Sign in

David Killoren

@davidkilloren.bsky.social
165 followers 384 following 44 posts

I work on moral and social philosophy and teach at Grand Valley State University. I try to blog every Sunday at eg.typepad.com

PostsRepliesMedia
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 30/09/2025
I seem to have made a Wordpress copy of my old Typepad blog. (I am not checking to make sure that the automated migration was comprehensive, because I would likely be disgusted by the sight of older posts.) I'll restart my Sunday blogging in November, and will make it a ritual thereafter. egegeg.me
egegeg.me
E.G.
"Me! Hear! My foreign ear--the sounds of welcome near!"
020
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 28/08/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/08/t...
eg.typepad.com
Typepad's death.
Long ago, someone gave me a lifetime subscription to Typepad. I used it for a while, and then I stopped for a while, and then I started again. I like the ritual of producing a blog post every Sunday. ...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 24/08/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/08/s...
eg.typepad.com
Sinead O'Connor's appropriation of the Catholic Church and other things.
I'm listening to Ethel Cain's Willoughby Tucker, I'll Always Love You. I am thinking about Ethel Cain's interest, in much of her work, in the uses of Christianity by ordinary people who think of thems...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 18/08/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/08/t...
eg.typepad.com
Theistic moral science vs. realistic moral faith.
Basl and Coons memorably worry about inferential movements from ought to is. Such movements constitute attempts at what they call moral science. There seems to be something fishy about such inferences...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 11/08/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/08/d...
eg.typepad.com
Does wrongness have to be tropic in order to be normatively potent?
According to a view I find appealing, when somebody does something wrong, there are three particulars involved. There's the particular agent who's done the wrong thing; there's the particular action t...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 04/08/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/08/a...
eg.typepad.com
Scattered thoughts on absurdity and the future.
In Mere Christianity, CS Lewis writes: Reality, in fact, is usually something you could not have guessed. That is one of the reasons I believe Christianity. It is a religion you could not have guessed...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 28/07/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/07/b...
eg.typepad.com
Bret Stephens's defense of Israel against the charge of genocide.
Bret Stephens says: [T]here is a glaring dissonance to the charge that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. To wit: If the Israeli government’s intentions and actions are truly genocidal — if it is ...
110
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 21/07/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/07/p...
eg.typepad.com
Occasionalist pictures and perception.
Let's say an Occasionalist picture is any picture where (a) there is some agent S, and (b) there is some object O, and (c) S and O cannot directly interact (S cannot influence O, and O cannot influenc...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 14/07/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/07/v...
eg.typepad.com
Veganism is collective bargaining.
My opinion is that we should be faithful vegans: We should consistently and constantly follow veganism's rules. On an alternative view, we should be economic half-vegans. An economic half-vegan is som...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 07/07/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/07/m...
eg.typepad.com
My Dad's views on money.
My Dad was pretty choosy when it came to ideas. If you wanted to persuade him of anything that he didn't already believe, you'd usually have your work cut out for you. But when he did find an idea he....
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 30/06/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/06/l...
eg.typepad.com
Let's not hope that MAGA incoherence will save us.
Kevin Vallier says that the American right is now a "strange blend" of three things: (1) Techno-optimism, exemplified by Peter Thiel, the billionaire investor and Trumpist, who thinks that "the forces...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 23/06/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/06/g...
eg.typepad.com
Graceful vs. confrontational activism.
Sarah McBride advocates a politics of grace. In a recent conversation with Ezra Klein, she defines grace like this: I think grace in politics means, one, creating room for disagreement: assuming good ...
001
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 16/06/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/06/l...
eg.typepad.com
Let's not hope that beauty will save us.
I think the general type of view that Errol Lord presents in this paper is somewhat widely held, and Lord develops a sophisticated version of the view. For these reasons, the paper is valuable. But I ...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 09/06/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/06/a...
eg.typepad.com
AI friends will make us weird to each other.
