Sign in

Andy Maciver

@akmaciver.bsky.social
146 followers 8 following 86 posts

Founder/Director of Message Matters 📢 + Wednesdays on Holyrood Sources 🎧 🖥️ + Fridays in The Herald & occasionally in The Spectator 📰 💻

PostsRepliesMedia
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 04/08/2025
@kateforbes.bsky.social’s news is, in my view, simultaneously bleak news for Scottish politics and government, and good news for Kate and her family. Our instantaneous reaction, on @holyroodsources.bsky.social , is streaming now. Geoff Aberdein | @calumam.bsky.social
002
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 25/07/2025
Of course we should welcome Trump to Scotland..... and we should give Turnberry the Open too. My thoughts in today's @heraldscotland 🇺🇸🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Trump Turnberry must host the Open – and Swinney must drive it
John Swinney needs to exploit President Trump’s weak point. The locations of his visit offer the clue about what that is.
011
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 23/07/2025
This week’s @HolyroodSources , streaming now and on video on YouTube: 💨 zonal pricing rural cost/benefit from wind farms 🛣️ infrastructure spending 🇺🇸 Trump in Scotland 🗳️ & the disconnect between parties and people @geoffaberdein | @CalumAM podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/h...
podcasts.apple.com
Zonal Pricing, Trump’s Visit & Why Scotland Can’t Build
Podcast Episode · Holyrood Sources · 23/07/2025 · 45m
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 18/07/2025
The time is right to make independence the settled will, but nationalists will have to perform much better to make it so. My thoughts on today’s @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Ten years to make indy the settled will: Can the SNP do it?
John Swinney and his indispensable deputy Kate Forbes are presented with opportunities that, in their wildest dreams, they never thought they would…
021
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 03/07/2025
Tomorrow’s column today… Labour's reform agenda is over. The rebels are in control | @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Labour's reform agenda is over. The rebels are in control
The Labour rebels are in charge now, and the same people who said no to welfare reform will also say no to healthcare reform
031
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 27/06/2025
“Far from causing moral panic, using private health care in other countries is seen as an act of moral propriety.” My thoughts on healthcare in today’s @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Let's have a conversation about debunking the NHS as a national cult
Using private healthcare in this country is seen as an act of selfishness. A grotesque display of privilege. Two fingers to the little people…
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 20/06/2025
My thoughts in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social on the Scottish Tories woes, and the growing distinction between its urban and rural wings. www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
The Tories are becoming two parties in one. Which one will prevail?
The Tory party in Scotland finds itself in the hottest water it has encountered since devolution began
102
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 13/06/2025
🔴🟡From unthinkable to improbable to inevitable. Why you shouldn't rule out the prospect of a 'grand coalition' between Labour and the SNP, for the same reason it happened in Germany 🇩🇪 and Ireland 🇮🇪. By me in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
A Grand Coalition between SNP and Labour may go from unthinkable to inevitable
Don’t bother publicly asking a politician from our two established mainstream parties about a Grand Coalition. But discuss it with some of them in…
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 11/06/2025
This week’s @holyroodsources.bsky.social ‬⁩, with me and my amigos @calumam.bsky.social ‬⁩ and ⁦‪Geoff Aberdein‬⁩ , and this week @reformukscotland.bsky.social ‘s ‬⁩ Labour 🔴 defector. Plus, the grand coalition is back….. podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/h...
podcasts.apple.com
By-election Aftermath... and Reform UK defector
Podcast Episode · Holyrood Sources · 11/06/2025 · 44m
043
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 06/06/2025
The @heraldscotland.bsky.social has done a brilliant series on the future of Edinburgh this week - here's my contribution on suburbs and transport, and why the rail and the river give us the way forward: www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
I know frustration of commuting from Edinburgh's suburbs by bus. Here's my solution
Growing up in Edinburgh's suburbs, Andy Maciver knows the frustration of commuting into town by bus but he has a solution...
