third of a century later, the situation of Catholicism in our society would be very different today.” My interview with OutReach's @MikeOLoughlin.bsky.social on THE LAST SUPPER outreach.faith/2025/07/inte...
outreach.faith
Interview: “The Last Supper” includes struggles of gay Catholics in 1980s New York - Outreach
Michael O'Loughlin interviews Paul Elie, author of "The Last Supper," exploring the stories of struggle for gay Catholics in 1980s New York.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 17/07/2025
Up and out (all this week, it happens): a conversation about THE LAST SUPPER --and its New Orleans episodes, especially -- with the great Susan Larson, for @wwno.org's The Reading Life: www.wwno.org/podcast/the-...
wwno.org
The Reading Life: Paul Elie
010
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 07/07/2025
From @thbevilacqua.bsky.social: "With THE LAST SUPPER, Paul Elie has cemented his place as one of the preeminent examiners & historians of art & religion in the modern world & has shown how the latter half of this century is robust with voices speaking to the lived experience of believers . . ."
010
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 06/07/2025
THE LAST SUPPER, reviewed by Rebecca Bratten Weiss in the National Catholic Reporter (@ncronline.bsky.social): "Elie's exploration of the struggle between art and faith in the 1980s offers valuable insights for anyone seeking clarity on faith in public life today" www.ncronline.org/culture/book....
sky.social
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 28/06/2025
On the Dishcast, Andrew Sullivan and I talk about THE LAST SUPPER & crypto-religious art, carrying forward a 3-decade exchange--this time from "... Sinead O'Connor’s refusal to get an abortion" to my "gobsmacking omission of the Pet Shop Boys" andrewsullivan.substack.com/p/paul-elie-...
andrewsullivan.substack.com
Paul Elie On Crypto-Religion In Pop Culture
His book explores the religious roots of some of the biggest artists of the 1980s. Listen now on the Dishcast.
010
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 25/06/2025
Now posted: a full episode of The Russell Moore Show devoted to THE LAST SUPPER - and to THE LIFE YOU SAVE MAY BE YOUR OWN, which Moore (@drmoore.bsky.social) says he has read three or four times . . . www.christianitytoday.com/podcasts/the...
christianitytoday.com
Paul Elie on Culture Wars in Music and Art - Christianity Today
What do Andy Warhol, Leonard Cohen, Bob Dylan, Flannery O’Connor, and Bono all have in common? According to writer and cultural historian Paul Elie,
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 20/06/2025
'Elie’s book seeks to demonstrate just how consistently slanted toward the “crypto-religious” and mystic the American public imaginary has been, even throughout “secular” postmodernity, even by the most rebellious of its rebels for artistic causes.' www.americamagazine.org/arts-culture...
americamagazine.org
Review: The Catholic fragments of art, faith and sex in 1980s pop culture
Paul Eli'e's 'The Last Supper: Art, Faith, Sex and Controversy' investigates pop culture’s crypto-religious, uncanny symbols of immanence and transcendence.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 16/06/2025
In @newyorker.com: THE LAST SUPPER "parses not just art works but the uproar that they incited. Conflicts over 'authority and individual conscience' ... didn’t fade with the decade; they helped set the terms of the culture wars that continue into the present." www.newyorker.com/magazine/202...
newyorker.com
Briefly Noted Book Reviews
Short reviews of recent releases.
020
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 11/06/2025
"Elie makes the point that the 1980s culture wars help explain wherever it is that we are today ... In our time of oversimplicity, he reminds us that tearing up a photo of the pope on TV...can have multiple complicated, enigmatic meanings." www.washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com/bookreview/t...
washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com
The Last Supper: Art, Faith, Sex, and Controversy in the 1980s | Washington Independent Review of Books
The Independent is an important voice in the community of readers and writers dedicated to book reviews and writing about the world of books.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 10/06/2025
"Where the clerics couldn't speak, the artists stepped in." A conversation with the grandmaster interviewer Chris Lydon for Open Source (@radioopensource.bsky.social) is up now -- an afternoon well spent at his home library and studio in Boston radioopensource.org/the-last-sup...
radioopensource.org
The Last Supper
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 09/06/2025
In Rome today I'll have the privilege of leading the keynote conversation in this spring's Georgetown Global Dialogues -- with Cardinal Tolentino, head of the Vatican's Dicastery for Culture and Education globaldialogues.georgetown.edu/events/liter...
globaldialogues.georgetown.edu
Literature, Social Friendship, and the Culture of Encounter
How do Pope Francis's call to a "culture of encounter" in "Fratelli Tutti" and his recurring emphasis on literature as a means of encounter point to/open up ways forward in a divided world?
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 08/06/2025
An invigorating conversation about THE LAST SUPPER and "crypto-religiosity" with old-and-new-friend Dominic Preziosi on the @commonweal.bsky.social podcast . . . www.commonwealmagazine.org/podcast/cryp...
commonwealmagazine.org
Crypto-Religiosity
What if American religiosity hasn’t disappeared, but just taken less visible forms?