Conversation is like dancing. Some conversations are like square dances, some conversations are like mosh pits, and so on. If someone who's used to having mosh-pit conversations is paired up with some...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 02/06/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/05/i...
eg.typepad.com
Inward light and Hare's Paradox: mutually illuminating, maybe.
Inward light is what I take to be the central idea of Quakerism. In its main forms, it has the following four features: It's in you: To find inward light, you're supposed to look inside yourself. This...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 26/05/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/05/t...
eg.typepad.com
The MAGA aesthetic.
Tim Kenyon and Jennifer Saul have observed that Trump often "appear[s] uninterested even in constructing plausible falsehoods." They say he is a "bald-faced bullshitter." A bald-faced bullshitter is o...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 19/05/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/05/d...
eg.typepad.com
The inertness of desert.
Some people say that there is no such thing as desert. They say that bad people do not deserve to suffer, and that good people do not deserve to be rewarded. One way to reach such a view is via...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 12/05/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/05/e...
eg.typepad.com
Flagrant evil.
There are many different views about what the basic stuff of material reality is. Some have said, for instance, that everything either is an atom or is made out of atoms; others have said that, in add...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 05/05/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/05/i...
eg.typepad.com
Intuitional diversity in the philosophy profession.
A few days ago, a somewhat prominent philosopher created a hullabaloo on Facebook by suggesting that hiring people "on the basis of" race or gender is unjustifiable, and is illegal, yet is commonplace...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 27/04/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/04/s...
eg.typepad.com
Second-order stoicism.
Recently, for a little while, many philosophers were toying with stoicism. Happily, the stoicism trend seems to be dying out. Here's The worst form of stoicism: The world around you is completely outs...
100
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 20/04/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/04/v...
eg.typepad.com
Veganism, specifically.
We should not just be in the neighborhood of vegan. For example, we should not be vegetarian. We should not be flexitarian. We should not be reducetarian. We should be vegan, specifically, rather than...
010
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 13/04/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/04/w...
eg.typepad.com
Moral reasons as deontic grounds.
Consider: The Darwall-Dancy definition of moral reasons: A reason to φ is a moral reason to φ =def it is the sort of reason that can, in the right circumstances, give rise to a moral obligation to φ. ...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 06/04/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/04/o...
eg.typepad.com
Our distance from ourselves.
I saw Mickey 17 in the theater the other day, and it made me worry about whether I might be wrong in my belief that we have relationships (relationships of the folk sort) with ourselves. I won't bothe...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 31/03/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/03/d...
eg.typepad.com
Directed obligations in random beneficiary cases.
I'm a fan of the view that All moral obligations are directed: If S1 has a moral obligation to φ, then there is some individual, S2, to whom this obligation to φ is owed. The view runs into problems w...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 23/03/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/03/a...
eg.typepad.com
Anti-reductionism about relationship tokens.
To illustrate the distinction between relationship tokens and relationship types, consider: Huck's friendship with Jim is a different thing than Bert's friendship with Ernie. These two things are dist...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 15/03/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/03/t...
eg.typepad.com
The People's Bribe.
I don't see why the following very simple idea isn't good. The People's Bribe (1) Key decision-makers (KDMs) in the federal government are guaranteed a large income for life. (2) Apart from whatever t...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 09/03/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/03/c...
eg.typepad.com
Let's not accept all moral-conceptual freebies.
A standard (I think) story: Before the chemical composition of water was known, people didn't know, and couldn't know, that water=H2O. But they still had the (or a) concept of water. It's just that th...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 02/03/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/03/t...
eg.typepad.com
A vignette approach to well-being might be enough.
It is widely and, I think, correctly thought that if The desire-satisfaction account of well-being: For any individual S, S's well-being consists in S's desires being satisfied, such that S is made be...
010
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 23/02/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/02/t...
eg.typepad.com
A moment that precludes what it requires.
Compare and contrast: Curtis Yarvin and Elizabeth Anderson. Yarvin's signature idea is that the United States should not be a democracy and should instead be a dictatorship. He thinks the country shou...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 16/02/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/02/t...
eg.typepad.com
The natural.