100
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 06/06/2025
🚨 Streaming now from Rome @calumam.bsky.social, a park bench (Geoff Aberdein) and a leisure centre (me), immediate reaction to Labour’s remarkable by election win (and how @anassarwar.bsky.social can justifiably bask ☀️) podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/h...
podcasts.apple.com
Labour WIN Hamilton by-election
Podcast Episode · Holyrood Sources · S4, E27 Bonus · 25m
231
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 30/05/2025
My thoughts in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social on how we can rescue our schools and avoid sleepwalking into a social and economic calamity www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Scotland's educational establishment is betraying our children - and our economy
In maths, reading and science - Scottish children’s scores are continually declining. We are now hovering around average in PISA rankings. If our…
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 17/05/2025
ICYMI, my thoughts in yesterday's @heraldscotland.bsky.social on how the asissted dying debate showed our MSPs at their best, and how they could do it more often www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Our MSPs can be better if we let them
Most of what our lawmakers do on a day-to-day basis is fairly drab. This is not to say it is unimportant, but the issues they tackle and the…
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 30/04/2025
Pleasure to have @adamboulton.bsky.social join us on @holyroodsources.bsky.social today. Streaming now on audio and video Geoff Aberdein | @calumam.bsky.social
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 25/04/2025
End your week with @holyroodsources.bsky.social , the most-listened-to Scottish political podcast. This week, the Supreme Court gender judgment. On audio 🎧 And here on YouTube 🖥️ youtu.be/-_OjvLl_HLI?... @calumam.bsky.social | Geoff Aberdein
youtu.be
What is a Woman? Susan Smith from For Women Scotland on the political reaction to the Supreme Court
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
112
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 25/04/2025
The SNP is likely to need some help after 2026, and it's probably only the Greens or the Lib Dems who can provide it. By me in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Which foes will the SNP become friends with? Greens or Lib Dems?
Who could be a governing partner for the SNP? There are probably only two options.
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 18/04/2025
"We are in Scotland, the Emerald City of politics, where, unlike Elphaba, John Swinney appears not to need a broomstick to defy gravity." @heraldscotland.bsky.social
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 18/04/2025
What would an SNP win in the Hamilton by-election say about Scottish politics? By me in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
An SNP by-election win would defy gravity
Andy Maciver: An SNP by-election win would defy gravity
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 10/04/2025
This week on @holyroodsources.bsky.social with me, Geoff Aberdein & @calumam.bsky.social 🔵➡️🟠 @jamiegreeneuk.bsky.social on his move from the Tories to the Libs & 🟡➡️🔵 Kenny MacAskill on Alba’s prospects at #sp26 📺 Watch it here: youtu.be/PIxk4DoCQ4k?... 🎧 Streaming as usual as a podcast.
youtu.be
What's the Alba party's strategy? Plus, defections | Jamie Greene MSP & Kenny MacAskill
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 07/04/2025
This is why the press is still critical and must be supported. @edinburghuni.bsky.social re-starts funding debate in an op-ed in yesterday's Scotland on Sunday, carrying into @scotsman.com and other titles today, and onto broadcast, and into politics. www.scotsman.com/news/opinion...
scotsman.com
Scotland must act to save universities from economic abyss – Edinburgh University Vice-Chancellor
If dire financial problems facing universities are not confronted, the education system as we know it will perish, says Professor Sir Peter Mathieson
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 05/04/2025
Some thoughts from me on @thespectator1828.bsky.social on @jamiegreeneuk.bsky.social joining @scotlibdems.org.uk Will more Tories defect to the Lib Dems? www.spectator.co.uk/article/will...
spectator.co.uk
Will more Tories defect to the Lib Dems?
Jamie Greene is a one-time Scottish Tory leadership contender who has resigned the Conservative whip and joined the Liberal Democrats.
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 04/04/2025
My thoughts in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social , on how our agreeable mainstream politicians could make a roads revolution the biggest achievement of devolution www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
An A-road revolution would be the highlight of devolution
Hurray, we built a road! The Cross Tay Link Road was opened this week, linking the A9 north of Scone to the A93 and A94, up into Scotland’s north…
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 19/03/2025
This week’s @holyroodsources.bsky.social , streaming now and on YouTube. Today: 🟥 Labour & benefits 🟨 The SNP’s candidates 💨 Aberdeen & energy And in listener questions, one happy customer asks who gave me and Geoff a platform? That would be @calumam.bsky.social … youtu.be/9SGp_Qcn3uk?...
youtu.be
Getting Scotland Working
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
222
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 14/03/2025
This week’s @HolyroodSources, in full on YouTube now ➡️ Sturgeon’s exit 🟨 Swinney’s reshuffle 🟥 Sarwar’s welfare 🥾 Smith’s outdoor ed Also streaming 🎧 @CalumAM | @geoffaberdein | @mspliz youtu.be/ZBetByw6q7w?...