021
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 01/06/2025
Unerringly thoughtful . . . This is an essential read for those interested in how art can take a stand when spirituality takes the form of a repressive ideology." That's Douglas C. MacLeod, in The Arts Fuse (#ARTSFuse), on THE LAST SUPPER artsfuse.org/310999/june-...
artsfuse.org
June Short Fuses — Materia Critica - The Arts Fuse
Each month, our arts critics — music, book, theater, dance, television, film, and visual arts — fire off a few brief reviews.
010
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 30/05/2025
"Elie’s third book is also his most personal: the period under review is one he lived through. The book revisits the 1980s—not as a decade of political conservatism, but as a rich period of spiritual and artistic questioning."--from Nora Futtner's profile berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/visual_stori...
berkleycenter.georgetown.edu
Faith, Culture, and the Search for Meaning
For more than three decades, Paul Elie has been charting the often-overlooked topographies where faith, culture, and the arts converge. His latest book, "The Last Supper: Art, Faith, Sex, and Controve...
011
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 29/05/2025
Up too is podcast conversation about THE LAST SUPPER on @literaryhub.bsky.social: we go into why my generation of Catholics aren't "lapsed" so much as "crypto- religious." lithub.com/paul-elie-on... . . .
lithub.com
Paul Elie on Art, Faith, and Sex in 1980s America—and the New Pope
Nonfiction writer Paul Elie joins co-hosts Whitney Terrell and V.V. Ganeshananthan to discuss his new book The Last Supper: Art, Faith, Sex, and Controversy in the 1980s and Pope Leo XIV. Elie comp…
073
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 29/05/2025
The @washingtonpost.com review of THE LAST SUPPER, by Mark Athitakis, is up: "Elie's book feels delightfully comprehensive, shifting from big exemplars of his themes to small representatives of crypto-religiosity": the Pogues, Seamus Heaney, Lucille Clifton ... washingtonpost.com/books/2025/0...
washingtonpost.com
Review | Want to understand today’s culture wars? Look to the 1980s.
In “The Last Supper,” Paul Elie explores how controversies over artists like Sinéad O’Connor and Keith Haring paved the way for today’s political and cultural rifts.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 06/05/2025
My latest: a brief reflection, for @vanityfair.com, on a remarkable photograph Fr. James Martin (@jamesmartinsj) took in Rome last October. It's an image of the Catholic future that Pope Francis brought near -- and that the next pope ought to carry forward www.vanityfair.com/news/story/a...
vanityfair.com
On the Eve of the Conclave, a Peek Inside the Pope’s Last Grand Gathering
A cell phone tableau of inclusion and splendor from last year’s synod contrasts the Francis pontificate with this week’s secret meetings to choose his successor.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 27/04/2025
My latest, for @newyorker.com: a personal (& semi-polemical) postcard from Rome, where I was ideally situated on a day for the ages: the day of the funeral for Pope Francis www.newyorker.com/newsletter/t...
newyorker.com
Catholic Tradition Remains at Pope Francis’s Funeral
From the daily newsletter: a dispatch from Vatican City, where the Pope was laid to rest today.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 21/04/2025
In this respect, yesterday's encounter in Rome was telling. The anti-strongman (Francis) -- being an anti-strongman --met graciously with the would-be strongman's henchman (Vance), who had arrived at the Vatican in a neo-imperial thirty-vehicle motorcade out of a circa 1940 newsreel
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 21/04/2025
R.I.P. Jorge Mario Bergoglio -- Pope Francis - 1936-2025. My Postscript essay, for The New Yorker, is below
040
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 18/04/2025
My latest, for @newyorker.com: With Pope Francis diminished by illness and advancing age and the U.S. bishops timid in their response to the Trump administration's abrupt funding cuts, there's concern for the Church's witness against a vengeful and capricious chief executive . . .
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 18/04/2025
My latest, for @newyorker.com: With Pope Francis diminished by illness and the U.S. bishops timid in their response to the Trump administration's abrupt funding cuts, there's concern for the Church's witness against a vengeful and capricious chief executive www.newyorker.com/news/the-led...
newyorker.com
This Easter, with the Pope Ailing, Will the Catholic Church Stand Up to Trump?
Pope Francis has long advocated for immigrants, refugees, and the vulnerable—but the Church, like other institutions, may need to find new ways to sustain its commitments.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 13/03/2025
"An in-depth exploration of a turbulent time in American culture that seemed obsessed with secular freedom...but in fact was shot through with noncanonical religious fervor.” THE LAST SUPPER (@fsgbooks.bsky.social) is out in May. Interview in @PublishersWkly: www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/...
publishersweekly.com
Birth of the Culture Wars: PW Talks with Paul Elie
The author’s latest book examines the tension between religious and political conservatives and secular popular artists and entertainers in the 1980s.
000
paulelie.bsky.social @paulelie.bsky.social · 13/03/2025
Really pleased to welcome New York Times columnist (and Pulitzer Prize awardee) Carlos Lozada to Old North today -- looking forward to our in-class discussion of THE WASHINGTON BOOK and our public conversation. The latter will begin at 4:30. events.georgetown.edu/humanities/e...
events.georgetown.edu
The Washington Book: A Conversation with New York Times Columnist Carlos Lozada
Carlos Lozada is a columnist for The New York Times, based in Washington. He was awarded a Pulitzer Prize for criticism in 2019, while with The Was...
000