Here is the idea of naturalness that I like the most: A fact F is natural if and only if either (i) F is brutely natural or (ii) F explains (= substantively contributes to the best explanation of) at ...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 09/02/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/02/t...
eg.typepad.com
The procreation muddle and carnism's persistence.
In America, (a) there are 10 billion livestock animals and about 330 million humans, which is to say that (b) almost all Americans who are alive at this moment (>97% of the population) will soon be br...
011
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 02/02/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/02/i...
eg.typepad.com
Is there a good worry about Marxian alienation?
I've never been particularly thoughtful or knowledgeable about what's called "alienation" in Marxian circles but I've been teaching Philosophy of Work this term and in the course of that I've been rea...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 26/01/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/01/m...
eg.typepad.com
Most undocumented people in the USA are already American citizens, I think.
You can correctly say of an undocumented person that she is not a legal citizen, i.e., isn't considered a citizen by the US government, doesn't have a US passport, isn't allowed to vote, can't run for...
010
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 20/01/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/01/a...
eg.typepad.com
A serviceable but modest substitute for an afterlife.
Consider: The forever view: Each moment of your life is, was, and always will be happening locally, at its particular time and place. This view has long been a comfort to me. It strikes me as a somewh...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 12/01/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/01/n...
eg.typepad.com
Notes on the idea that USA will, could, or should eventually encompass the whole world.
Certain weird statements recently made by Donald Trump have created renewed interest in the scenario where America metastasizes: Each of the world's countries become states of the USA, one by one, unt...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 06/01/2025
eg.typepad.com/eg/2025/01/y...
eg.typepad.com
You are sort of like a parent to yourself.
I'm a fan of the idea that we have moral obligations to ourselves, for two main reasons: Feelings of guilt: I feel guilty when I let myself down, and I feel guilty when I let others down. The feelings...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 30/12/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/12/k...
eg.typepad.com
Keeping a spare religion spare.
According to a view I'm attracted to, we should think there are precisely two realms of reality: the natural world and morality. We can learn about the truths of the natural world with scientific meth...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 23/12/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/12/p...
eg.typepad.com
Parenthood and sex in the fourth dimension.
In Slaughterhouse-Five, Billy Pilgrim is informed by the Tralfamadorians that their flying-saucer crews had identified no fewer than seven sexes on Earth, each essential to reproduction. ... Billy cou...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 15/12/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/12/b...
eg.typepad.com
Blaming regular people for the world's problems.
There are muckety-mucks, and then there are regular people. Muckety-mucks are the ones with a lot of influence, visibility, perceived authority, etc. Brian Thompson, the UnitedHealthcare CEO who was r...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 08/12/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/12/l...
eg.typepad.com
Let's define activism in order to give it its due.
We do not treat all speech equally. We have classes of privileged speakers who enjoy special tolerances, protections, and advantages. That's as it should be. It's good that journalists and only journa...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 01/12/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/12/c...
eg.typepad.com
Case-based activism.
Activists point at cases. Four illustrations: (1) Black Lives Matter activists talk about Trayvon Martin, George Floyd, and a number of other Black people who have been killed in recent years. (2) MAG...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 24/11/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/11/i...
eg.typepad.com
I don't quite know what stances are.
Over time, metaethicists have shifted from Definition 1: Moral realism is the view that moral facts are mind-independent to Definition 2: Moral realism is the view that moral facts are stance-independ...
020
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 17/11/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/11/i...
eg.typepad.com
In praise of Quakerism.
All traditional religions should be abandoned, but if we are going to participate in any traditional religions at all, it seems to me that Quakerism is a pretty good choice for a typical American pers...
000
David Killoren @davidkilloren.bsky.social · 11/11/2024
eg.typepad.com/eg/2024/11/i...
eg.typepad.com
In praise of wokeism.
I doubt that the movement known variously as wokeism / identity politics / political correctness deserves much of the blame for Trump's victory. But in any case here are some of my current opinions ab...
010