youtu.be
Sturgeon Quits, Labour and Welfare, and Outdoor Education
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 12/03/2025
Bumper @holyroodsources.bsky.social sources coming your way later this afternoon, with me, Geoff Aberdein and @calumam.bsky.social: 🚪 #NicolaSturgeon's exit 💷 Labour's welfare policy 🟡 Scottish Government #reshuffle 🥾 and we're joined by Liz Smith MSP to chat about her outdoor education Bill
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 10/03/2025
I’ll be on Mornings on BBC Radio Scotlasnd shortly, discussing Trident in the Trump era. Tune in! 📻
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 07/03/2025
In today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social @scottishcomment.bsky.social We're underplaying the impact on Scotland of the Trump presidency, on: 💷 our exports 🗳️ our election 💣 our defence Scotland is up to its neck in Trumpland, whether we like it or not www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Scotland is up to its neck in Trumpland, whether we like it or not
There is a fine line between diplomacy and debasement. The hyperactivity of President Trump and the US administration means that diplomacy will…
021
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 06/03/2025
Should the Scottish Tories ignore the Reform threat? By me in @thespectator1828.bsky.social www.spectator.co.uk/article/shou...
spectator.co.uk
Should the Scottish Tories ignore the Reform threat?
What do the Tories do with a problem like Reform? Kemi Badenoch’s party in Westminster has some time to consider this, with over four years to go until it has to put her strategy – whatever that is – ...
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 05/03/2025
My scene-setter for this week's @holyroodsources.bsky.social , with Lt Col Stuart Crawford and @stewartmcdonald.bsky.social , on Scotland's place in Trump's world, here: linkedin.com/posts/andy-m... @calumam.bsky.social | Geoff Aberdein
linkedin.com
Andy Maciver on LinkedIn: Today's Holyrood Sources podcast is all about Scotland's place in Trump's…
Today's Holyrood Sources podcast is all about Scotland's place in Trump's world. We were joined by Lt. Col. Stuart Crawford and Stewart McDonald - please do…
120
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 05/03/2025
This week's @holyroodsources.bsky.social , recording now. What is Scotland's role in Trump's world? Streaming later today... 🎧💻 @calumam.bsky.social | Geoff Aberdein
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 28/02/2025
Scotland - all of Scotland - needs regional mayors based around the city-region growth deals. My thoughts in today's @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
It's not just Glasgow that needs a mayor – we all do
Scottish devolution is a job half done. Decentralising Scotland up, down and out from Edinburgh is important for our governance and politics
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 22/02/2025
ICYMI, my @heraldscotland.bsky.social article from yesterday, on Labour’s chances of government 🌹 www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
If Sarwar wants to be FM, first he must become Mr Scotland
Recent censuses have told us that we are a Scotland-first nation. The most recent told us that almost two-thirds of the country have a Scottish…
201
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 19/02/2025
🌹 A real pleasure to sit with @anassarwar.bsky.social and Jackie Baillie for a full hour today for a @holyroodsources.bsky.social exclusive, with @calumam.bsky.social and Geoff Aberdein 🧵
101
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 16/02/2025
The more I think about the idea of a women's rights party - which @euanmccolm.bsky.social has mooted in @scotsman.com here ⬇️ - the more I think that, with well chosen candidates, it could be the great disruptor of the 2026 election. www.scotsman.com/news/opinion...
scotsman.com
We need a progressive political party to protect women's rights - I'd vote for them
The Sandie Peggie case exposes the lack of progressive, gender critical voices in Scottish politics, writes Euan McColm. He asks who could fill the void.
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 16/02/2025
@jameshansonradio.bsky.social has this dead right. @scaramucci.bsky.social saying similar things across the pond. From @thespectator1828.bsky.social www.spectator.co.uk/article/dona...
spectator.co.uk
Donald Trump is making the same mistake as Neville Chamberlain
It is easy to forget how popular Neville Chamberlain was in the autumn of 1938. Proclaiming ‘peace in our time’ after signing the Munich Agreement, he was heralded as the deal-maker supreme. A leader ...
8266
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 14/02/2025
Today in @heraldscotland.bsky.social - why focusing on the NHS is a risk for John Swinney www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
NHS could bring pain for Swinney. Does he have the stomach for a cure?
