Sign in

monicatranel.bsky.social

@monicatranel.bsky.social
1.1K followers 18 following 277 posts

Montanan

PostsRepliesMedia
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 01/10/2026
The best of America: Choosing to replace decay with connection, and the future. In Big Timber, Jami introduced me to community members working on Sheepherder Square and said, “They are the real story. They are the people who show up and get things done.” monicatranel.substack.com/p/force-for-...
monicatranel.substack.com
Force for Good
Sheepherder Square, Big Timber, Montana
011
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 28/09/2026
America is in a hard place. But that doesn’t mean it’s a bad place. Anaconda can teach us a lot about finding what matters, while knowing that the waste product is part of the process. monicatranel.substack.com/p/anaconda-a...
monicatranel.substack.com
Anaconda and the Jesuit Volunteer Corps
My friend Jack grew up in Anaconda, Montana.
012
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 24/09/2026
Monopoly public utilities are “competing” for hyperscale loads. Data centers, Meta, Amazon, Microsoft could go anywhere. East Texas. Mars. But public utilities want more than their “fair share” of AI loads, and have the captive ratepayers backstop the risk. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
IAEA for AI
In 1961, construction of the first Minuteman facilities began in Great Falls, Montana, putting Montana in the center of the nuclear weapons arms race.
022
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 21/09/2026
Wildlife is a public good. Montanans from Darby to Wibaux have the same claim on an elk. We have the same access to streams. But “big money” is working Montana’s hunting programs to lock down nonresident elk tags and to lock us off public lands. monicatranel.substack.com/p/elk-and-th...
monicatranel.substack.com
Elk and the equinox
It’s that time of year.
041
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 17/09/2026
Embedding a hyperscale data center within a regulated public utility forces captive ratepayers, people on fixed incomes, to guarantee risk for trillion dollar corporations. That makes no sense for anyone other than the data centers. monicatranel.substack.com/p/two-kinds-...
monicatranel.substack.com
Two kinds of dumb
It’s time for Montana to take a page out of the Hoosier state’s regulatory play book to deal with the kind of dumb that’s in our living room right now:
011
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 14/09/2026
In the Black Hills NorthWestern deal, Montana goes from 90% of the corporaye entity to a second tier subsidiary of an eight state conglomerate. Questions have to be asked now, while Montana regulators can reach the parent company. monicatranel.substack.com/p/public-uti...
monicatranel.substack.com
Public utilities are supposed to be boring
In August, thousands of people in northern Indiana went without power for days.
032
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 10/09/2026
Last week’s APR ruling gives us a chance to walk back from political entrenchments that don’t serve us. A long-time friend (with whom I disagree about politics) texted me: I am grateful for the ruling in favor of APR today. We both want the prairie. monicatranel.substack.com/p/the-bison-...
monicatranel.substack.com
The Bison connection
Last Friday I got a text from a long-time friend (with whom I disagree almost completely about politics):
000
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 07/09/2026
Labor Day in Montana is remembering that Montana’s middle class was carved out of the rock by people who may not have spoken the same language, but refused to stand alone. monicatranel.substack.com/p/montana-is...
monicatranel.substack.com
Montana is an island for labor
Democracy and capitalism wrestle constantly with the tension between labor and capital.
095
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 03/09/2026
Tariffs are not being imposed to help the people of Montana, or the people whose families live on both sides of The Medicine Line. These are choices. We can make different ones. Thank you Hannah for your work and the story in the Washington Post. monicatranel.substack.com/p/the-medici...
monicatranel.substack.com
The Medicine Line
This week Hannah Natanson’s story about how the tariffs have impacted Blackfoot tribal members was published.
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 31/08/2026
Labor wants construction jobs and our communities want a vital tax bases. Those are real asks. But let’s not hand our resources to out-of-state corporations that don’t want to deal with environmental and rate-payer protections. We know how that movie ends. monicatranel.substack.com/p/granite-bu...
monicatranel.substack.com
Granite Built a Town, what does Broadview get?
What Montana learned about data centers in 1893
000
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 27/08/2026
Tariffs on our northern border, mines in the headwaters of our rivers on the southern border. In the 1930s, the arguments were solid. The market moved. The hole in the ground stayed. monicatranel.substack.com/p/braiding-s...
monicatranel.substack.com
Braiding Sweet Grass and Sheep Creek
What hockey sticks and the Sheep Creek mine have in common
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 24/08/2026
Fifty years after A River Runs Through it came out, we are facing warmer, smaller rivers. That is the result of choices we’ve made as a country and a state. Whether our rivers keep running through the next fifty years depends on what we do next. monicatranel.substack.com/p/a-river-ru...
monicatranel.substack.com
A River Runs Dry
Rowing across rivers and lakes brought to mind Norman Maclean’s story A River Runs Through it: “Eventually, all things merge into one, and a river runs through it.”
