This is 100% correct.
Criticize replicability of business-school psychology all you want. Work on rigor and reproducibility.
But be clear that many sorts of science are strong and replicable, and the right has been using “reproducibility crisis” as a lever to attack all of us.
5. If as a community we confuse what is desirable for what is obtainable or if we suggest one might do well to throw out the environmental chemistry baby with the social psychology bathwater, it’s going to be very hard to for good science to withstand Daubert challenges.
That empowers corporations.