Sign in

Melinda Robinson (she/they)

@melindarobinson.bsky.social
86 followers 61 following 57 posts

Philosophy MA student at Queen's University. My focus is on phenomenology, feminism, queer rights, neurodiversity and bioethics. Comparative classics is my secret crush.

PostsRepliesMedia
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 11/04/2025
If the person telling you how to be a man and attract women has little to no female audience, it's because they are good at repelling women, not attracting them. Listening to Rogan, Peterson or Tate puts you at an automatic disadvantage because these men teach other men how to be unlikeable.
041
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 19/03/2025
I just finished my backlog of tasks that I've been dreading and putting off. Now I don't know what to do with myself. How am I supposed to motivate any kind of action if I don't have an immanent or overdue task to procrastinate on?
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
If we do not stop this now, our grandchildren will not learn that MAGA was like the Nazis. They will learn about the Nazis by being taught that they were like MAGA.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 18/03/2025
When concentrations camps opened, the term didn't yet mean death camp. The first gulags were sold as corrective labour camps. The US just shipped 238 people to a forced labour camp. There was no process. They were not deported to their country of origin. You never get to pretend you "didn't know."
050
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 11/03/2025
An IPV survivor's perspective on Trump's "51st state" threats. #canada #trumptariffs #canadastrong #elbowsup #WeTheNorth #trump #never51 #tradewar
open.substack.com
Trump is Already Making War on America's Allies
Threats are not just "words," they are a form of violence
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 07/03/2025
You may be familiar with C. S. Lewis' argument that Jesus can't be a "great moral teacher," because he says he is Lord, so either he is, or he's a liar or a lunatic. This argument assumes that you can't be a great moral teacher and also mentally ill. Mental illness ≠ moral deficiency.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 21/02/2025
People talk a lot about mental health in the trans community: such high rates of mental health problems must mean that these people are crazy, that they're sick. They need to be fixed.
When I took my child to the doctor to talk about gender affirming care, he asked about anxiety. "What's that?" my daughter said. She wasn't serious -- she knows what anxiety is -- but it's not a routine feeling. Being trans, for her, has not meant growing up being told that she can't wear the clothes she feels comfortable in, that she can't use the name that sounds like hers, that she has to fit herself in a gendered box and play a social role that she can never play well enough because it isn't true.
She hasn't had to worry that she would be rejected by her family for being herself. She hasn't been told that there is something wrong with her, that God will be disappointed unless she learns to perform masculinity. She hasn't kept this secret for years, or decades. She hasn't faced the trauma of actually being rejected by the people who were supposed to love her unconditionally. 
She hasn't been told over and over that she doesn't know who she is, that her instincts and her deepest feelings are wrong.
My older kids didn't have this advantage, and I will regret that for as long as I live. I enabled a father, and a church, that insisted on harmful gender roles. I know this has taken a toll on their mental health, and I will always bear responsibility for that.
But my younger daughter is growing up with the freedom to define herself. And it means she is not growing up with the anxiety, and the secrecy, and the fear. 
Trans people are not mentally ill because they're trans. They're mentally ill because we traumatize them and claim that we're doing it for their own good. That the naked hatred and abhorrence which so-called "Christians" display towards them is "love." And then we use the harm that we've inflicted as an evidence that they were broken from the start.
030
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 12/02/2025
Why give a man a fish, when you can self-importantly assume that the problem is that he doesn't know how to fish, and then ignore him when he says "My people do live here. We know how to fucking fish. The problem is that you've poisoned the river and made it illegal to fish in it."
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 09/02/2025
Do analytic philosophers intend their thought experiments to be funny? Like, are they knowingly joking and part of the humour is keeping a straight face? Or are they like "This is a perfectly sober and serious idea which I am expressing in a very serious way ... wait, why are laughing?"
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 08/02/2025
They believe aid work is a "scam" and NGOs are only concerned about their bottom line b/c that's how their charitable contributions work. They don't experience empathy & can't imagine it as a motive. This is why teaching cognitive empathy matters. Not everyone feels empathy. But it can be learned.
061
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 07/02/2025
The success of MAGA depends on people who know, instinctively, that something is wrong — and who also know, instinctively, that many of the people they love and depend on are not safe. If they name this truth, accept it, their whole world will fall apart. And there will be nowhere safe to go.
open.substack.com
It Takes Time
Safe spaces, ideological traps, and why people don't see Trump for what he is
000
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 04/02/2025
Some people have realized that they were conned and they voted for fascism. They are hurt and angry. Be kind to these people: life will give them consequences, we need to help them move past shock into fighting to undo what they did. The people who deserve anger are the ones still making excuses.
1112
Reposted by Melinda Robinson (she/they)
Mandi Rose @mandipom.bsky.social · 02/02/2025
"People who voted for Trump are evil people. They saw what was happening and they had the chance..." I get the thought. I truly do. And if that thought motivates you to create healthy boundaries and cut out toxic people, then you know what, you do you. But, here's where I think it's dangerous:
221
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 31/01/2025