What is it that would cause Mr Swinney a problem enormous enough that the SNP could lose 10 points in the polls and hand Labour’s Anas Sarwar the…
111
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 13/02/2025
This week’s @holyroodsources.bsky.social streaming on audio as normal, or here 👇🏻 on YouTube. 🌹 Labour 👩🏻‍⚕️ the NHS 📑 the civil service With me, Geoff Aberdein and @calumam.bsky.social youtu.be/0ZTMovveIew
youtu.be
NHS Crisis, Labour and Change, is the civil service broken? | Q&A
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
142
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 11/02/2025
This is well worth a read, by Euan McColm in @thespectator1828.bsky.social I’d never really thought about the idea of a women’s rights party for 2026 but it’s VERY interesting. t.co/ZlV5ExLl7X
t.co
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-arent-scotlands-politicians-standing-up-for-sandie-peggie/
010
Reposted by Andy Maciver
The Herald @heraldscotland.bsky.social · 07/02/2025
'Independence sentiment in Scotland grows when the unionist alternative is seen to be repulsive' www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie... @akmaciver.bsky.social
051
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 07/02/2025
In today’s @heraldscotland.bsky.social The headline says it all. Have a read for detail! www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
I've changed my mind: Swinney and Forbes could pull off indy
On July 5 last year, when Labour cruised into Downing Street having handsomely won both England and Scotland, I thought independence was dead.…
144
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 05/02/2025
This week’s @holyroodsources.bsky.social recording now… 🌹 Labour and Reform… 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 … and what it means for independence 🏡 The rent caps are going ❓ And your questions. Streaming later 🎧 🖥️ ⁦‪@calumam.bsky.social | Geoff Aberdein
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 27/01/2025
More on this theme this morning www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-...
spectator.co.uk
Why the SNP should form a pact with Labour
Last year, marking the tenth anniversary of Scotland’s independence referendum, I wrote an article for The Spectator looking at the state of Scotland’s political conversation and the prospects for the...
010
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 26/01/2025
ICYMI, my @heraldscotland.bsky.social article from Friday on how the unthinkable SNP/Labour coalition may become thinkable, and may even become normal. With a nod to Germany 🇩🇪 and Ireland🇮🇪. 🟡🔴 t.co/miNkrdj7K8
t.co
https://www.heraldscotland.com/politics/viewpoint/24879511.snp-labour-government-may-not-unthinkable/
001
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 26/01/2025
The full @holyroodsources.bsky.social ep with Anthony @scaramucci.bsky.social in full on YouTube. 🤝🏻 how to deal with Trump & Musk 🍣 🥃 his thoughts on export tariffs 🌍 and his well read and well thought position on America’s role in the world @calumam.bsky.social youtu.be/Ga9Nw95QC9Q
youtu.be
Donald Trump will "hurt" First Minister John Swinney - Scaramucci
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
143
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 17/01/2025
Yes, you read it right.... @heraldscotland.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
I believe your MSP should be paid £150k a year, and here's why
More money for politicians? These spongers. They should be put on the average wage so that they understand what it’s like for the rest of us. Give…
101
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 15/01/2025
Today’s exclusive @HolyroodSources polling podcast, with Sir John Curtice, in full on YouTube now @calumam.bsky.social www.youtube.com/watch?v=89em...
youtube.com
New polling: Reform surge, Labour down, SNP win, coalition Government in 2026
YouTube video by Holyrood Sources
122
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 14/01/2025
Clearly Rachel Reeves was right to go to China, but you can't deny the 'Peking duck' is a great political soundbite. Fair play Mel Stride....
000
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 14/01/2025
Early coverage of @holyroodsources.bsky.social WM poll via @alexofbrown.bsky.social @thescotsmanpaper.bsky.social . When a Westminster government sneezes its Holyrood arm catches a cold. Holyrood poll, and more, tomorrow and at the weekend. @calumam.bsky.social www.scotsman.com/news/politic...
scotsman.com
John Swinney is 'uniting Scots', says SNP as party extends polling lead over Labour
The poll makes grim reading for Anas Sarwar
033
Reposted by Andy Maciver
Donald Anderson @da-anderson.bsky.social · 13/01/2025
Thoughtful as ever Andy. I think HSR to London is more of a priority than a Maglev between Edinburgh and Glasgow, but lots of food for thought there.
011
Andy Maciver @akmaciver.bsky.social · 11/01/2025
ICYMI, yesterday's @heraldscotland.bsky.social column on what the government's #Maglev flirtation says about our infrastructure. With some mentions for Murdo Fraser, @stevenpurcell.bsky.social and @da-anderson.bsky.social www.heraldscotland.com/politics/vie...
heraldscotland.com
Why are we always in the slow lane when it comes to infrastructure?
It is a long time since the Scottish Government could credibly claim to have outlined genuinely ambitious vision on transport infrastructure.
221