I'm sure someone in the chat has suggested this to you by now, but Grave Seasons might be up your alley. It's basically a farm sim, but whenever you start a new game a random NPC is a serial killer.
store.steampowered.com/app/3255110/...
store.steampowered.com
Grave Seasons on Steam
Grave Seasons is a narrative farming sim with a terrifying twist – someone in the town is a supernatural serial killer. Farm, romance, and investigate your way through the unsettling town of Ashenridg...