Trump's most recent displays of raging sociopathic narcissism are not caused by "dementia." He has always been this way. Please do not use dementia as an insult and a slur. People with dementia are worthy of respect, compassion and inclusion. Trump's behaviour is typical of #Trump, not #dementia.
040
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 17/01/2025
Performative guilt is always actually a demand for forgiveness, for the absolution of debts. Self-punishment is an attempt to coerce forgiveness through self harm. Responsibility is the work of figuring out how to make restitution. This is what actually heals relationships.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 17/01/2025
White guilt, then, is the public performance of white pain. It centres the white agent. It construes others as objects of our failure, rather than members of our community who need us to act responsibly. It situates us in a violent past and demands performative atonement, self-inflicted retribution.
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 17/01/2025
Guilt can be a reminder that we have neglected responsibilities. But we can take responsibility without feeling, or being, guilty. To take responsibility is to respond to the present reality of a situation. Guilt is pain over a past that can't change, responsibility is the will to change the future.
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 17/01/2025
The fundamental problem with white guilt is that it reproduces the central assumption of white supremacy: that the white person is a subject, an agent, and all others are objects who are merely acted upon. Thus responsibility = whiteness. This is why POC reject white guilt as useless/harmful.
031
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 14/01/2025
There is a kind of obnoxious person who "works with" or "volunteers with" disabled kids, and who believes that special needs parents should be able to keep up the same level of energy and enthusiasm 24-7 that they have for an hour or two at a stretch. (Pt. 1) #autism #autismparenting #ableism
110
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 11/01/2025
When I went to Italy in HS, we were told to prominently wear Canadian flags. Seemed weird, but locals routinely commented & told nice stories about Canadians. Then one night, a group of American tourists marched by our hotel in Rome at 2am loudly singing the Star Spangled Banner, and all made sense.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 08/01/2025
Did not realize just how mad I was about Trump's threats against Canada until I started talking about something unrelated with a Trump supporter. Threats are still violent even if they are just hot air. You voted for someone who casually makes threats against my country. We are not friends.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 02/01/2025
Talking to my partner, had to more precisely define "YOLO" as "The particular manifestation of humanity that you currently inhabit will realize only a single set of possibilities." I promise we are not fun at parties.
000
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 11/12/2024
The stages of reading philosophy: "This is nonsense. Gibberish. What is he even talking about? Is that supposed to be an argument? Maybe it's the translation? Nope. What was this guy smoking?" (Sleep) (Re-read) "Oh. Yes, Perfectly clear and lucid. Not sure why people struggle with this text."
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 09/12/2024
If you're an undergrad (or are in a position to advise one), I recommend against using Grammarly -- or if you use it, use it sparingly. It will recommend that you flatten your style so that you sound generically "academic." This makes it more difficult to distinguish your writing from AI.
000
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 30/11/2024
The transvestigators are going after another non-white woman athlete. Here's an important paper on why this keeps happening. It's not coincidence, or just unconscious racism. Sex testing is intended to police bodies of women from the global south. #BarbraBanda www.researchgate.net/publication/...
researchgate.net
(PDF) The Powers of Testosterone: Obscuring Race and Regional Bias in the Regulation of Women Athletes
PDF | Using strategies from critical race studies and feminist studies of science, medicine, and the body, we examine the covert operation of race and... | Find, read and cite all the research you nee...
010
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 30/11/2024
You've heard of "emotional labour," but have you heard of "hermeneutic labour?" Okay, so hyper-academic term, but it describes an important aspect of women's work in maintaining intimate relationships with men -- and it helps explain our vulnerability to gaslighting. (Pt. 1) #philosophy #feminism
2123
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 29/11/2024
Aristotle has melted my brain. My head hurts, I feel physically ill. Unfortunately, this means I will probably be a massive fangirl by the end of the month.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 22/11/2024
Are you a "too hot to only inhabit only one gender" enby, or a "too tired to have a gender" enby? #notquitebinary #enby #oldtiredold
370
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 21/11/2024
Trans bathroom laws are about body policing, not women's safety. You can't enforce the rule without examining women's genitals. In practice, the rule targets women (cis or trans) who don't look "feminine" enough. This does not make women safe. #sarahmcbride #transmisogyny #IllGoWithYou #letthempee
070
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 20/11/2024
Giving a lecture tomorrow on Classical Stoicism. If you were a Philosophy undergrad, what would you want to know?
000
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 16/11/2024
One of these days, Audible is going to figure out that I'm not going to download the top new popular bestsellers and will start trying to sell me on sexy new translations of Parmenides. Hasn't happened yet. The algorithms are still hopeful that I'll be interested in developing successful habits.
020
Melinda Robinson (she/they) @melindarobinson.bsky.social · 16/11/2024
Hi all. New platform, same weird human. I'll probably post more political stuff in December when my papers are done. For the moment I'm deeply focused on the role of sung speech in archaic societies and how this relates to the Rig Veda and preSocratic philosophy. Very timely. Super pragmatic.
040