081
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 20/08/2026
1910 taught us that we know how to fund the Forest Service and will do so generously after we watch people die. 1988 taught us that our policies and the land don’t always line up. This August 20 we are seeing that the landscape doesn’t lie. monicatranel.substack.com/p/august-20-...
monicatranel.substack.com
August 20, a third time
1910, 1988 and 2026
030
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 17/08/2026
Right now, the utilities need something from the Commission. Approval is required for the deal to close. This is the moment when the PSC can impose conditions on the parent holding company. That power lasts until the deal closes. It won’t exist after that. monicatranel.substack.com/p/hollywood-...
monicatranel.substack.com
Hollywood and Montana mergers
Paramount’s attempt to buy Warner is now set for trial in March of 2027.
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 13/08/2026
The history of the Irish in Montana asks us hard questions. Who are the immigrants? Who is inside? Who is out? Who runs the Company? For what end? Who profits, and who loses? monicatranel.substack.com/p/both-ends-...
monicatranel.substack.com
Both Ends of the Rope
Frank Little and the Irish in Butte, America
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 10/08/2026
Steve believed in succession of public service the way the Irish believe in succession of story. Each generation receives something from the one before and is obligated to pass it forward. He received that from mentors like Mike Mansfield and Pat Williams. monicatranel.substack.com/p/my-friend-...
monicatranel.substack.com
Steve Doherty, passing the baton
Out in Circle hunting, and in the hearing room when it mattered
010
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 06/08/2026
The challenge of who can own what, and how much, and how the public interest is aligned with private gain, has always been the challenge for democracy and capitalism. Democracy is the force that has, on balance, curtailed the worst of capitalism. monicatranel.substack.com/p/the-landsc...
monicatranel.substack.com
The landscape gives us what money can't buy.
Theodore Roosevelt came to the West to find something that money can’t buy.
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 03/08/2026
Like the mining magnates of the early 20th century, modern tech infrastructure wants to shift the risk and the financial burden of expansion directly onto families. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Sunlight as a Structural Guarantee: What Montana knew in 1972 that will help us now
In the American West, government transparency isn’t just good ethics.
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 30/07/2026
Who pays for what is not a fight between the city mouse and the country mouse. The problem is the fat cat that flies in on a corporate jet, lands at a private landing pad, bringing in their personal chef for a gourmet meal from ingredients that not grown in Montana. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Seeley Lake Secession
Stop Fighting Over Scraps: The Real Villain in Montana’s Tax Crisis
032
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 27/07/2026
We get to know where our food comes from. We get to know where it went. That does not disappear just because a corporation used its safe words “trade secret” and nobody made them prove it. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Our Health Is Subordinate to Corporate Profits
Corporations don’t want to tell us who is selling, or where they sell, poop in our food.
022
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 23/07/2026
Using executive branch power to claim public lands for the current political in-group reflects a larger constitutional shift, echoing the 1800s when cattle barons used newly-invented barbed wire to illegally fence off public lands for private, industrial monopolies open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
The Bison Wars of 2026 echo 1876
American Prairie is a Bozeman-based conservation nonprofit that has spent more than two decades assembling roughly 500,000+ acres of deeded and leased land in north-central Montana, with the goal of r...
010
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 20/07/2026
Nights aren’t cooling off the way they used to during heat events. My mom’s rule, open at dark, close by 10, was never about the clock. It was about trusting that the temperature would do its job while we slept. This summer it isn’t. Time to listen. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Because the Night got too hot
The End of the Montana Window Routine
001
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 16/07/2026
As the Supreme Court strips independence from federal agencies, and a Montana governor suspends elected officials, this from 1903: Unchecked corporate power leaves us "dwelling in corporate houses, paying corporate tariffs, and being buried in corporate coffins.” open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Corporate coffins filled with elected officials?
Ten states elect their utility regulators. The other forty have them appointed, almost all by the governor. Montana is one of the ten.
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 13/07/2026
The real question isn’t how we get back to some imagined harmony. It’s whether we can continue showing ourselves to be honest, brave, truthful, and intelligent, without deciding everyone else is a threat. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
The Man in the White Truck
Last week on our road trip to the Teddy Roosevelt Library, we stopped in Glendive for gas.
