iiinova — where your digital self keeps evolving

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

I’m opposed to premature detailed blueprints for a united Ireland. However I acknowledge that some people are frustrated by the lack of any debate whatsoever on the specifics. My unsolicited thoughts on how pensions ought to operate in a future united Ireland (if and when that ever happens).

000

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

Some public assistance (for example insulating the homes of the elderly, or free transport) reduces pensioners' costs but is not counted as a pension. This makes nation by nation comparisons difficult. Ireland spends less on pensions but its its elderly are also less poor than in the UK.

021

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

The goal of the state pension in Ireland is to reduce pensioner poverty, not to make some pensioners rich. It achieves that goal. Pensioner poverty has decreased over the decades, and whilst some pensioners are still poor, pensioner poverty is less of a problem now than, for example child poverty.

010

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

With this in mind, it would undermine Ireland's pensioner poverty goal for almost two million pensioners to be paid in a different currency and at different rates. It would also undermine unity to have a pensions frontier with pensioners living a few meters apart being treated very differently.

010

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

Nevertheless the UK collected National Insurance contributions from its Northern Ireland workforce throughout their working lives and dispensed promises of future pension entitlement. The UK has a moral obligation to make good those promises.

000

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

My preferred way to deal with this would be for the UK to pay an amount per annum into an escrow account, actuarially adjusted annually to account for NI demographic changes. Ireland can draw from this fund to pay pensions to NI residents, to be paid in Euros, and where possible at Irish rates.

000

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

Northern Ireland has an annual fiscal deficit (subvention) of about £14billion (the exact makeup of imputed spending is debatable). Nevertheless this puts a de-facto ceiling of fiscal and political acceptability on what the UK might reasonably be expected to fund (ie. break-even in the short term).

000

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

Fortunately Northern Ireland pensions and other related benefits amount to £3,738m (2024/2025) so well below that notional ceiling amount defined by the level at which the UK calculates it is already subsidising Northern Ireland.

000

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

Public pensions paid to NI recipients will of course be taxed in Ireland. The amount withdrawn by Ireland from the escrow fund should be net of the average tax deduction for pensioners. This will reduce the UK's £2.738 billion annual bill for NI public pensions obligations even further.

000

bendav.bsky.social @bendav.bsky.social · 10/07/2026

If there is a shortfall, Ireland should make up the difference from its sovereign fund. The UK is not responsible for providing a more generous pension than it promised its NI workers during their working lives. If there is an annual escrow surplus, then some annual rebate may revert to the UK.

000