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 10/07/2026
People in Wibaux don’t get to vote on where CenturyLink’s capital goes. That is the point of utility regulation. The regulator stands for people who have no option. The Public Service Commission can decide whether it will protect Montanans from the Black Hills acquisition of NorthWestern.
open.substack.com
Wibaux County Knows How This Ends
Growing up in eastern Montana, we had party lines.
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 06/07/2026
On the Sheep Creek mine in the Bitterrot public comment was promised. It is legally required. It has not been opened up. Email Dan Pliley, West Fork District Ranger at Daniel.Pliley@usda.gov and ask the status and when this project will be open for public comment. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Sheep Creek Mine: what is happening behind closed doors?
The proposed Sheep Creek rare-earth mine at the headwaters of the Bitterroot River has been advancing with little public visibility.
041
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 02/07/2026
The early 1900s was a time of unrest, tremendous wealth disparity, and media mistrust. Good people tackled overwhelming problems in troubled times. In meeting today’s challenges, let’s understand and learn from the complicated figures of our history. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Thomas Walsh and the Sedition Act of 1918
Thomas Walsh, a Helena lawyer, was elected to the U.S.
000
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 29/06/2026
As we mark the 250th anniversary of America’s declaration of independence from tyrants, Meagher is a powerful reminder of what one voice can do. Every voice counts. One person can make real change. No quiet piggy for Thomas Francis Meagher. And none for us. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
No Quiet Piggy for Thomas Francis Meagher
Montana’s territorial governor Thomas Francis Meagher refused to be silenced.
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 25/06/2026
Capital might not be finite for Wall Street pirates. But it is finite for the people of Montana. It is time for the PSC to enforce the regulatory compact, investigate the costs of this data center pipeline, and reject the Black Hills acquisition of NorthWestern. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Broadview Pirates
Montana’s monopoly utilities are telling regulators one story and Wall Street another. American families pay for the difference.
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 22/06/2026
The Spirit of 1776 wasn’t just about celebrating our country’s revolution. It was about the nerve it takes to start over. For us in the west, that has to include hard questions. What did it mean to go west? What do we carry forward, what do we need to set down? open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Spirit of 1776
The summer of 1976 was a great time to be an American kid.
010
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 18/06/2026
We the People. Again. The Montana Plan’s theory is untested at the federal level. Nobody knows how the current Supreme Court will rule. But we know the first step to change is to win the vote. And we know the only way to win the vote is to be on the ballot. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
We the People. Again.
The county deadline for Initiative 194 signatures is tomorrow, June 19.
030
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 18/06/2026
The Montana Plan’s theory is untested at the federal level. Nobody knows how the current Supreme Court will rule. But the only way to win the vote is to be on the ballot. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
We the People. Again.
The county deadline for Initiative 194 signatures is tomorrow, June 19.
010
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 15/06/2026
The Montana Plan is a direct challenge to the corporate “rights” movement, going back to John Marshall’s 1819 description of corporations as creatures of state law. They have the powers their charters confer. No more, no less. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
We the Corporations? No.
Anyone ever sign a contract that says it will be governed by Delaware law?
317254
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 11/06/2026
The dispute over Crazy Mountain’s water is not over. The question is simple: does the process belong to the public, or can it be bought? We still get a vote on that. If the Boston Boys want to hear from the community, they know where to find us. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Crazy Mountain Water: The Pressure is On
Crazy Mountain Ranch and CrossHarbor told 150 people to put down their phones. Then they called a crisis firm.
011
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 08/06/2026
Unchecked money and power, operating in the dark, was behind the deaths of 168 miners. That same culture of secrecy surrounds mines in the Bitterroot and Blackfoot rivers and a data center in Broadview. We have a right to know what is being done. Let’s use it. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
No Kings, copper or crypto
On June 8, 1917, a frayed electrical cable ignited an oil-soaked cloth in the deep mines in Butte, starting the Granite Mountain and Speculator mine fires.
000
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 04/06/2026
Thank you to the people of MT HD 92 for entrusting me to represent you. And thank you to everyone along the way, all of you who do this work because you believe that what matters most is what we cannot put a price on, and it’s worth fighting to protect. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
What We Cannot Measure
This week Montana held its primary election, and this week we also mark the anniversary of Robert Kennedy’s own fateful primary victory, and his death.
060
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 01/06/2026
In a sixth consecutive drought year, on an over-allocated river system, should management of the water insulate private users from the oversight the system was designed to provide? Show up at the hearing. Let the court know that the community is watching. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Crazy Mountain Water: The heat is on
CrossHarbor Capital’s Crazy Mountain Ranch wants to take water management out of a Montana water commissioner’s hands.
021
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 28/05/2026
Phil Aalberg said “On a clear day, you can see the Rockies a hundred miles away. I try to communicate that sense of distance and loneliness.” He did. Let’s mark his passing by taking his email tag line to heart: Listen. Listen. Listen. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
A tribute to Phil Aaberg
My friend Phil Aaberg passed away this week.
141
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 25/05/2026
“What were four Georgians doing in Helena in the 1860s?” Looking for gold. The Civil War migrated, settling in on people who had lived here for millenia. Montana has been at that intersection of memory and progress since. Place flowers. Ask hard questions. Remember open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Last Chance: Memorial Day in Montana
This Monday, May 25, the Montana Veterans Memorial is hosting its 21st Annual Memorial Day Ceremony.
011
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 21/05/2026
There is a question about what it means for a land-grant university’s power costs to be decided by an eight state corporation that answers to Meta’s server farms in Cheyenne. Black Hills acquisition of NorthWestern does not serve Montana. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Part II: Capital Is Not Finite. Except When the Law Says It Is.
The phrase came from the witness stand at the hearing last week in Helena on Black Hills’ acquisition of NorthWestern. Since the hearing, people have been saying: we know we’re being taken.
000
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 18/05/2026
Capital is not finite for institutional shareholders at Vanguard and BlackRock, the largest shareholders of Black Hills and NorthWestern. But it is for captive ratepayers. Questions about the grid, data centers, and who pays for our energy, demand honest engagement. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Capital Is Not Finite. For Whom?
Last week, the Montana Public Service Commission held its evidentiary hearing on whether to approve Black Hills Corporation’s acquisition of NorthWestern Energy.
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 14/05/2026
If you are in the Great Falls area today, join the discussion at the Great Falls Public Library, May 14, from 6:00–7:00 pm, for an engaging conversation about one of Montana’s greatest achievements: our Constitution open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Montana’s Constitution
In May of 1864, President Lincoln signed the Organic Act that made Montana a territory.
38226
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 11/05/2026
While listening to the hearing this week at the Montana Commission on the proposed NorthWestern and Black Hills merger remember, these things are not new. Follow the money open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Samson and Delilah in Montana
This week, the Montana Public Service Commission will be hearing about NorthWestern’s proposed merger with Black Hills Corporation. This brings to mind the issue of mergers at the U.S. Supreme Court i...
040
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 07/05/2026
In 1874, gold in the Black Hills made treaty promises inconvenient. In 2026, data centers and energy companies are making promises about how they will operate in the Land of the Shining Mountains. We should keep our history in mind when we hear these promises. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
From gold to data centers and the Battle of Little Muddy Creek
In 1868, the second Fort Laramie Treaty was signed.
031
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 04/05/2026
Public education is the single most powerful investment we can make in our communities. Voting yes on our local school levy won’t fix every flaw in how we fund education in this country. But it will keep a teacher in the classroom, and a counselor in the hallway. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
School Mill Levies
On May 5, 2026, voters across the country will decide the fate of school levies for districts in Ohio suburbs, Montana mountain towns, New Mexico ranching communities, and Washington state school dist...
012
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 30/04/2026
The story Grinnell began telling about the bison is not finished. Like Grinnell, we must be vigilant and insistent. We can put the lessons from the late 1800s to use in today’s world, across many landscapes. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
The Last Bison and the BLM
In 1886 the last bison was shot on the Great Plains of central Montana, the place we sometimes call, with affection, the Big Empty.
020
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 27/04/2026
Attorneys General can act as gap fillers, stepping in to sue corporations over privacy violations, deceptive marketing, or environmental harm. But Montana’s AG has gone the opposite direction open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Attorneys General and Ticketmaster
On April 15, 2026 a U.S.
010
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 23/04/2026
The 2026 Forest Service reorganization rejects the lesson of the 1988 fires. The West is entering what may be a historically dangerous fire summer with an intentionally traumatized agency managing 193 million acres of forest and grassland. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Fire and Ignorance
In 1988, fires burned through Yellowstone National Park.
011
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 20/04/2026
The labor movement in Montana isn’t in the rear view mirror, although dark money campaigns are working hard to make it so. Montana’s workers are focused on keeping our history alive. Let’s support them. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
Anaconda Road Massacre
On April 21, 1920, miners in Butte walked off the job demanding fair wages.
010
monicatranel.bsky.social @monicatranel.bsky.social · 16/04/2026
Our land and our libraries are not backdrops. They are the connective tissue that nurture life, and republics. On this July 4, let’s celebrate the land, and our libraries. And our freedom to be changed by what we experience there. open.substack.com/pub/monicatr...
open.substack.com
What the Land Teaches Us
Theodore Roosevelt Presidential Library and the architecture of belonging
051